Showing posts with label children. Show all posts
Showing posts with label children. Show all posts

Monday, September 15, 2014

Review: A Rule is to Break: A Child's Guide to Anarchy

It is a sad day when you bring home a book called A Rule is to Break: A Child's Guide to Anarchy, and the biggest problem you have with it is how banal and prescriptive it is. I joked when I first heard of this book that my strong-willed adventurer of a seven-year-old must never read it. I still think that, but only because it offers so little to children who are feeling stifled by rules about what to eat, when to sleep, and how to behave.

The authors, john & jana, make a fundamental mistake: their entire book is a series of commands. "Don't look like everybody else. Be you!" "Build it. Don't buy it." "Forget about grocery stores and get dirty in your garden."

My favorite page has got to be the one that says, "No rules!" and then, right next to that, "Be nice!" Isn't "be nice" a rule?

I'm used to the liberals I know engaging in a game that goes, "Be a freethinker! Follow my rules instead!" but I'm discouraged to find anarchists engaging in the same bait-and-switch. I understand that exhortations to garden and build instead of shop are in keeping with anarchist goals not to support capitalism, but these pages could be re-purposed into any of a hundred didactic picture books aimed at the children of progressives, books about taking care of the planet or promoting peace or living more authentically.

As I read A Rule is to Break, I couldn't help answering back to it on practically every page. "Cake! For! Dinner!"? OK, but what if you're really hungry for tofu, or a nice piece of fish? "Stay up all night"? I have two kids who don't like sleepovers because of the pressure to do just that. "No more baths ever"? But what about how good it feels to be clean? "Don't look like everybody else"? But what if you don't care to draw attention to yourself by how you dress or wear your hair?

My kids bristle at being given a series of peremptory commands that might or might not suit them, and this book makes anarchists sound like one more set of grownups who want to boss you around and tell you what to think, even if the second-to-last page of the book does say, "Think for yourself." Too little, too late.

I'd have written a different book. Mine would have said things like:

"Have cake for dinner if you want! Or tofu, or a nice piece of fish! Whatever you're hungry for! Trust your appetite!"

"Bedtimes? Pah! Sleep when you're tired, or four hours after you got tired when you finally finish that book. You can stay up all night and watch the sunrise, or you can get up early and watch the sunrise, or you can never watch the sunrise at all."

"Baths are great if you like soaking in the water or want to get clean! But don't take a bath just because somebody else thinks you should! You can be bath-indepenent and make up your own mind!"

"You can follow a rule if it seems like a good one. But a bad rule wants to be broken."

My mother, for all her many failings, had her moments. And one of her best moments was during high school, when she said to me, "Susan, I wouldn't want you to do a thing just because everyone else is doing it. But not doing something just because everyone else is doing it is just as bad. You're still letting everybody else do your thinking for you." Staying up all night because people want you to go to bed, eating cake for dinner because they want you to eat spaghetti, wearing skinny jeans because everybody else has moved on to boot-cut: that's rebellion, not independent thought. It's an adolescent way to mark yourself as different from the herd. A Rule is to Break is, sadly, more "A Child's Guide to Oppositional Behavior" than a guide to anarchy. I hoped for more. I hoped for a book that might really feel too dangerous to give to my children.

Thursday, November 28, 2013

Won't Someone Think of the Children?

In October, CNN published this pretty good article about a family made up of three adults and their nine-year old daughter. Of course, the responses across the internet ranged from supportive to appalled, and many on toward the "appalled" side of the spectrum purported to be about the writers' concerns over a child being raised in such a family. Some folks assumed that the situation was de facto unhealthy; others saw it as unstable, and wondered what it would do to the girl when her family broke up and the third partner, who is not one of her biological or legal parents, disappeared from her life.

Whenever an unconventional relationship comes up, onlookers always express concern about the children. Whether it's the mixed-race child of a biracial couple, or the black child adopted into a predominantly white family, single women or men becoming parents by choice, lesbians and gay men parenting, or non-monogamous people practicing non-monogamy while raising kids, the same questions come up: Is this good for the child? Won't it be harmful to them? What about the social stigma they'll face? Is this family--whether of gay men or of three people in a partnership or a couple that dates outside the relationship--too inherently unstable to raise children?

This concern is so common that I have even had a polyamorous friend tell me he thought it was wrong for parents to practice polyarmory while raising their children.

I, of course, have several thoughts about this.

Gosh, I Never Thought of That Before

I can't tell you how many people have told me that the Tiny Tornado might change his mind about his gender expression. People somehow believe that the first thought that pops into their heads when they hear about him is something that hasn't occurred to us in all the years we've been living in the situation.

The "what about the kids" questions about polyamory feels similar. Whether people pay due attention to the needs of their kids is independent of whether they're monogamous. Surely you can think of plenty of examples of monogamously married people who think only of their own wants and needs and not of their children's; I was raised by such people, and I'm pretty sure my brother is another such parent. Whether people take good care of their kids' physical and emotional needs is about whether they take good care of their kids' physical and emotional needs, not about whether they do that as a single parent, part of a married couple, as part of a trio, as someone who's been celibate for decades or someone who has a new sexual partner every time the moon is full.

This is why I'm such a fan of the good-faith question. Because I'm perfectly happy to answer those. "How have you dealt with being a parent and being polyamorous," for instance, is a good-faith question, and I can tell you a story to help answer it. "Don't you worry about your kids?" is not a good faith question, because it tells me that you think the answer is "No, I don't. I think only of my own gratification." But that's not how it is.

Last year, I dated a person I'll call Lovely Girlfriend. It was a long-distance relationship that started at a Quaker gathering, and the first time I visited her, we were sitting in her kitchen drinking tea and she said to me, "So, I'd like to talk about breaking up."

"So soon?" I said. "I didn't think we were there yet."

She wasn't dumping me. But she wanted to talk to me about how to be with each other so that if we stopped dating (and we did, about a year later), we could do it well. We both have kids; we like each other's kids, and our kids are friends. At Gatherings, we've done a lot of shared kid-activities and reciprocal child care. We have a lot of friends in common, and a relatively small, tight-knit community of people is an important part of both our lives. Lovely Girlfriend wanted to talk about how we would be with each other so that, whether dating turned out to be a long-term thing or not, we could still care for each other's kids, and we could continue to share our community.

It boiled down to being decent, and honest. And I think we were. Next time we see Lovely Girlfriend and her kids, the children might or might not sense that the relationship between us is different than it was. But her younger kid will still hug me hello (I hope), I'll still be happy to take the whole passel somewhere fun while Lovely Girlfriend fulfills a work commitment, she'll still sit with my younger kids in the cafeteria while I have a committee meeting, and the two of us will still be glad of the moments we can steal to be together in the busyness of a gathering. She'll still be one of my kids' grown-up friends, and mine, too.

Things aren't always that smooth, because people aren't always decent and honest, especially if strong emotions get involved. But that leads me directly to my next point:

My Kids Have Lost Precious Grownups. But It Hasn't Been Anybody I Was Dating

I think people who worry about relationship instability in polyamorous relationships imagine that we're doing something like telling the kids, "Hey, kids, here's Lovely Girlfriend. She's your new Other Mommy. Give Other Mommy a great big kiss!" And then a year later, Other Mommy is gone and the children are bereft.

We haven't done it that way, though. Lovely Girlfriend and I, for instance, were friends before we started dating, and we didn't announce the change to the kids, though they did notice we were visiting each other a lot more. Once when I hung up the phone, Word Boy said, "Was that Lovely Girlfriend?" and I said, "No, it was my doctor. Why?" He said, "Because usually you only answer if it's Lovely Girlfriend." So, you know, they do notice things. But they don't get real-time updates every time a relationship shifts a bit in one direction or another.

I always want to tell people, too, that being monogamous doesn't necessarily protect your kids from these kinds of losses. It hasn't protected mine. Raider used to have a friend, one of his best friends since college, who was very involved with us and our kids for years. She was so close that the kids called her "Aunt Cowrie," and my photo albums are full of pictures of her giving Baby Lego Savant bottles, playing with him, reading books to him, helping him plant flowers. She was the one who saw Word Boy's first steps, hanging out in our living room with him while I cooked dinner, and the turtle-shaped sandbox we recently got rid of was a gift from her.

And then she disappeared. She told Raider that she disapproved of our parenting so strongly that she couldn't bear to stay around and watch us ruin the children. And, just like that, one of the most important people in my kids' lives was gone.

But we still had Farina, one of my best friends, and her family. Now that was a close, stable relationship--a few years ago, Raider commented that our families had become to intertwined he didn't think we could get rid of each other if we tried. We lived about an hour apart, but visited back and forth regularly. For most of a school year, I kept their oldest son two days a week while they were experimenting with homeschooling, but that was OK because he was one of the Lego Savant's best friends. Farina repaired my front door and put new screens in the breezeway windows. I lent her money to buy her first rowing shell, and she lent me money when we were having trouble paying our mortgage during the custody fight with TT's birthfather. We took vacations together. Farina's wife became a good friend in her own right.

And then some problems Farina had with PTSD and depression got worse, and she began to lie to me, and to be verbally abusive. When I tried to talk to her about the situation, she became more entrenched, describing herself as my victim and redoubling her attacks on my character. I ended the relationship, and one more time the kids--and I--lost someone important.

You all probably know, as well, that last Christmas my dad, the kids' only surviving grandparent, disowned me for letting the Tiny Tornado live as a boy. I don't expect to see him again.

My point is, my kids have already suffered the kinds of losses that people worry about when polyamory comes up. But not because I was dating someone. We could have avoided these losses by not having best friends and a dad, but that hardly seems reasonable. (And I don't go around asking people with friends and parents whether they've really thought about the risks.)

Let Me Sum Up

My point, and it seems like such an obvious one that I can't believe I've taken so many words to make it, is that, in some ways, there is nothing special about the relationships you have when you're polyamorous, and the path they take is as varied as the paths taken by monogamous marriages, close friendships, relationships with biological family, dating relationships you have when you're single. As parents, we're making decisions all the time about who is part of our children's lives: whether to take them back to Miserable Small Town for another crappy tension-filled Penn family Thanksgiving, for instance (thank you, Dad, for solving that one for me); whether to introduce them to a certain friend; whether to trust them with that coach or that teacher. We make decisions ourselves about who to trust with our own hearts. Sometimes we get it right; sometimes we get it wrong. Sometimes we get it right and it still goes wrong. Sometimes somebody you thought would be there forever, isn't, and there's nothing you can do about it.

I still trust people. I trust Raider to the ends of the earth. I think we'll be together forever, but I believe that even if we're not, he will always be a great dad and a decent person. I have a girlfriend now that my kids adore, and I trust her with them. I trust her with their hearts. She might break mine, but she'll always take care of theirs.

But what I trust most is myself. I trust me to take good care of my children. I trust me to stand by them. I trust me to get into good relationships, and to get out of bad ones without drama. I trust me to explain things to my kids, as clearly and compassionately as I can, and I trust me to stand by them as they work out any confusion or sadness they feel. I trust me to do these things because I have done these things. I trust them to be smart, loving, emotionally whole, and resiliant, because they have always been these things.

There will always be losses. That is the cost of loving. I hope my kids come to feel, as I do, that the loving is worth it.

Friday, October 25, 2013

Homeschooling Word Boy

It has been a tough couple of weeks for me parenting Word Boy, because of his anxiety. I've handled it really well, but this morning I broke down crying talking to Raider about how I just couldn't face homeschooling. Yesterday was a very challenging day that left both me and Word Boy (and possibly also his therapist) exhausted, and he's doing better today but it's a pretty thin veneer. His perfectionism leads him to have anxiety attacks when he makes a mistake in math or doesn't understand something immediately, and it has been a challenge to me to be disciplined enough to make him do math anyway. A friend who studies behaviorism says that parents are very motivated by negative reinforcement. Negative reinforcement is the removal of an unpleasant stimulus--in other words, when a parent will do anything to avoid dealing with a tantrum, that's negative reinforcement. It's not easy for me to sit down to math with Word Boy when the likelihood is high that I'll have to spend half an hour dealing with an anxiety attack in order to get through what should be 10 minutes worth of math. He's behind grade level in math primarily because I have been negatively reinforced not to do math with him.

I've been doing a good job dealing with his anxiety-fueled behaviors during the last couple of weeks, which have feature not only yesterday's epic two-hour meltdown at the therapist's office but a four-day anxiety attack the other weekend. But I'm worn out. And the idea of trying to do homeschooling with him today when his equilibrium is so fragile just felt like too much.

And, honestly, I don't know why I bother "homeschooling" this kid. He and I decided to go the library, and on the way there, he asked about an errand I ran earlier, to renew the tags on our cars. I ended up explaining vehicle registration as well as automobile and homeowners insurance. He asked about the flood we had in our basement some years ago, which led to a conversation about sump pumps and the water table. From there, he gave me an impressive run-down of the causes and stages of a tsunami, which, like so many things, I have no idea where he picked up.

By this time, we were at the library, where, in a characteristic absent-minded professor slapstick, we had quite a bit of trouble figuring out how to open the unlocked door.

Once we were in, we browsed his favorite section, Juvenile Non-Fiction. He found a book on the Arctic and Antarctic; I found him a book on predictions people in the past have made about the future, which interestingly enough is something he had asked me about recently, so he was pretty thrilled. He found a Calvin & Hobbes collection he hadn't read. I found a book on Ideas that Changed the World that I decided to bring home just in case anybody wanted to look through it, and a book on teeth I bet Word Boy will like eventually. I found a book called Real-Size Animal Babies to show the Tiny Tornado, and then I slipped around to fiction and grabbed some Beverly Cleary for bedtime reading, because TT is all about the chapter books these days.

At this point, Word Boy, who is excessively conscientious, began to be concerned that we were checking out too many books. "Do you know how many things I'm allowed to check out on my card?" I asked him. "Fifty. And you could get your own card, and also check out fifty things. And the Lego Savant could get his own card, and then we could check out..."

"A hundred and fifty things," Word Boy said. "That would be a lot to carry."

He seemed reassured, but said again as we walked toward the circulation desk, "I don't know, it just seems like an awful lot of books." I spotted the librarian, who was just finishing up a conversation, so I hauled him over to her. "Librarian," I said, "This is Word Boy. Word Boy, this is the Librarian."

"Hello, Word Boy," said the Librarian. "It's nice to meet you."

I said, "Word Boy is concerned that we are checking out too many books."

The Librarian looked at him and said, "I don't think there's any such thing."

We ran our stack through the self check-out and hauled it to the car (Word Boy: "I have an idea for a new workout...it involves putting a strap around all of your books and then carrying them around.").In the car on the way home, he started reading about Antarctica, reading aloud little tidbits that interested him. "Did you know that the largest animal that lives on land year-round in Antarctica is a tiny insect? Did you know that there is evidence that Antarctica had a subtropical climate 70 million years ago, suggesting that the land that is now Antarctica used to be located near the equator?"

I kept saying, "I didn't know that. Wow, really? That is interesting." Finally, I said, "Ha, I guess it's your day to homeschool me."

Word Boy said, "Mom, I'm just reading stuff out of a book to you!"

I said, "How do you think I do it most days?"

He's reading in the big recliner now, having dealt with the perennial post-library problem of which book to read first.

I actually bought him a curriculum this year, because with me being in school it was very hard for me to keep up with homeschool planning last year, and things really fell apart somewhere around March. I was willing to pay someone to do my planning for me. It's been a mixed thing. I bought him a fifth-grade curriculum, and much of it is focused around grammar, spelling, and vocabulary lessons he doesn't need, so we don't waste our time on that. He finds the assigned books very interesting, but they're short and he goes through them quickly. This week, to try to address that, I assigned him a book that was supposed to be two weeks' worth of reading. He finished it Monday morning. Over breakfast. And then went on to read the next book, which was supposed to be for the next two weeks. And then read half of a biography of Alexander that is part of his big brother's curriculum and that happened to be in the stack on the table. I wanted to be able to hand the reins over to a curriculum. But this curriculum is not running the show the way I hoped it would. Word Boy's insatiable curiosity and drive for knowledge is. He's a fast horse galloping ahead at full speed; I'm doing my best to keep up; and our curriculum thinks maybe he's ready to learn a genteel trot.

 

Sunday, August 4, 2013

Not Actually a Boy, and Here Are the Reasons Why

When I said the other day that I was going to try to do a post every day in August, I was hoping to pull my daily readership back into the low (very low) triple digits, which is where it lives when I'm posting regularly. And then my article at Friends Journal about the Tiny Tornado's gender history went viral. I don't know how many total hits it's gotten, but nearly over 14,000 people have "liked" it on Facebook, and it's been reblogged and linked to all over the place, including at It Bets Better, which must have given it a big boost.

The article has driven traffic to this blog as well. I got nearly 4000 hits on Friday, though today we're down to a mere 1500 (so far). I figure today's decline marks the end of my fifteen minutes, and I'm trying to accept it with good grace. By tomorrow I'll be a has-been, and by Tuesday, I hope to be poised for a comeback.

The response has been overwhelmingly good, but of course we've had the usual assortment of judgment and ignorance, and one or two actual trolls. A favorite activity for commentators is explaining why the Tiny Tornado could not possibly be a boy. We have heard all of these theories before, and we're going to hear them again. Here's what I think of them as of today.

1. Sexism

This is a common theory. It goes like this: The Tiny Tornado, observing the sexism that is rampant in our culture and recognizing the limited options available for women, decides to be a boy to protect himself and to give himself more opportunities.

Why I love it: A child who is two or three is not imagined to know enough about his internal landscape to express a preference about his own gender expression, but is nonetheless somehow able to analyze and interpret the cultural landscape in a sophisticated way and make a rational decision to maximize his privilege within it.

2. He is emulating his older brothers.

Another popular contender. In this one, the Tiny Tornado is so enamored of his older brothers that he abandons his innate and biological sex and gender in order to be more like them.

Why I love it: The Tiny Tornado, an independent, assertive, confident, fashion-conscious, extroverted athlete who doesn't sit still even when watching TV, is almost nothing like his older brothers. If he were emulating his older brothers, he'd consider extended periods of "alone time" to be essential to his functioning; he'd sit still for hours on end, building with Lego, reading, or playing Minecraft on-line with friends. If he wanted to be like Word Boy, he'd be more interested in dissecting animals than in training them, and if he wanted to be like the Lego Savant, he'd have a passion for history. His older brothers are wonderful kids and well worth emulating. But the Tiny Tornado is a force unto himself.

3. He's never seen a girl playing hockey or wearing an oxford shirt.

In other words, he simply lacks role models for the kind of tomboy he really is.

Why I love it: The theorist imagines that ze knows what the Tiny Tornado has and has not seen, and also that something as minor as a girl playing hockey (which he owns a book about) or wearing an oxford shirt (which he has seen many times on the older girls down the street who dress very well) could shape a person's entire identity. It would be like diverting the mighty Mississippi with a popsicle stick.

3. He doesn't know that being a lesbian is an option.

To be fair, this is actually part of the gender pathway for many gender-variant kids. It is not uncommon, I am told by people who know a lot more than I do about these things, for a kid to approach puberty, begin to feel sexual attractions, become aware of lesbians and gay men through the media, and realize that they can resolve their sense of not-fitting by coming out rather than by transitioning.

Why it doesn't work for the Tiny Tornado: many if not most of our closest friends are in same-sex relationships, including TT's much-loved Uncle Toots, who is practically a third parent to him. In addition, the two women next door, who are the best neighbors in the world and also TT's mentors in the world of dog training, are an affectionate couple who love each other very much and are not exactly conventional in the femininity department.

4. He wore a Spiderman t-shirt the summer he was two, and wanted short hair.

Nobody actually thinks that wearing a Spiderman t-shirt and cutting his hair makes TT a boy. But they think I think it.

Why I love this: Because these people simply don't know us. I identified as a lesbian for much of my adult life, and have a whole string of butch lovers in my past (and maybe not only in my past). If there is one thing I know about women, it's that they can have short hair and shop in the menswear department. In fact, I'd say that one of the things I love about women is that they can have short hair and shop in the menswear department.

Also: although I currently have luxuriant curly hair, this is me in the summer of 2009, holding my newborn nephew. Why did I have that haircut? Because I wanted to. Am I a girl? Yes.

A woman with her hair cut clipper-short holds a baby and looks affectionately at him.
Su Penn, who identifies as a girl, rocks her buzz cut.

5. His parents are unable to imagine anything beyond the gender binary.

I'm being playful in this post, so I won't rant about how people seem to believe that transgender kids somehow have an obligation to be "ungendered" or "bigendered" that their non-trans counterparts don't share. I will say that I do my best to imagine what is beyond the gender binary because people I love live there. And maybe the Tiny Tornado isn't fully aware of the option to be both/and or neither/nor or "other," but he has encountered the possibility. Our kids met a both/and adult who was helping in the children's program at TransHealth, and meeting zer challenged all three of them in ways that we are still having conversations about.

6. His parents are pushing him, deliberately or subconsciously, into a male identity for self-aggrandizement or to further their own political agenda.

Yeah, OK, this one is totally true.

Ha, no. Just kidding. If anything, our love of GLBTQ people (including our own selves) and our sense that we would find it somewhat satisfying if one or more of our kids grew up to be G, L, B, T, and/or Q led us to hold back, to not take steps like suggesting male pronouns or a name change until the Tiny Tornado brought them up or was offered them by other adults, because we didn't want to push him. We were always supportive, I think, but we really forced him to be very clear with us. If you want to know more about just how slow I really was to let go of the bright, sassy girl I was sure he was going to grow into, you might want to read the story of the daisy dress in this post from last August.

I sometimes still feel a little sad when I see a black girl of 6 or 7 or 8, with her hair done up nice in braids and beads, wearing something bold like a purple skirt with red tights, and bossing somebody around. I thought he was going to be that girl. I love boys. I love being the mother of boys. I was going to love my daughter, though, just as much. I wanted that girl, no denying it, and letting her go grieved me, even as I celebrated the emerging little boy.

Wednesday, June 13, 2012

Some Conversations with My Kids

Warning: Self-Satisfied Mommy Blogging.

1.

The kids and I are walking from the ballfield to our car along a narrow edge of grass beside the parking lot. The Lego Savant's hand bumps mine every time it swings back as I walk.

Me: Are you doing that on purpose?

Lego Savant: Doing what? [He grins mischievously.]

Me: We should have named you Alec. For Smart Alec.

Word Boy: What should you have named me?

Me: Um...

Lego Savant: Brain Boy. Um... The Knower, because you know so much.

Me: The Thinker.

The Tiny Tornado: I am The Thinker, too. Because I am always thinking of things. I always have ideas.

Word Boy: I don't really know so much, it's more like I am always asking questions.

Lego Savant: The Questioner. Curiosity Man!

2.

Word Boy reads in his bunk bed until I get the Tiny Tornado settled, and then I go in to tuck him in. He says, "I like my bunk bed. I like my room." He looks around the room, and then says, "Hey, are the blades on the ceiling fan tilted on purpose, or did something happen to them?"

Me: It's on purpose so they push the air better.

Him: Are all fans like that?

Me: Yeah, pretty much. And propellers.

Him: Huh, I didn't know that. I guess I thought they would just be straight. How did they make them that way? Do they twist?

I inspect the fan: No, the blades themselves are straight, but the things that hold them on are made so that they hold them at an angle.

Him: Ah.

He collects his five special stuffed friends and gathers them into his arms while I climb onto a stool and turn the tangled ball of covers back into a sheet and a blanket. He lies down, all five friends in his arms. I cover him up. He rolls on his side, tugs the blanket up under his chin, and closes his eyes. He gets the same supremely contented look that he has gotten every day of his life when he feels cozy and safe. And then he is asleep.

3.

We are at the park, me and my three kids and a 4-year-old friend ("The Boy With the Beautiful Smile," maybe. Accurate, but too long. I'll have to keep thinking). The Lego Savant is pushing the other three on the tire swing. He gets them really going, then sits beside me on the bench to watch them spin. They are hanging their heads backwards and laughing and laughing.

The Lego Savant: I love making little kids happy.

4. One night, at a Chinese restaurant in Philadelphia, the Lego Savant keeps finding water chestnuts on his plate even though they aren't part of his dish. The Tiny Tornado is sneaking them on there, it turns out, because he knows how much the Lego Savant likes them.

5. That's it. Mostly I just wanted to try out this new blogging software for the iPad.

6. Smug, self-satisfied mommy blogging? Don't say you weren't warned.
 

Tuesday, May 15, 2012

The Child You Don't Want

I have had a cold since Friday afternoon. I spent most of the weekend in my big chair, while David and the kids brought me tea and the like. It hasn't been a bad cold, but because of a persistent cough, I wasn't able to sleep more than about an hour at a time, with hours of late-night TV in between. Last night, desperate to get some rest, I took a vicodin, and slept for about 6 hours.

Today, I felt more energetic, because of the sleep, but also kind of off and flaky because of the drug hangover. Or because of the combination of the drug hangover and the cold. Or something.

Anyway, many things happened today to remind me that I was not at my best. I loaded the dishwasher but discovered hours later I hadn't turned it on. I went to Hobby Lobby with a short list of supplies I needed for my next arigurumi project. In the parking lot, I spontaneously decided it was a good time to clean out some tissues and napkins and random bits of paper that had accummulated in the front seat and floor of my van. Only after I'd shoved the mess into a reeking garbage bin outside the store did I realize that I'd managed to crumple up my shopping list and toss it in there, too. I did OK, though I bought the wrong size crochet hook, and tomorrow I'll have to go back for one more skein of yarn.

And then, I took Word Boy and the Tiny Tornado to the bookstore after preschool, and it was only after we were out of the car and starting to walk toward the store that I realized I'd left the van running. I haven't done that since early in Word Boy's life, when I was seriously sleep-deprived from his round-the-clock nursing schedule. That time, I left it in gear, too, and it slowly drove itself into the garage door with Word Boy inside it.

My brain remains fuzzy and fragmented. And yet! I have resolved to write every day, so I will write something.

At the Festival of Faith & Writing, I heard Amy Julia Becker talk about her recent book, A Good and Perfect Gift. It's a momoir, in this case about Becker's daughter Penny, who was diagnosed with Down Syndrome shortly after birth. Becker was an excellent speaker. One of the things I like about the FFW is the opportunity it gives me to hear from people whose beliefs are very different from my own but who are thoughtful and self-aware. Becker is pro-life, and one of her concerns is the high rate of abortion of babies with Down Syndrome; she said that just over 50% of babies who are diagnosed with Down Syndrome are aborted now. She also talked about some recently-developed blood tests that can allow the detection of chromosomal abnormalities early in pregnancy and without risky and invasive procedures like amniocentesis, which she expects to increase that percentage.

If everyone who was pro-life were like Becker, though, we'd have a very different conversation about abortion taking place in America. During the Q&A, an audience member asked, with great intensity, "What do you do if you encounter a woman who is thinking of aborting her baby with Down Syndrome?" Her tone suggested to me that what she really wanted to know was how to stop her.

Becker said that she thinks many families fear having a baby with Down Syndrome because they don't have a good understanding of what these children are likely to be like, what they might be capable of, what good qualities they are likely to have. She thinks it's too bad that most people probably don't know any families with Down Syndrome kids, that they don't have a model of what is both positive and challenging about raising these kids. So, she said, if the woman is open to it, you might offer her some information, or some opportunities to meet some families raising Down Syndrome kids. She thinks that if more people knew more about Down Syndrome, they'd be more willing to raise these kids.

But, she said, the most important thing is to be compassionate, because this woman is disappointed, and probably frightened, and facing a hard choice. And, she said, ultimately, you have to respect that it is her choice to make, and refrain from judgment or any words or actions that will add to her burden.

Well. Rock on, Amy Julia Becker.

In her response to another question--I don't remember the question--Becker said that someone had told her once thats having a child born with an obvious disability is not that different from having any old ordinary baby. "You just find out that much sooner that you got the child you didn't want."

Every parent in the audience chuckled and nodded knowingly.

I think most parents have to deal, at some point, and to a greater or lesser extent, with figuring out that there is something they were hoping for from parenting that they're not going to get. My friend Farina Endfen is a tough, authority-defying, mess-loving type of person. She looked forward to mucking through swamps with her son, catching frogs and lizards, and looking under logs for crawly things. Her son, it turns out, doesn't so much care to be outside, or to get messy that way. In the realm of parental disappointments, this is a small one. But it requires mindfulness to negotiate nonetheless--the awareness that your child is an autonomous person and not your pet or your doll, the willingness to accept the differences between you, to support your kid in being the kid he is, to manage your own disappointments, large or small, and not expect your child to carry that burden for you.

David and I sometimes joke that parenting the Tiny Tornado is a great blessing because she completely strips away any illusion we might have had that we were in control, that we could "instill" our children with certain virtues or interests. I remember saying to my friend Carolyn, back when the Tornado was maybe 2, that I was having to learn a whole new parenting style with her. Carolyn said, "Detachment?" And she was right.

Today I was reminded--not that I needed to be--that you don't always get what you want. I have this vision of what it is like to take kids to the bookstore; they browse contentedly, they choose a book or two, we pay our bill, they start reading in the car on the way home. Because I love books and I want my kids to love them, too.

Some of this happens. They choose books; we pay for them; they start reading on the way home. Recently the Lego Savant has begun tearing through a series of novels, staying up late to read, spending the whole of a day caught up in a book. I'd have been perfectly happy with him if this had never happened--but I'm glad it did. I hoped I would have at least one kid who was, at least some of the time, a voracious reader.

But bookstore trips never go the way I picture them in my mind. The Lego Savant didn't come to the bookstore with us; he knew exactly what books he wanted (#8 and #9 in the Ranger's Apprentice series, and he was happy to have me pick them up for him). Word Boy wanted a manga, either a Warriors graphic novel or a Legend of Zelda book. The store was sold out of most of the Warriors graphic novels, but he hadn't read the one they had in stock, so he chose that.

The problem started when the Tiny Tornado chose the same book.

Obviously, she can't read it. But she loves to look at the pictures and make up her own story about what's happening, and she loves to have the same kinds of books her older brothers do. It gives her tremendous pleasure. And my philosophy of book selection is that kids should pretty much be able to choose whatever book they want; we will steer them away from books that have content we think might be uncomfortable for them (no suspense novels for the Lego Savant!) and if they ever headed for something I thought was truly inappropriate, I'd steer them elsewhere. But I'm not going to say nay just because she chose a book she can't actually read yet.

Anyway, Word Boy fell to pieces. He had been sitting on a couch in the kids' area, reading his book and waiting for us to make up our minds, and when he saw what the Tiny Tornado had chosen, he had a fit. He went boneless, and fell onto the couch. He began to shudder and "huff"--breathing rapidly and making little noises. It's an anxiety attack.

Why? Several reasons:

1. He did not want the Tiny Tornado to choose the same book he did, because that makes it not special

2. It is #3 in a series and she had not "read" #1 or #2; reading the books in order is very important.

3. She can't even read it!

4. If she just wants to look at the pictures, the Zelda manga have much better illustrations for that.

5. The Lego Savant might try to get her to give him the book, and she might agree, and sthen she might change her mind and then there might be a big fight (this is such a typical scenario that I told her I would buy her that book on the condition that she under no circumstances give it away to her older brother).

How do I handle this kind of thing? I said, "No. You can't do that here. If you can pull yourself together to walk to the checkout, I will buy that book for you. If you can't behave appropriately, I will put that book back on the shelf."

He huffed and shuddered and whined.

I said, "The Tiny Tornado and I are going to the checkout. If you can pull yourself together to come with us, I will buy the book."

And so the Tiny Tornado and I headed to the checkout, and after a moment Word Boy got off the couch and followed along.

As we walked to the car, he said, "I really felt like everything was going to be horrible, but it's not really horrible at all."

I said, "Yes. Your anxiety likes to tell you those kinds of lies. But usually the horrible thing doesn't happen, and if it does, it's not as horrible as you expected, and even if it's pretty bad, you often find out that you can deal with it."

It's very draining, even now that I've learned that not engaging is the fastest route to the end of the fit, and am not letting myself be sucked into it with him. It would only have been worse if the Lego Savant had been there, because he gets embarrassed when Word Boy does this kind of thing in public and jumps into his own anxiety-management mode, which is the effort to control everything around him, starting with Word Boy, and then to use his dissatisfaction with the present moment as a jumping-off point to complain about everything that bothers him about his siblings, me, our home, our yard, his life.

It's extra-hard when their issues feed on each other. You should see them some days, doing seatwork at the dining room table. The Lego Savant has aversions to many sounds and smells, and depending on his general mood and how strained his resources have been, he can be driven mad by Word Boy's breathing or the scratch of his pencil. But, in typical Lego Savant fashion--"flexible" not being a word one would readily apply to him--he will refuse such obvious solutions as taking himself to work in his bedroom. Meanwhile, the Lego Savant likes to talk quietly to himeself as he works, especially when he's solving math problems, and this drives Word Boy crazy because it can be challengings trying to solve your own math problem when someone is sitting across from you muttering, "5 and 8 is 13, carry the one, so that's 60, 63, OK..."

I have been known, on occasion, to point out to them that if they were in school, they'd be in a room of 20-30 kids, all of whom would be breathing, many of whom would have scratchy pencils, some of whom would be congested and making gross sniffling noises, and that they themselves would be discouraged from muttering, from drawing little monsters in the margins of their math workbooks, from getting up for a snack to help them concentrate ("Mom! Why does he have to crunch like that?"). It falls on deaf ears; they both want the problems between them to be solved by the other one changing his behavior. I have made little headway in getting them to see the options that are available to them in terms of modifying their own behavior.

I didn't mean to sound whiny. This is all one of the pieces that's hard, a problem I continue to delude myself that I should be able to solve. If I could just open their brains and pour in what has taken me decades to learn about living with and managing anxiety and inflexibility and sensitivity! I want it to be easier for them than it was for me, and I want it to be easier for them than it is. I always thought that if I were the right kind of parent, it would be.

Thursday, August 26, 2010

Social Class, Female Solidarity, and the Child Welfare System

In the Baltimore Law Review, Chris Gottlieb, a lawyer who represents parents who have been accused of abuse or neglect, talks about the child welfare system, the rights of parents, and why women with privilege should feel more solidarity with those whose parental rights are challenged.

(Adapted, shorter, non-pdf version in the New York Times here.)

I'm only about halfway through and am already kind of goggle-eyed at the analysis she's making and what she has to say about the child welfare system. Some quotes:

In advising my clients, I frequently tell them that the single most important factor in whether they will be able to keep their children (keep their children!) is how well they get along with the caseworker. You've seen the pictures of the burnt and beaten children who have suffered at the hands of abusive parents, some ending up dead. Those are the children whose stories motivated our child welfare system and continue to fuel efforts to be more protective of children. Yet, as almost anyone working in the field will tell you, those instances of severe abuse, which garner all the attention in the media, are unrepresentative of the cases that clog the system.

Most children in foster care simply are not there because of child abuse. In most cases abuse is never even alleged. Neglect is the charge and neglect is broadly construed. It entails everything from having a dirty or run-down house, to refusing special education or recommended psychotropic medications, to corporal punishment, to smoking marijuana. In other words, neglect includes many things that reasonable people have very different ideas about. Indeed, it includes many behaviors that my yuppie friends and I engage in without threat of government intervention. (pp. 378-9)

And this:

But these cases are often viewed by the caseworkers and judges not as being about material, economic problems, but as being about parenting ability. The parent who "chose" to leave her ten-year-old alone while she went to work is deemed to have such bad parenting judgment that she may not be trusted to keep her child safe under any circumstances. Of course, a mother who leaves a child home because otherwise she will lose her job and means of supporting that child was choosing between two bad options. She may have made the wrong decision (though, of course, this is one of the many parenting questions on which contradictory views are held), but she may be an excellent parent. She certainly is a parent who could be given better options. Similarly, the mother who "chooses" to let her child live in sub-standard housing may not be taking every step another parent would to address the situation, but that doesn't mean she's unworthy to be a parent (whatever "worthy to be a parent" might mean.) It surely does not mean her children must be better off without her.

Acting as if these cases are about parental judgment is dangerous and ultimately bad for the kids involved. None of us would pass the test of always exercising the best possible judgment when parenting. It's just that some of us have luxuries that mean our bad choices don't have to be between two really bad options (and our choices, whether good or bad, are far less likely to be seen by government officials). (p. 381)

And this:

The point is not that rich, white kids are never abused, and certainly not that we should be less concerned about the poor and minority children who are. The point is that, just as when there is any severe discrepancy in how rich and poor or black and white are treated, we should question what is underlying the disparity. Clearly, we are far more willing to allow government officials to judge the parenting of poor and minority parents. We have allowed, indeed encouraged, government officials to be judgmental of certain--but only certain--parents. With respect to these disadvantaged groups, rather than limiting intrusion into family life to the relatively rare extreme cases of parental behavior that are truly beyond the pale, we have invited the government to engage in an endless game of "What is wrong with that mother?" As any mother knows, this is a game no mother can win. (p. 382)

And this:

Even when mistakes are caught and unnecessary separations ended, those children can never again have what we like to believe is the birthright of all children: a feeling of security that their parents will always be there for them, that their parents have some power to control an otherwise scary world. We take that away when we act as though parents are so great a threat to their children that it should be easy for government workers to come between them. (p. 385)


It's very much worth a read.

Friday, June 25, 2010

Understanding Normal

My Facebook status this morning was: I feel so sorry for the mothers of only children. They'll never experience the joys of the extended, passionate, knock-down, drag-out fight over a toy nobody had previously touched for six months.

A friend commented that mothers who are only children will never understand such fights. Which reminded me of something I've been thinking about lately: David's and my efforts to understand what's normal when it comes to kids fighting.

David was an only child. I have an older brother, and for most of my childhood our relationship was so terrible that for, for awhile in my 20s, I actually considered myself to have been abused (I have a much more nuanced view of things now, and a lot of respect and affection for the man my brother is, but growing up in the same house with him was such a crap experience that when he left for college, I felt like I was being let out of prison. [Second parenthetical: apparently growing up as my sibling was no bed of roses, either. I just want to be clear that I'm not trashing my brother here.]).

My brother and I, in our mid-to-late 40s, have only in the last couple of years tentatively begun to have a relationship that goes beyond showing up at our parents' house at the same time twice a year on major holidays. Because of the way my relationship with him played out, I have never quite believed it when people told me, "My sister and I fought like cats and dogs the whole time we were growing up, but now we're the best of friends." I have always thought one of two things:

1. This person does not really understand what it means to "fight like cats and dogs," and did not in fact do it with her sister. Or,

2. They're not actually best friends.

So, because of David's lack of experience with siblings, and because of my bad experience with my sibling, we are at a loss when the kids fight (and my buttons are pushed big-time, especially if Eric does something that leverages his bigness and older-ness).

You can imagine, then, how tremendously helpful it was to me to read recently a report of a study that followed siblings through childhood into young adulthood, and tried to understand the factors that led to good or bad adult relationships. One finding was that all the siblings fought, to more or less the same degree. What made the biggest difference in predicting the quality of their adult relationships was what they were doing when they weren't fighting. Siblings who ignored each and spent time apart when not fighting tended to grow up to be estranged, like my brother and me. But siblings who had positive experiences together when not fighting grew up to be close, like my hypothetical "you" and her hypothetical sister.

I now believe you when you tell me that you fought with your sister but are best friends now. Because I'm guessing that when you weren't fighting with your sister, you were spending at least some time hanging out with her having a good time.

I'm also pretty sure, too, that my kids are doing OK. This morning's knock-down drag-out between Carl and Yehva, for instance, was followed by a half-hour or so of cheerful quiet pretend play together. A balm to the motherly heart.

That study reminded me of some of the findings in Meaningful Differences in the Everyday Experiences of Young American Children, a book that, first, you have to respect for having the most straightforwardly descriptive title of the 20th century. You're probably familiar with some of the study's findings even if you haven't read the book; it's the source of the datum that children of professionals hear 5-8 million more words in the first three years of life than children of working class parents or of parents receiving welfare benefits, which I still see cited all the time, and which has led educators to really wrestle with the question of what kinds of interventions, if any, can make up for the deficits even preschoolers can bring with them to school.

But another piece of info I carried away with me from reading it a few years ago is that all of the children heard "No" and its variants--"Don't touch that," "get down from there," "come away from that"--at roughly the same level. But one of the class-based differences researchers found is that for working-class and welfare kids, that's often the vast majority or even the only speech directed at them by parents, whereas the children of professionals also heard a great many positive statements--"I see you," "Good job," "Go ahead, try it," "Wow, I like that picture."

Both of these findings--about siblings fighting, about saying No to children-- have helped me as a parent to relax about the moments when things aren't as smooth and good as I wish they were, either between the kids or between me and the kids, by reminding me that these moments exist within a greater context that makes a world of difference.

Oh, man, I would so much rather keep writing, which I am really in the mood for, than put laundry in the dryer, load the dishwasher, update the checkbook, call the vet, and take the kids grocery shopping. I have a blog post in my head about my upcoming chore of writing the annual letter to Yehva's birthmother, and another one about something else I forget right now but that will come back to me [Edited: I remember! It's about portrayals of adoptive parents in the media]. Also, the parrots remind me I have not fed them breakfast.

On the one hand, if I didn't have the kids, I could write as much as I wanted. On the other hand, if I didn't have the kids, what would I write about?