Showing posts with label Quakerism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Quakerism. Show all posts

Saturday, July 20, 2013

Sex, Birth, and Singing Alto in the Sacred Harp

My partner Raider is an extraordinary lover. When we were first together, he would take me to bed with no thought but my pleasure. He spent weeks and months exploring my body and listening to what it told him. In quiet persuasive whispers he got me to give up all the secret wishes I'd been harboring, and then he made them come true. He was like a guide leading me into my dark secret places, and sex with him was like psychoanalysis, spiritual revelation, deep epiphany. Every time. I could tell you about the orgasms I had with him, and how they started deep in my body, centered in my womb, and spread out from there, pulling all my muscles into one great clenched fist, and then letting go. I've always thought I was so good at giving birth because he helped me find the muscles in my deep core, got me acquainted with the iron earth. But after awhile, I didn't always want to have sex with Raider. Nobody wants to have a life-changing experience every time they go to bed; who can stand to be that in touch with her deepest parts, bodily and spiritually, day after day? Sometimes you need a break. So we had to learn to have sex that was merely very good, that was satisfying but didn't leave me drenched and mind-blown, that didn't have me staggering through the next few days, dazed and happy but unable to balance my checkbook or safely drive a car.

This is exactly why, although singing alto in the Sacred Harp is one of the things I love best, I don't do it at every opportunity. There's a local singing twice a month, but I only go occasionally. There's a larger one two hours away; I make it once or twice a year. I love the Sacred Harp, but I don't trust it. It's too powerful. Singing the Sacred Harp reminds me of the time I was bodysurfing in big waves in Hawaii and got tumbled about when I missed my timing; I made it to the beach safe and sound, but when I stood up in the shallows, the water had taken my swimsuit off.

Mary Rose O'Reilley says in The Barn at the End of the World that the six elements of a Sacred Harp alto are rage, darkness, motherhood, earth, malice, and sex. The trebles, by contrast, "sing a descant line composed of ecstasy, light, purity, jet contrails, and self-surrender." O'Reilley isn't wrong, except about the malice, perhaps--she seems to have encountered a meaner and more self-interested brand of alto than I have. The altos tend to take the grounding line, the steady drone that keeps a song on the earth. We tend to sing the notes that give the harmonies their rough edge, and we do it sometimes by staying still while the other three parts move around us. Sometimes the altos are holding a steady, solid note and the music shifts around us and I hear a buzzsaw digging into lumber, I see the invisible whirling blade that, one time, took off the end of my father's thumb, I taste the sudden spurt of blood.

Singing alto in the sacred harp isn't for the dainty or squeamish. It's loud and raw. It helps to have had some really good sex, or to have given birth a time or two without anesthesia, to know where the womb is with its hidden muscles, the strongest in the body, some say, but locked away and not for you to command. Singing Sacred Harp has something in common with sex and birthing: all three are done better if you can set aside self-consciousness, modesty, and concerns for propriety, if you're willing to lay it all out there.

It helps, too, to have grieved a time or two. You can see that right in the music, that it was created and sung by people for whom death was always present. The Sacred Harp birthday song goes like this:
Youth, like the spring, will soon be gone, by fleeting time or conquering death.
Your morning sun may set at noon, and leave you ever in the dark.
Your sparkling eyes and blooming cheeks must wither like the blasted rose.
The coffin, earth, and winding sheet will soon your active limbs enclose,
Will soon your active limbs enclose. (Morning Sun, 436)

We sing it as a joke, but the people who originated this music weren't making fun of death. They were living side-by-side with it.

That's one of the dangerous things about the Sacred Harp, to my mind: the way you take on someone else's religion for a few hours or a couple of days at a time, belting it full-out like you're a believer, too. I always feel, when I sing, like I'm pushing at an invisible membrane between me and some woman not that different from me, who sang this music a hundred and fifty years ago, who struggled with her husband to make a go of a farm with poor soil, who had buried a baby, say, as well as two kids at once the year cholera came through. A woman who carried all of the hard work of her days, all of her losses and disappointments, to church with her, whose church was her only consolation.

Sacred Harp was a teaching tradition, originally, and we still call a short sing a lesson, an all-day sing a school, and a group of singers a class. It's not just the music we're being schooled in, though; it's the lives and faith of the original singers, the times they lived in, the God they worshipped.

Mary Rose O'Reilley writes, "The trebles have by now burst the bounds of earth. They will all call in sick on Monday." She writes, "The singing over, we drop like birds who have been buffeted to the edge of the oxygen zone. We have barely escaped with our lives." And that's the thing, that's the answer to why I don't show up twice a month at my local singing and drive two hours every month to the singing in Kalamazoo, why I go to only some of the conventions, and often for only one day. It's not just to save my voice, though that gets raw enough after awhile. It's to save my life, the life I'm living now and love, the one I could lose if that membrane ever ruptures and I'm not just getting a view of another life, another faith, but dropped into the middle of it. I don't want to find myself face-to-face with the God of that gray woman; I like the God I have, so much friendlier, more loving, less capricious. The God I have lets me keep the things I love best.

I walk away from a Sacred Harp singing sweaty, hoarse, wrung-out, and with a sense of having narrowly escaped being turned into something else, someone else. It's a good thing there's not an altar call in the afternoon, in place of the Memorial Lesson, or after four hours of singing to God with my whole heart, I'd be on my knees in the center of the square, accepting Jesus as my personal savior.
Convicted as a sinner, to Jesus I come,
Informed by the gospel for such there is room.
O'erwhelmed with sorrows for sin I will cry,
Lead me to the rock that is higher than I. (The Rock That is Higher Than I, 496)
It's like a kind of Russian roulette, every time I sing. I never know when the hammer will come down and boom! I'l be on the other side of a change I can't easily come back from. I carry my songbook into the square and settle myself in the second row of altos. Today, I have decided, I'll take my chances.

Friday, July 20, 2012

The Grab-Bag & The New Normal

Raider likes to make fun of my handwriting on grocery lists, and sometimes it irks me. And then I come upon something I can't for the life of me read, and I have to admit he's not just imagining things. For instance, in the "For my blog" section of my notebook, I find something that looks for all the world like, "hairy ban gars nee dry a hamcat."

 

I'm sure it's actually about someone or something needing a haircut. But that rings no bells at all.

I'm in the mood to write something that will make people say, "Oh, ha ha Su Penn you are so very funny." But the chickens in my brain are not laying funny eggs at the moment.

I'll take a moment to explain that image. When I was at the Festival of Faith & Writing, somebody asked a panel of writers the classic question about where they get their ideas. One woman--I don't remember which one, a poet. Anyway, she said that she thinks of it like she has a chicken in her brain, pecking around and laying eggs. And every now and then the chicken lays a good one.

My own image is more like I have a big sack in my brain, and sometimes things fall in there, and sometimes I toss things in there. And every now and then, when I root around in the sack, there's something worth pulling out and showing people. Or a couple of the things in there have combined in a new way, and that's worth showing people. Or something in the sack starts to feel heavy, and I have to unload it because I'm tired of carrying it. Or every now and then, something in the sack comes to life and demands my attention.

But I like the chicken image, too.

I actually had a sack-related issue come up at the Gathering the other week. On Wednesday night, I found myself thinking that I was having a really good gathering, but that somehow it just hadn't tipped over into being one of the truly great ones. I decided that the problem was probably that I wasn't getting enough worship. Because I was working at the info desk, I wasn't doing a morning workshop, and my experience is that even if the workshop doesn't include a lot of worship per se, it often feels quite worshipful nonetheless. I had also missed two out of three afternoons of FLGBTQC worship, one from working and one, IIRC, from going to the beach.

So I decided that the solution was to make sure to get to worship on Thursday and Friday.

Accordingly, on Thursday I herded the kids to FLGBTQC childcare and planted my butt in a comfy chair in the beautiful room we had been assigned for afternoon worship. All around me, people were settling into the silence. They seemed peaceful and centered. Few fidgeted. Eventually some vocal ministry was offered. It seemed to speak to people; there were nods and the occasional quiet tear.

None of it reached me. I couldn't center at all. I was restless and fidgety. I wished I had my crocheting to help settle my mind. I didn't feel like I was in worship at all.

Eventually, I decided to peek into my Vocal Ministry Grab Bag--it's right next to the Writing Grab Bag, very handy. And there was nothing in there. Nothing at all.

It's not that I expected to find something I could offer as ministry. You can't open up the grab bag from such an unsettled place as I was and expect to find a little avatar of God holding up a shiny apple and saying, "Give them this!" But I did expect to find something I could think about, meditate on, use to center.

Nothing.

Now, you have to understand that my bags always having something in them: dust, some mice, a peach pit, a faded photograph, a half-remembered Bible verse, a story somebody told me one time. If there's one thing I'm good at, it's generating ideas, and borrowing ideas, and stealing notions, and having thoughts that I want to hold onto in case they're ever useful. The Vocal Ministry grab bag is very like the Writing grab bag--there are odds and ends in there, bits and pieces that are not much in and of themselves. But some of them are seeds that grow, or broken pieces waiting for their other half, or gems that just need the cruft knocked off. Sure, plenty of what's in there is chaff ("What if God is like a Big Mac, and Quakerism is like the sesame seeds on the bun?"), but if you toss enough stuff in there, and let it ferment, and stir it around a bit from time to time, some of it becomes something worthwhile.

You might also know that, prior to leaving my Quaker meeting last November, I had spent more than a year seriously considering, along with friends and elders and clearness committees and prayerful prayer and the whole shebang, the possibility that I had a leading to preach.

So, I've tended to carry around a pretty full Bag of Holding. Sometimes I have pulled something out of there prematurely, I admit it. Sometimes a good story I thought would connect to something deeper turned out to be just a good story; sometimes a fragment I thought had found its mate hadn't. Sometimes it's hard to know for sure what is junk and what is a jewel.

But the bag has never been empty.

Until Thursday, July 5, 2012, at about 5:10 p.m. Eastern Daylight Time, when I decided to root around in the bag. And there was absolutely nothing in it.

I was stunned. I was confused. I was disoriented.

Section 48 of "Song of Myself" can fairly be described as my statement of faith. I won't quote the whole thing to you, though you can find it here, but the last three lines say everything about my experience of God's universal presence and abundance and generous voice:

I find letters from God dropt in the street, and every one is sign'd by God's name,
And I leave them where they are, for I know that wheresoe'er I go,
Others will punctually come for ever and ever.


When my bag turned out to be empty in worship, I knew that I had been wrong about this. That other letters had not punctually come for ever and ever.

God, I thought to myself, has stopped speaking to me.

I needed, right then, an hour or so alone in a quiet and cool place to let the feelings I was having, the despair I felt, wash over me and subside a little. But, of course, I had no hour, no quiet, no cool. With a friend's help, I fetched the younger kids from child care. I took them to the cafeteria for dinner. I tried to hold it together, the way moms do, to keep the emotions at bay until I could have some time and solitude. But, I couldn't. So I handed the kids over to their older brother and his friends, sat down in the quiet dining section, carefully set my glasses on the table, put my hands over my face, and wept.

Eventually, I got up and washed my face. I accepted some expressions of concern, a couple of hugs, a protestation of love. I joined my kids for dinner. I hung out at the rocky stream with them for a little while. I dropped them at their Junior Gathering groups. And I headed over to the student union for my evening work shift at the Information Table.

I was happy to see that my co-worker was my friend Sue, whom I don't get to see often enough. She asked how I was and I acknowledged that I'd been better. She asked if I wanted to talk about it, and I said, "I don't know. I hardly see you, I'm not sure that's how I want to spend this short time with you."

Sue said, "Would you rather I be able to tell people, Hey, I saw Su Penn for the first time in two years, and we made twenty minutes of nice small talk?"

She had a point. I sang like a canary.

She asked me, "Is that how you know that God is speaking to you? By offering vocal ministry? Because I hardly ever offer vocal ministry." And we went on to talk about other ways of experiencing God. And, later in the evening, I got to talk a little more about it with my friend Shani.

I felt a little better. Not a lot. Still pretty unsure. I was curious to see what happened in Friday's meeting for worship. Which is that I fell asleep and woke feeling rested and refreshed. Not the best worship I'd ever had, but certainly not the worst. Entirely inconclusive on the question of whether God was still dropping odds and ends into my bag.

I shouldn't really be surprised by this change. Right now in my life, I shouldn't be surprised by any change. Last fall was a singularity in my life, there's a Before and an After and you can't predict the After from what happened Before. Two things mark this singularity: the beginning of my treatment for chronic headaches with my new neurologist, and laying down my membership in my monthly meeting.

The headache thing is surprisingly far-reaching. Not only have my headaches improved dramatically and my sensitivity to fragrances and chemicals declined, but my mood has improved. One of the medications I take for my chronic daily headache is Effexor. It's an anti-depressant. Taking it solved the problems I was having with severe mood swings before my periods. It has also caused me to be in a good mood for longer than I have ever been in a good mood before. I think I've talked about this before. Cheerfulness is apparrently, for me, a side effect of my headache meds.

The last couple of visits with my neurologist, I've expressed concern that the Effexor was flattening my emotional reactions, that my mood was too good. My main reason for thinking this is that there are many times when I would normally expect myself to cry, but I don't cry. My neurologist, taking me at my word, has been tweaking my meds.

My therapist, when I saw her for my monthly check-in, was more skeptical. "Can you cry at all?" she asked me.

"Yes," I said. "Just last week I read a book about two terminally ill teenagers who fall in love, and cried like a baby at the end."

"Hmmm," she said.

The upshot is that it's entirely possible that what I'm experiencing is perfectly normal. My therapist isn't so sure I need my meds tweaked. She thinks I might just need time to get used to my New Normal. I've been through this before, the first time I had effective treatment for my anxiety. I had to learn the names for all kinds of new emotions I was having instead of panic and fear. I had to learn to live without the constant heightened drama that comes from always being on the edge of freaking out.

Leaving my Friends meeting changed a lot, too. For one thing, it freed all the energy I had been devoting to trying to fix that relationship; like any breakup, once I finally made the split I realized how much the relationship had been holding me back, how much of a drag on my time and energy it had become.

I realized as time passed that it had created a huge blind spot as well, that I had been trying to solve all of my problems within the context of Quakerism. But it turned out that some of the solutions weren't to be found there. I wondered if I was led to preach, but in February I found myself, quite unexpectedly, on stage storytelling for the first time in a decade. I had been having a kind of midlife crisis about wanting an actual job, a profession, say, that had a name people recognized and that perhaps I could even be paid for. After seriously considering seminary, once I laid down my membership I quickly found my way to an idea that had been in my Grab Bag for several years: Speech Language Pathology.

I don't know why I assumed, then, that my relationship to vocal ministry wouldn't change, that things would keep dropping into that bag. At least now, since my talks with Sue and Shani, since letting my emotions simmer down a bit, I don't think the empty bag is necessarily a tragedy. It may simply represent, like the storytelling and the speech pathology degree, that a new conduit has opened up between me and God. Just because I don't know, right now, what that conduit is, just because I don't, right now, recognize what it is that God might be saying to me, doesn't mean it's not there. It doesn't mean God has stopped speaking. Perhaps, sometime, we'll get back in touch. Perhaps, if we're no longer passionate lovers, we can be friends.

 
Another typical page in one of my notebooks. You can see that I am not the only person who writes in them. The rule for the kids is, "You can write or draw on any blank page." I like the little surprises that turn up for me from time to time. Sometimes it's math problems, sometimes it's robots.

 

Friday, July 13, 2012

The Things You Find Out About Yourself

I had a couple of surprises at last week's FGC Gathering of Friends. One was that one of the highlights of my week was being invited to meet with a group of polyamorous and kinky Friends. A small group of us met early in the week, and enjoyed it so much that we met again a few days later. That second meeting was one of the deepest, most worshipful parts of my week.

I was surprised by how much meeting with these folks meant to me, because I hadn't thought of polyamory as a central part of who I am. If anything, I see myself as something of a poser--Raider and I claim to be in an open relationship, but it's only been actively opened up a couple of times, and that before we had kids.

Indeed, we've spent most of our 19 years together too busy with other things to have relationships on the side. For the first few years, we were so busy enjoying each other we actually thought we were monogamous. Then, one day in the car, we engaged in one of those "what if" conversations--what if you were at a conference and it was someone you'd never see again? what if it was an ongoing relationship with someone out of town? what if it was someone in town and you wanted to date them in a clearly secondary-to-our-relationship way? what if it was someone in town and you got very serious with them?

And we discovered that none of these scenarios was a deal-breaker for either of us. "Huh," we said. "I guess we're not monogamous. Who knew?"

It was another four or five years before either of us acted on it, though. We got busy with figuring out how to stay in a relationship past the first couple of years, and then in dealing with an undiagnosed anxiety disorder I'd had since childhood, and with one thing and another, there was never a good time. For one thing, we were too darn busy to have time to date. For another, it's never a good idea to start a second relationship when your first one is vulnerable. It's too easy to use the new lover as an excuse to opt out of the work you need to do with the old one.

I'm sure some people do it and make it work. It's not a risk I'm willing to take.

And then, after awhile, all the drama and hard work was behind us. We were stable, settled, happy. And over several months in the summer of 2000, we both had some outside adventures, and it was fine. It was fun, and it was fine.

And then, a few weeks later, I got pregnant with the Lego Savant, and there followed another decade of being just too darn busy. Most parents can attest that nurturing your own relationship during the years you're raising young children is hard enough; I couldn't imagine having the energy or patience for a girlfriend.

In general, for the last decade, I've seen myself settling into life as a very conventional middle-class stay-at-home mom. I felt like I clung to my theoretical polyamory the way I clung to my nose piercing--something that signalled that I wasn't boring and middle American. Or, at least, not just boring and middle American.

I need to digress to say that I don't mean to suggest that heterosexual, monogamously married moms are dull or unworthy. I know many women who are, so far as I know, HMMMs, and they are all awesome. They make mothering into a loving art, they like their husbands, they all have something that isn't their children that they are passionate about, whether that's gardening, art, religion, political and social activism, bread-baking. There's no shame in being one of them, and to the extent that I am one of them, I'm proud to be. This is just a holdover from some anxiety from my youth; it's about me, not about them.

It never occurred to me that I clung to my "theoretical" polyamory because polyarmory is actually part of who I am. That I might not be a poseur trying to be more interesting than I am, but a polyamorous person who just hasn't had the inclination or opportunity to practice much these last two decades.

But I had a lot of time to reflect on the long car ride home, and realized that nearly all of my relationships have been non-monogamous. I've done it well, and I've done it badly. I've done it with women whose care and respect for their lovers were a model to emulate, and I've done it with women whose behavior was a red flag I should have let myself see sooner. I've gotten it so badly wrong that I've hurt someone I care about very much (long since forgiven!), and I've gotten it so right that my girlfriend and I could double-date with her lover and her lover's other lover.

But I've always done it. My first woman lover and I broke up in 1988, and I don't think I have committed to be exclusive with anyone since then (that first few years with Raider, when we mistakenly believed ourselves to be monogamous, are a special case).

Anyway, I wanted to say that until I walked into that room for that meeting last week, I hadn't realized how isolated I have felt among Quakers as a polyamorous person. (And as a person with some unconventional sexual preferences, but I'm not going to talk about that in any detail.) It felt good to be in a circle of folks where I knew I wouldn't be judged, though it actually took us some work to get to that point, because you never know. Unconventional people can be just as prone as anybody else to think that everything on their side of some self-defined line is OK, and anything on the other side is just plain wrong. Nobody wants to face that moment when you make yourself vulnerable only to find out that you were not safe from judgment in that space. But we got there. And it was a good, deep, and worshipful place to be.

I might have another post on this topic in me--thinking about this brought up so many memories: good, bad, funny, sexy. I might write about what, in my experience, works and what doesn't. What are some of the common blunders? What are the red flags you should look for in a new relationship? How do people of good will take care of each other in multiple relationships? I'm no expert, but I spent a few intense years in my 20s learning by trial and error, and I might have a few words to say.

I usually do.

Wednesday, May 9, 2012

I Crochet Because I'm Hooked.




Back in February, I took up crocheting literally one day before the kids and I left for the FLGTBQC Midwinter Gathering. My motivation was partly peer pressure; I have lots of Quaker friends who knit or crochet or quilt their way through business meetings, and I've always envied them a little. It was also serendipity. Earlier in the month, I'd spent the day at the Midwinter Singing Festival, and a very nice woman sat next to me at the Tin Pan Alley sing-along and took out her needlework.

She was doing something interesting with a big crochet hook, that involved putting a bunch of stitches on and then taking them off again. I asked her about it, and it turned out she was doing Tunisian crochet, and she assured me it was both easy and fun. "This is what I do when I'm in the dark, like at the concert last night, and can't watch my hands."

"Easy and fun," I thought to myself. "Hmmm."

I crocheted my way through the Midwinter Gathering, and liked it. I felt like I had joined the community of stitchy people. But I was also interested to notice that crocheting seemed to keep me from blurting out jokes at inappropriate times during business meeting, one of my less attractive habits. I also found that having my hands busy allowed me to focus my mind more effectively; often I have a notebook open in biz meeting, and end up doodling or thinking about to-do lists or starting to write something. A pen and a blank sheet of paper is too appealing.

By April, I'd moved on to single crochet, and cute Amigurumi animals, having discovered that Tunisian crochet is not especially versatile without learning many many complicated stitches, and having pretty well exhausted the potential of the Tunisian Rectangle. I took a big bag of yarn and a couple of crochet hooks to the Festival of Faith & Writing with me, hung my scissors and a stitch marker from my name tag's lanyard, and spent 9-12 hours a day for three days listening to panelists, speakers, and authors, all while crocheting.

I learned a couple of things. One is that, with a little practice, it is possible to count stitches with one part of your mind while another part is paying close attention to what someone is saying.

Another is that there is something refreshing about listening without trying to hold on. At the last FFW, I took something like 20 pages of notes. At this one, I only wrote things down if they were important enough to make me put down my hook and pull my notebook and pen out of my bag. I get anxious about retaining things; it was a relief to just listen and trust that anything important would either stick with me, or turn up again sometime. And to let it be OK just to listen and have a good time.

And, finally, I learned that crocheting can help you through a mediocre panel. There were a couple I'd never have had the patience for if I didn't have the steady work of my hands to keep me calm and grounded.

(Also, I learned that, if you take up a new craft on, say, a Tuesday, doing it non-stop all day and evening that Thursday, Friday, and Saturday will lead to big improvements in your work very quickly. FFW wasn't just spiritually and intellectually enriching for me this year; it wasn't just a chance to have a great time with old and new friends. It was like Amigurumi Boot Camp.)

I'm not the only one who has noticed this. A friend once told me that she was taking knitting to some contentious meetings because it helped her not wave her finger in people's faces when she was making a vehement point. And when I shared the bumper sticker that started this post on Facebook today (thanks to my friend Oliver Danni for the picture), she also commented that knitting has gotten her through some dull meetings.

At home, I find crocheting helps me sit still in the evenings when I might otherwise be jumping up every five minutes to put just one more load of dishes in the dishwasher, or add something I just thought of to my to-do list, or get the laundry out of the dryer. Partly this is because by the time I get into my chair with my hook and my yarn and my poly-fill stuffing and my scissors and my tapestry needle and my stitch counters and my little pad of paper for keeping track of rows and my pen, it's quite the production to get up again so whatever it is had better be worth it. But it's also because crocheting helps me stay focused on a TV show or an audio book.

My friend Stasa has written about doing handwork as allowing her to remain in worship despite physical pain, or fatigue. I wish I'd realized I had the option during the time when I was dealing with constant fatigue--I dozed off in worship very often, and it was discouraging and a little embarrassing (everyone falls asleep in Quaker meeting some time--but every week?), and, as Stasa points out, kept me from participating in worship nearly as effectively as if I had stayed home. In fact, I often did stay home from worship during that time. Stasa invites us to think about handwork as an accessibility tool some people might use to be present in worship, or as a ministry they might be engaging in.

On a lighter note, I'll add that I have been enjoying crocheting--especially my amigurumi--in part because several years ago, I saw amigurumi for the first time and loved it. I aspired to it. But, I said to myself, I could never do that. My mother was, pre-arthritis, a very talented needleworker. She could make anything out of yarn. If she were young today, she'd probably be one of those people knitting parking meter cozies. But, as a kid, I never could learn, despite trying many times.

Now, I think I gave up too easily back then. As a middle-aged person, I've learned to be patient about learning--I was happy to make Rectangles of No Particular Use out of my Tunisian crochet for quite awhile, just getting the hang of the stitches and rows. I dived into amigurumi animals more quickly. I did one test sphere to see if I could manage a head, and it came out pointy on one end but close enough to convince me I had some hope of learning to do it right. My first animals came out all kinds of lopsided; just in the last couple of days I've really gotten the hang of using my stitch markers and getting through a whole row without accidentally adding or dropping any stitches. I've gotten comfortable with doing something badly until, inevitably, I get better at it.

My point was supposed to be: here I am, doing something I thought would always be beyond me. OK, crocheting a hot dog bun (my next project, requested by the Tiny Tornado, who already has an amigurumi ketchup bottle and needs the hot dog to go with it) isn't going to win me a Nobel Prize. But, however small the accomplishment, there is something very satisfying in thinking, "I can't," and then finding out, "I can."

[Look! I figured out how to include images in a blog post. Turns out there's a "picture" button. Who knew? Visual appeal, here I come!]

Friday, May 4, 2012

Unchurched: Six Months On

It's been about six months since I laid down my membership in my Quaker meeting. I haven't been to worship on a Sunday since, not in a Quaker meeting or anyplace else. I miss it. I really enjoyed the Vespers service at the Festival of Faith & Writing for giving me a chance to worship, and I'm looking forward to next Saturday's bat mitzvah for the same reason. But I'm not feeling led to go to weekly worship, despite missing it. I thought I would. I left my Quaker meeting with an optimistic sense that I was going to find a new religious community, and imagined myself visiting around on Sunday mornings for awhile until something clicked.

And then I didn't do that.

"I'm just not ready to date yet," I said. And this feels true. It's a big commitment to join a community, and there's a lot of work to be done. Getting to know people, learning the norms, taking the risk that you'll invest your time and energy and it won't work out. Once in a conversation with some friends, I said that if my relationship with Raider ended, I'd probably just choose to be single. I love my relationship with Raider, it's the foundation for everything else in my life, but let's not kid ourselves: it has taken a lot of work. I sometimes doubt I'd be willing to take on that work again.

Maybe I'm not willing to take on the work of joining a religious community, either, even though I know that the payoff can make it worthwhile.

Also, I'm still a Quaker. This felt very clear to me when I was at the FLGBTQC midwinter gathering. So, it's not that I'm completely uncommitted and ready to be snapped up by any attractive faith that comes along. I'm a Quaker without a monthly meeting, and that feels different. It has held me back from visiting congregations that I might like but never feel I could commit fully to.

I've also been lukewarm about the obvious churches I might visit, the Unitarian Universalists and the United Church of Christ. One of my points of friction with my monthly meeting was our tendency to be talky, self-satisfied, affluent liberals, and I can't see the UU or the UCC improving much on that.

At the Festival of Faith & Writing, I had the opportunity to get to know a friend-of-a-friend, and listening to her talk about her church, I got excited for the first time. She is part of a United Methodist congregation in Brighton, Michigan (about 40 minutes from where I live) that decided to be a "missional" church. Their mission statement is "transformed by God to transform the world," and they try to do this by taking concrete action in their community and in the world. They feed the homeless in Detroit and house them in Brighton; they support a local dental clinic for low-income people, and a hospital in Haiti. They do work projects locally, in Appalachia, in North Dakota, and sometimes in the Czech Republic, where they also financially support a sister church. They throw a birthday party every month at a long-term care facility. Look at this list!

Quakers think of ourselves as activists, but in my experience our activism tends toward writing letters, writing "minutes" that we send to legislators and organizations, and demonstrating. It's not that I think a faithful witness like maintaining a weekly vigil for peace for over a decade of war is something to be derided. But I have often longed to be able to do something more concrete. I have always admired the Baby Pantry my friend Julie's church maintains, for instance. I hoped that when my monthly meeting built a meetinghouse, we'd be able to do something like that, something that would let us, on a regular basis, do something concrete and good for a real person standing in front of us.

But the meetinghouse we built doesn't have enough storage space to do that kind of thing (I was, for years, a big booster of the building project. But I remember the moment that changed for me, when I came to feel that we were spending too much money to build a building that would be too small for our needs as soon as we moved in. I know that many people love that meetinghouse, and it is a beautiful little building to worship in. But some of the doors that I hoped would open once we stopped renting space weren't able to open because of space constraints).

Anyway, I found myself seriously attracted to Suzy's church. It felt restful to imagine a church where, perhaps, I wouldn't be asked to do a lot of thinking and talking so much as I would be invited to show up to make sandwiches, to celebrate a birthday, to hammer a nail, to get some diapers or a new crib to a foster family. Perhaps part of what I was attracted to was Suzy's undiluted enthusiasm for the projects her church does. Sure, you'd expect that of her--she's the Director of Missions and Outreach. And she seems like a pretty enthusiastic person in general. I expect that many other people who meet her like her as much as I did. But it also made me aware of one reason I haven't gone church-shopping. After 20 years of practicing the Quakerly endurance test of sitting still, I am strongly drawn to the idea of specific action.

Hmmm. This isn't what I meant to talk about. I was going to talk about the many secular, familial, personal, and professional opportunities that have opened up. Laying down my membership cleared my calendar and settled my mind. But I will save that for another day.

Saturday, September 17, 2011

So Long, and Thanks for All The Fish

I have really wrestled with this post. When I'm not actually writing, I can feel it taking shape in my mind and it seems like it's all there, ready to write down. But when I sit down to write, I can't find my way into it. But I'm tired of carrying it around so I am going to finish it this time even if it doesn't come out right.

I have laid down my membership in my monthly meeting.

That's the short version, and there have been recent days when I thought about just plopping that onto my Facebook wall as a status update and getting it over with. But among the people who already know this, some have asked me to talk about why and how this happened, so I will now attempt the long version.

*stares out window, taps fingers on table for awhile*

The long version is hard.

I'm not interested in talking about any of the specific ways my Friends meeting has been hard for me, or laying out the various problems I see in contemporary unprogrammed Quakerism. I've been wrestling with both of those things for several years, and one of the nice things about finally making the break is that I don't have to keep thinking about them. It's quite a relief, honestly; an end to a long, hard struggle.

Besides, I could just as easily write a long thing about what I think works in Quakerism, and the many ways my monthly meeting is awesome--because it is. This is less a drama than a quiet breakup, like when those two nice people you thought would be together forever announce that they are divorcing but plan to remain friends.

It really does feel like a breakup. Like the breakups I've been through before, the final decision was less in response to a single event or problem and more a moment of clarity after a long period of trying really hard to fix things.

I think the breakup comes now because I have entered a period of lots of movement in my life. For most of the past year, I was feeling stuck and discouraged, wanting to make changes and not feeling able to. But in the last few months, suddently those changes have been not only possible, but easy and joyful. This is one of those changes, I think, a time of movement after being stuck for a long time: annoyed by the same things, hurt by the same things, frustrated by not finding answers to the same tired questions. I felt blocked with Quakerism, not able to find a way forward when something in me was straining at the leash. But I also felt trapped in Quakerism, unable to move away from it because I could not imagine that there was any other spiritual home for me. I assumed that liberal Quakerism was the best fit I would I find, that any other group of religious people would only be a worse fit.

But "she's the best I can hope for" is a bad reason to stay with someone. I have become optimistic about the possibility that there may actually be a spiritual community somewhere else that will serve me better in this new time in my life. There's a point during the ending of a relationship when you start to get excited about the possibilities that open up if the relationship ends. All the opportunities that have been forclosed by the success of that relationship open back up again.

I have been reminded, too, that it is better to be single than to stay in a bad relationship. I'm feeling willing to live with either of those options, open to the kind of changes that worshipping in a new way might bring me, and open to the possibility, too, that I'll wind up unchurched.

I don't quite know what my next step is. Laying down my membership has been a mental and emotional relief, and boy howdy has it cleared my calendar! I'm not sure if I should turn right around and head off to church on Sunday morning, or wait awhile before I start dating. Honestly, the search feels kind of exhausting: it's a lot of work to find your way into a community, and that's after the work of finding one you might want to be part of. I don't know if I'm ready to start yet. On the other hand, I feel eager to find out what's next, and may be too restless to sit around home too many Sundays in a row.

A small group of us began weekday morning worship at the meetinghouse two weeks ago, and I've been going every morning despite this decision. I don't feel quite sure about it; sometimes a clean break is best, for both parties. I've laid down all my responsiblities to the meeting, and maybe it will send a mixed message that I'm still worshipping there five mornings a week. But I don't have a strong feeling that it's wrong for me to be there, so I may wear that sword as long as I am able. It may help with the transition, or it may turn out to be too awkward, or it may ultimately prove to be something that is holding me back. But I like it and I think I'm going to keep doing it for now.

I plan to stay involved with FLGBTQC as well; everyone should plan to see me and the kids in Wisconsin next February for the midwinter gathering. I'm less sure about summer gatherings; we may not be able to afford the summer gathering without the generous stipend my monthly meeting gives to children who are attending. Time will tell.

This is not a bad thing, this breakup. It's a necessary thing. It feels right, like it is the answer to many painful questions I've been carrying for too long. Of course, I've traded those for a whole new set of questions, but I like these new ones.

As usual, our friend Walt Whitman has some words that speak to my condition. This is from section 46 of Song of Myself:

I tramp a perpetual journey, (come listen all!)
My signs are a rain-proof coat, good shoes, and a staff cut from the woods,
No friend of mine takes his ease in my chair,
I have no chair, no church, no philosophy,
I lead no man to a dinner table, library, exchange,
But each man and each woman of you I lead upon a knoll,
My left hand hooking you round the waist,
My right hand pointing to landscapes of continents and the public road.

Not I, nor anyone else can travel that road for you,
You must travel it for yourself.

It is not far, it is within reach,
Perhaps you have been on it since you were born and did not know,
Perhaps it is everywhere on water and on land.

Shoulder your duds dear son, and I will mine, and let us hasten forth,
Wonderful cities and free nations we shall fetch as we go.

If you tire, give me both burdens, and rest the chuff of your hand on my hip,
And in due time you shall repay the same service to me,
For after we start we never lie by again.

***

Sit awhile dear son,
Here are bisuits to eat and here is milk to drink,
But as soon as you sleep and renew yourself in sweet clothes, I kiss you with a good-by kiss and open the gate for your egress hence.

Friday, August 20, 2010

What We Look For, and What We Get

Kirk Cowell over at A Soul in Training is looking for a new church to attend, and while he is explicitly Christian in a way I'm not, and most Quakers I know aren't (even the Christocentric ones, I think), his thinking about what he and his family need from a church resonates with me. I've been musing off and on in recent months about how people come to Quakerism, and what they look for once they're there.

I know some people in my meeting come and stay because they find support and recognition for their political activism, a community that sees that work as important and spirit-led. Some come, I think, because we're a group of nice, welcoming people. Although some people in our meeting have known each other for twenty years or more, we're not insular. I think we do a pretty good job of making newcomers feel welcome but not overwhelmed. We can be accepting in good ways--one single mom who started attending a few years ago told me she appreciated the lack of judgment about her status as a single mom and about the way she dressed, after spending some time at a church where she felt scrutinized.

Some of us come to Quakerism because we're not comfortable with liturgical worship, or because we've been hurt by the Christian churches of our upbringing. This was my path; I wasn't raised in a church, but as a young radical lesbian feminist with vague spiritual yearnings, I couldn't see myself listening to a sermon about God the Father or singing hymns about Jesus. I tried joining some of the local lesbians in their pagan celebrations, but it didn't seem to me that anybody there really believed in what they were doing (I could have been wrong about this). And I wasn't comfortable with the Native American Lite spirituality of many white lesbians. So I tried the local Quaker meeting, and liked it well enough to stay.

The thing is, we come there for all kinds of different reasons. This can create tensions--as at a recent Meeting for Business I've talked about before, in which I had been seriously thinking, "If we approve this wording about what it means to be a Quaker, I'm going home and writing my letter withdrawing my membership," only a few minutes before a very beloved Friend said something like, "When we do this kind of word-smithing, I think we're getting awfully close to defining a creed, and I have to tell you if we start spending very much time on this kind of thing, I'm out of here." Despite the distress I was feeling, I couldn't help grinning inwardly and thinking of Mr. Bennett telling Elizabeth, "An unhappy alternative is before you, Elizabeth. From this day you must be a stranger to one of your parents. Your mother will never see you again if you do not marry Mr. Collins, and I will never see you again if you do." I think people in the meeting that day would be aghast to think they'd come to the brink of losing one or the other of us.

But I think overall we--my meeting, at least--do a pretty good job of being together in all our unlikely unity. I have a mystical relationship with a personal God I know experimentally, and Paul is an avowed atheist, but not only does the meeting want (and need?) both of us there, but Paul and I really care for and about each other. It seems to me that we bump up against our differences as we go about our Quakering--half the meeting loves so-and-so's vocal ministry, and the other half wishes he'd shut up already; one person needs to name God and another is pained to hear the word--but when we take time, in retreats or in business meeting, to listen to each other, we do it well, and it unites us.

What was my point?

Oh, I was going to say that we come to Quakerism for a reason. We're looking for a place where we will be comfortable and accepted, or where some of our questions can be answered. Does anybody walk through the door hoping to have all her most treasured beliefs challenged, to be transformed by faith, to be converted? Somehow I doubt it. And yet, to me, that's the best part of being a person of faith (also the scariest): the completely unexpected things that can happen to you when you let yourself be open. I joke that I am a person of faith today because when people told me that Quaker worship was a bunch of people sitting around waiting on God, I naively believed them, and after I waited long enough, God started showing up. And the thing is, once God shows up, crazy unexpected things start happening. Your whole like can change.

The balance seems tricky to me: we don't want to frighten people off, but if we think our purpose is to make them comfortable, we're never going to do God's work or help them find their piece of it. And yet, if we're honest with people, we would have to tell them that they're taking big risks by trying to listen to God, even if they don't call what they're listening for by that name. Mary Karr, author of The Liars Club and Lit, converted to Catholicism right in the middle of the pedophile priest scandal. She totally gets why people think she's a complete moron, and yet her conversion felt inevitable to her, and it was central to helping her become sober--conversion saved her life. But it also wrecked her life. Does anybody come to meeting for worship hoping to have their life wrecked? Should we warn them?

I went looking for a Flannery O'Connor quote I remember from 20 years ago, something about most people coming to church by means the church does not allow, and I couldn't find it. I found this one, though: "All human nature vigorously resists grace because grace changes us and the change is painful."

I preached in worship on Sunday (I just can't say "offered vocal ministry" right now, sorry) on the subject of conversion. At least, I think that's what I was trying to talk about, with God's help. I was hoping, I think, to encourage people to be open to the way their faith and their practice can change them, though I also ended up talking about why people resist that. Why I do, even after having been through it before. It's because your faith and your practice can change you in ways that seem intolerable from where you're sitting now.

When I first came to Quaker meeting, I came to "Quaker meeting." It was years before I could say "worship," or anything else that sounded religious. Now I have an affinity for the religious aspect of our society (I am the one who, if I didn't rein myself in, would be prissily correcting people who talk about "The Society of Friends" instead of The Religious Society of Friends) and even for religious language from outside our tradition: convicted, preach, grace, mitzvah. And yet, having gotten comfortable here, I don't really want to be changed any more. It's not that I have thrown down all the walls and am ready to follow God wherever God leads; it's more like I moved the walls. This far, and no farther.

I talk about me here, and I talked about me some in worship on Sunday, not only because I like to talk about me but because I want people to know that when I invite them to be open not only to the comfort that Spirit and spiritual community provide but also to the ways that Spirit and their spiritual community can change them, push them in uncomfortable ways, I am not speaking as someone who has solved this problem for herself. It's more like I'm looking for company in a prickly and frightening place.

I am woefully ignorant about the Bible (I recently asked my friend Julie, a Lutheran pastor, to clarify for me: Peter and Simon Peter: one person, or two? Julie is very patient). But in the few bits I do know, it seems like Jesus is always asking people to give up all they have to follow him. And nobody can blame the ones who answer, "You have got to be kidding me," and go back to their vineyards and mansions and piles of gold coins. And even the ones who say yes sometimes get what seem like paltry returns. There are a couple of people in my meeting who can speak eloquently on the subject of following a leading right into a brick wall at 60 miles an hour.

Hmm, I don't think Ministry & Outreach is going to be asking me to write the new outreach pamphlet anytime soon. All this talk about life-wrecking. But there you have it. You come into a silent room for a little peace and quiet, with maybe some coffee after with nice people who seem to like you. And then a bomb goes off.

Tuesday, June 15, 2010

A couple of more things about my meeting

I am loving how many comments I've gotten on my last post, and a few private e-mails as well. I want to be clear about something, though, which is that my monthly meeting is actually a splendid one. We are very good at listening to each other and holding our differences lovingly. For instance, year before last the Adult Religious Ed committee held a retreat at which we talked about our different relationships to Quakerism. It began in the morning with a panel of Friends describing their paths, and in the afternoon we did this great exercise where the leader would read a statement, such as, "I have a personal relationship with God," and then we would place ourselves along a continuum based on how true it felt for us.

The discussions then of why people places themselves where they did were deep, loving, and at times hilarious. Sometimes a person listening to someone else speak would move a few places down the continuum; once the people on the opposite ends of the continuum decided that they were talking about exactly the same thing using different words and that we should more properly therefore form a circle. It was great.

And I want to say, too, that during our almost-two-year custody dispute with Yehva's birthfather, my meeting's support for us was incredible. The meeting helped us financially through the fund for sufferings; two different families in the meeting were independently led to send us large checks to help out with legal fees; the meeting convened a support committee for us; and, more than any of that, I could feel how deeply people in the meeting were entering with us into our fear of losing her and our deep love for her. People's sympathy for our situation seemed to go so deep that I felt like some members of the meeting, at least--and not always the people I'd had the closest or best relationships with--were feeling it all with us.

That my hiatus from meeting began only two months after the appeals court finally settled the case in our favor once and for all sometimes makes me feel, as I told David recently, like the guy whose wife puts him through med school, and then he dumps her for a younger woman right after graduation.

But, you know, it is what it is. God told me to leave my meeting for awhile, in one of the clearest messages I've ever gotten in meeting for worship. I'm just a little cranky that the next step hasn't been made so clear.

Monday, June 14, 2010

Still Thinking About My Quaker Meeting & Me

A few months ago, our Ministry & Outreach committee was working on a pamphlet that might give a brief introduction to Quaker faith & practice to people attending an open house at our new meetinghouse. They brought a draft to business meeting that included something like our usual, "Quakers believe in that of God or Spirit in everyone." We usually say "or Spirit" because some people aren't comfortable with the word "God," and treating "God" and "Spirit" as roughly equivalent is something we've gotten used to over time.

This draft pamphlet, though, added "or goodness" as a third option. This was the first time I'd ever seen "goodness" used in this context, although, interestingly, I have seen it again since then on some Quaker blogs.

I've been struggling with my meeting for a couple of years now, and although I have been making efforts to return in recent weeks, have been on hiatus--not attending worship--since May of 09. Every week lately, as I've been trying to return, there has been some barrier to me attending meeting for worship, either at home or at the meetinghouse: I've been sick, the aforementioned patchouli-drenched hippy has sat down near me and I've had to leave the room, I'm so raw that a minor crankiness between me and a beloved Friend has led to a big emotional explosion on my part, or Yehva has fussed so persistently that I've decided to take her home.

I think most of these things would hardly be obstacles if I were more sure about my need and desire to be there. I think it is a sign of how fragile my intention is that a pebble in my path ends up feeling more like a military roadblock, complete with snarling dogs, circling helicopters with searchlights, and sarcastic immigration officers sneering, "And just what brings you to this part of town, girly?"

So, anyway, the committee brings this pamphlet draft that says Quakers believe in "that of God, or Spirit, or goodness, in everyone," and my heart sinks. One of my struggles with Quakerism is what I see as its secularization; I want to be part of a religion, not an affiliation of nice people with good intentions. The person presenting the draft asked the meeting for approval to print the pamphlet, and the immediate response was a number of voices saying, "Go ahead!" and "Good job!" and "Roll the presses!" and such like.

I thought that if it was really OK with my meeting to have a pamphlet published that equated "God" and "goodness," then I was definitely in the wrong place. And I also felt that I did not have it in me to be the lone voice of dissent; I really, in that moment, intended to let them go ahead and publish that pamphlet. And then, I thought, I would go home and write my letter withdrawing my membership.

"I'll stand aside," I said, which, many of you know, is that a Quaker does when she cannot unite with a decision of the meeting but recognizes that the meeting is otherwise in unity.

And the clerk accepted that. She was ready to move on, except that over the next couple of minutes, other people raised concerns as well. I don't remember about what, exactly; not the same as mine, I don't think. The M&O committee felt time pressure; they needed to get a pamphlet approved in time to have it printed for the open house. And the clerk, I think, felt time pressure, too--we used to have business meeting before our 12:30 p.m. meeting for worship, and that created a fixed end time. This was, if I recall correctly, our first business meeting in the new meetinghouse, and our first one on the new schedule: starting business meeting at 12:30 or so, after morning worship and the social hour, with nothing to force an ending on us if we ran long. And we were running long. Oh, so long.

Time pressure has got to be the number one cause of bad practice among Friends.

So, a few people raised concerns, but the clerk tried to move us along. "I heard a lot of approval in the room," she said, "and Su has agreed to stand aside..."

And damn if God didn't give me a word to speak in that moment.

I don't remember it very well--I often find that when what I have said is spirit-led is that I don't remember much of it afterward. But I said, "I may have been hasty," and then I went on to say something about "goodness" being a weak word, a word that seems to me to be almost completely about a human quality. God is not all about goodness, I said. God is a big dark hard mystery that we wrestle with, and it is a disservice to reduce God to this single quality. I said...I don't know what I said. But I was eloquent! Damn. And I felt as I said it that I was saying exactly what I meant, exactly what I needed to say. And I felt that it came inwardly from God.

We went on to have a good discussion. A couple of non-theist Friends spoke, and in hearing them I found raised up in me a concern for non-theist Friends in my meeting. I found myself wondering whether "we believe in that of God in everyone" has become an empty phrase we mouth, if half of us don't even believe in God; I found myself concerned that we were asking non-theist Friends to accommodate themselves too much; I went away musing about why we continue, as our first answer to the question of what Quakers are, to assert a question of belief as a defining thing when Quakers do not in fact share a unifying belief; and then I found myself wondering what, if not a belief in That of God in Everyone, does make us Quakers.

We were eventually able to unify around language for the pamphlet, much to the relief of the M&O committee. The woman who had presented it thanked us, and said, "I move every time we have this conversation," which felt true to me as well. This, to me, is the thing Quakers do better than anybody else I've ever encountered, this deep listening to each other (and, yes, to the Divine), and coming to a decision that respects all those voices. I felt pretty good after that meeting, actually, which was quite a change from "the first thing I'm going to do when I get home is write my anti-membership letter!"

And since then... *sigh.*

Yesterday I was at the meetinghouse for a committee meeting, and I found myself standing on the porch gazing at our sign, which is leaning against the wall there. "Red Cedar Friends Meeting," it says, and then the Quaker testimonies, based on the SPICE acronym: Simplicity, Peace, Integrity, Community, Equality.

I have always hated that acronym, without really thinking about why, beyond, "Oh, isn't that adorable, how my whole big messy deep religion can be summed up a cute little five-letter word?" (But I just googled for the SPICE acronym and found that I am not the only Quaker who doesn't love it.)

Yesterday, that word "integrity" really jumped out at me. This is a word we use in place of Truth, as in Publishers of Truth, the term early Quakers used to describe themselves. What truth? God's truth, as revealed to Quakerism's founder, George Fox.

Now, Quakers don't necessarily think there's one Truth for everybody (two people praying about whether they should take a certain action may well get different answers) and we have never claimed to posses the whole Truth. And some of what God revealed to Fox seems downright nutty to us now. But we have believed that seeking the Truth would lead to an increased measure of it, and that as our measures grew, we would find ourselves more and more in accord with each other. (Big generalizations there, many of which could be contested. It will do for now.)

"Integrity," though--there's another one of those human words. For a person to have integrity, her words and actions should be in accord with each other. But integrity does not require a person's words and actions to be in accord with God's will as they understand it.

Truth, on the other hand, calls us to consider not only our own human wishes and actions but God's. A person of integrity is not necessarily a person of God. A good person is not necessarily a person of God.

I want to be a person of God. I want my faith community to aid me in becoming a person of God. I want, in my faith community, to be able to use the word "God" without someone immediately following up with a comment about how uncomfortable they are with that word.

I do not like listing our testimonies as a way of defining ourselves. I don't like the SPICE acronym. And I don't like suggesting that what we strive for is personal integrity rather than Truth. Might as well put up a sign, I thought, reading: "Red Cedar Friends Meeting: We're Nice People."

Now, I recognize first, that this is getting really long and probably nobody is going to read it. But second, I recognize that there is probably no congregation of any religious body anywhere in which everybody is all heated up about discussing God and God's will. When my friend Julie and I were at the Festival of Faith & Writing in April, we both talked about how good it felt to be among people who wanted to wrestle with the questions we like to wrestle with. That festival draws on people from all kinds of Christian denominations, probably most of whom also don't have a whole lot people in their home church who meet their need for questioning and examining every last little thing. If we all had that at home, there'd be no need for the conference.

So I know that it is unreasonable for me to expect my monthly meeting to meet my every religious need, and I don't expect that. And I know that when I speak honestly about my concerns and interests there, I am heard with sympathy and respect. And I take very much to heart Friend Martin Kelly's point in the blog post I linked to above, that "comfort is not necessarily what God has in mind for us," so I wince when I hear myself wanting to be more comfortable in my monthly meeting.

And yet...

I thought it was time for me to go back to worship, but every time I go to the meetinghouse, there's a pebble in my way that feels like a wall.

Sunday, June 13, 2010

More About, Of All Things, Perfume And Race. Ranty!

My friend Julie commented in my post about the Black student who was removed from her class by a teacher because of the hair products she was using and I wrote such a long ranty and profane reply I decided to edit it for profanity and turn it into its own post. (Profanity not aimed at Julie...more about strength of feeling).

Here's what Julie, very reasonably, said about a time some years ago at a Quaker conference when I did not move my seat when a Black man wearing cologne sat down next to me, for fear of him thinking I had moved because he was Black:

My two cents is, just move when you have to move, and don't worry about what anyone else is thinking. You're responsible for taking care of your needs, not their potential or imagined reaction.


Julie is not wrong. But this is what I found myself writing in response:

The "just move" thing is a little hard for me, Julie. There are very few Black people at FGC Gathering most years, and I have heard some Black men in particular tell stories about women clutching purses or otherwise seeming wary when a Black man comes into the room or gets behind them in line at the cafeteria. I don't know how much of that is perception and how much is reality. I'm not a big fan of mind-reading in general, assuming you know somebody's motive, so when I hear "this white woman clutched her purse because she was afraid of me," I reserve judgment. I don't assume that's an accurate perception of what that woman did and why. On the other hand, I would like the Gathering to be a place where people of color feel welcome, like a part of the community. And having heard those stories, I just wasn't easy standing up and walking away.

As far as telling the man why I was moving--it can be so hard. One thing that happens with a perfume exposure, for me, is emotionality--I think emotion welling up is part of my body's response to the chemicals or whatever I'm reactive to, and part of it is just plain old weary, "I just want to sit here and worship God and all you damn people coming to morning worship straight from your showers with your hair still stinking-shampoo wet and your lotion freshly applied and your hairspray and deodorant are making it really hard for me to do that." So it's easy to imagine, sitting here, a really calm and rational response (and I have gotten better at this with practice, to be sure, because it's been a lot of years now) but it can be well-nigh impossible to do in the moment, especially if I forgot to be prepared for the possibility and am taken by surprise.

Perfume exposures in worship are about the worst for me. Not only do they mean that I have to get up and leave worship but I've of course been sitting there trying to get as open as possible. It's hard to open yourself up to Spirit while simultaneously keeping your guard up against the possibility of some patchouli-loving hippy sitting down in the next seat and wrecking half your week.

Here's an experience I had once with a Black woman at the downtown post office in Lansing, probably close to 20 years ago now. I was waiting in a long slow line, and this woman a couple of people ahead of me was wearing a really beautiful dress that just draped on her wonderfully. She was about my size, and I was lost in a reverie of thinking about how beautiful she looked and idly wondering how a dress like that might look on me.

And all of a sudden, she flew out at me. "What the fuck are you looking at? You got a problem with Black people? You got a problem with me?" I was so taken aback I couldn't say anything, let alone tell her that I hadn't meant to be staring at her but if I was it was because I thought she was beautiful.

That idea just doesn't seem to have been available to her, that a strange white woman in a public place would be staring at her in absent-minded admiration.

Sometimes I have an over-strong reaction to somebody wearing perfume not just because they're wearing perfume but because they're the 100th damn person this week who has made me give up a good seat in a movie theater or leave a restaurant before my dessert or drop out of the line at the grocery store or walk out of a kitschy little shop I wanted to browse in for awhile longer or go home and change my clothes even though my shirt was clean out of the wash two hours ago because the damn stink is all over me now just from standing five feet away in an aisle at Target. Or go back into my own house and close the windows instead of enjoying my yard because the neighbor's dryer sheets are so toxic and the wind is blowing my way. Or get out of the shower half-rinsed and run down the hall to my dorm room mostly naked because the person who just got into the shower next to me apparently doesn't understand what it means to agree to room on a fragrance-free floor and I value my ability to keep breathing over being clean and maintaining my dignity.

I told David the other day that I've had so many little aggravations lately that it's like I'm carrying this "Fuck you" around inside me right now and it's going to pop out at some, I don't know, perfectly nice lady at the grocery store who's doing nothing worse than moving too slow in the pasta aisle when all I need to do is dash in there and grab a box of rotini. That's how I feel if I've had a lot of perfume exposures, too, like I could just strangle some poor woman emitting a light and airy citrus scent because it's not just the light and airy citrus scent, it's that the light and airy citrus scent is the straw, baby, and citrus woman is the camel's back and I am so gonna break her.

So, this man who sat next to me was the metaphorical citrus woman, you see? And in the post office, I was the citrus woman. But I did not want to be the 100th person that week to do something that might or might not be a racist reaction to a Black man coming into the room or joining the line or sitting down to worship. I did not want to be his citrus woman. I wanted to be his Friend.

Thursday, April 29, 2010

Maybe we need to remember that irritants are the progenitor of pearls

My Monthly Meeting's April business meeting was a big one for me. I came out with so much to think about. There's a whole big thing I'll need to write about how we describe ourselves and why, what unites us as Quakers, belief versus action, and big stuff like that. But today I get to write about something a little smaller.

Anybody who knows me in real life or reads my blog knows I've been struggling with my place in my meeting for awhile, and have been on hiatus since last May, though I have attended business meetings because I have continued as meeting treasurer.

Our meeting begins business meeting with worship sharing, during which we explore a query. Usually they're the queries from Philadelphia Yearly Meeting's Faith & Practice, and in April we took on #4: Care for the Meeting Community, which includes questions like, "Do I recognize and face disagreements and other situations that put me in conflict with others?" and "Are avenues for exploring differences kept open? To what extent does our meeting ignore differences in order to avoid possible conflicts?"

One of our members spoke to the query. She started out by describing herself as a "combative" person; I would not have used that word about her, but I recognized in her description my own perception of her as very direct and not afraid of conflict (I know a few people like this, two in particular in my meeting. I admire them, even though they intimidate me a little). But she went on to say that she thinks sometimes we fall into a mistaken belief that every little disagreement is something that has to be addressed and solved, but we might be better off recognizing that these little disconnects and differing perspectives are something we can just accept and live with.

"Hmmm," I said to myself. I have Big Religious Reasons for my hiatus from my Friends meeting; I also have Petty Little Personal Reasons, and, honestly, it is the petty little personal stuff that makes being there hardest, that blindsides me when I've been happily chugging along through the social hour, that leaves me uncertain how to proceed: do I need to bring this up with this person? Or is it best to let it be? If I don't bring it up, am I being accepting and peaceful, or cowardly? If I speak to it, am I bringing Truth or fomenting discord?

So this Friend's words spoke directly to questions I've been wrestling with.

A few days later, I went to the Festival of Faith & Writing. The festival opened with a talk by Scott Cairns, which I found a bit rambly and hard-to-follow, maybe because I was tired. But he said a few things that seemed like they were speaking right to me.

One was that he talked about alienation from church as "an ongoing failure." He sees isolated spirituality as lacking in an essential collective quality, as being unsupported and, in need, unsupportive. "Faith cannot be both solitary and healthy," he said. "Somehow or other, these beloveds must find their way home."

I know he said these things, in these words, because they spoke so directly to me that I wrote them down.

He then went on to talk about God as being an essential witness in conflict. God's witness, he said, has freed him from the need to make every offender aware of their offense. Practicing the awareness of the presence of God, and trusting in God as a loving witness, led, he says, to forgiveness being an almost-automatic process for him. He found that he was no longer an angry person who needed every person to be called to task for every transgression, no matter how small.

I was not challenged by this at all because I could see it had nothing to do with me, and my problems in my Quaker meeting. Thank goodness! Because I really want to cling to the belief that the problem is not with me, but with my meeting, and the other people in it, and that the solution is for me to find a way to speak Truth to them and change them. So many times in the past, the solution to a conflict, whether between me and David, me and one of my kids, me and a friend, me and my mother, or me and people in my Meeting, has turned out to be a change in my own attitudes and behavior. That's not gonna happen this time! No matter how much my Friend's comments in worship-sharing began to move me, or how convicted I felt by Cairns.

Am I convincing you? Because I'm trying really hard to convince myself.

The cherry on top of this sundae: the other day, on the way home from taking the kids to the park, I passed a church that had this message on its letter board (actually, this isn't the exact message. In my memory, it's got this profanity, but I'm sure there was actually a different word outside the church):

Stop bitching about your church. If it were perfect, they wouldn't let you in.

It's so true. I know for a fact that other people in my meeting are made uncomfortable by others' actions and opinions, too--and that I am one of those others. For instance, a year or two ago, one member spoke in worship-sharing about how troubled she is by how many families in our meeting homeschool. She has a concern that families that choose to homeschool are abandoning school systems in which they would be an asset, and improve the quality of the school for other children. She feels this so deeply that she was near tears talking about it.

Now, one reaction I have to this is that I've heard this argument before, many times, and rejected it. I have all kinds of reasons why I think this is a weak anti-homeschooling argument. And it would be kind of fun to run through those again.

But that's not the point. The point is, this woman feels a concern for disadvantaged kids and their educations, and she worries that parents pulling their kids out of public schools leaves behind the most vulnerable children and makes their learning environment worse. She may be right or wrong about whether my family's, or any other homeschooling family's, involvement would be an asset for a public school. But what she feels cannot be denied. And the number of families homeschooling in our meeting reminds her of her concerns, and that is distressing to her.

I've also heard one mom in our meeting say, half-jokingly, that she wishes there weren't so many of us in the meeting homeschooling, because she thinks her kids would be better off homeschooled and it's just not an option for them, and we homeschooling families are a constant reminder.

My point is, if there are choices people in my meeting make that remind me of my own concerns and fears, or are very different from my own carefully-considered choices, and are therefore painful or irritating to me, well, I'm performing that same service for others in the meeting. I am also a source of discomfort. Probably I am a source of discomfort in ways I don't know about, because people have not chosen to make me aware of my every transgression.

I tried for a neat little conclusion here, but I don't have one. So I'm just going to toss this all out there. It's what I've been thinking about. It feels like movement. God only knows where it will lead.

Sunday, April 4, 2010

Comfort and Discomfort in the Spiritual Home

This week, I read big chunks of Fit for Freedom, Not for Friendship: Quakers, African-Americans, and the Myth of Racial Justice, by Vanessa Julye and Donna McDaniel. This is a huge, carefully-researched history of Quakers' relationship to black people, slavery, racism, abolition, civil rights, education, and more. Julye and McDaniel wrote the book as an antidote to Quakers' partial understanding of our own history; we often point to the fact, for instance, that Quakers stopped owning slaves a good hundred years before the Civil War, without necessarily digging deeply into how complex, fraught, hard-fought, and divisive that decision was. The tone of the book is neutral and factual, the level of detail is impressive bordering on numbing, and it's all in there: everything we got right (freed our slaves! marched on Washingon! Opened a school to meet the needs of black children in Detroit!), everything we got wrong (actively participated in the slave trade! resisted abolition! refused membership requests from exemplary black applicants!). It's a very thorough portrait of a flawed people with a checkered history with regard to race.

The piece that I've been chewing on for a few days, though, is from Vanessa Julye's author's statement, the very first paragraph, in which she writes:

I am one of very few African American Quakers, and I have naturally been drawn into the question of why this is so. I believe that the seeds of this circumstance were planted more than three hundred years ago, that Friends have been plagued by racist attitudes from that time to this day. These attitudes largely account for why our numbers in the Society of Friends have been and continue to be small. (xix)

I've seen this assumption for years: that any organization or institution that is predominantly white is that way because of its racism, or the racism of its members. But I'm not sure. It seems to me that in a society that continues to be as segregated as ours, a specific institution could be segregated for reasons that have little to do with the racist attitudes of its members; in fact, one could argue that Quakerism, for instance, remains predominantly white despite the active anti-racism of many of its members. This is something that I have heard white Quakers talk about with confusion and pain.

In the case of my own meeting, it is easy to imagine outside influences working against racial diversity. For 40 years, the meeting has been located in a city that the census bureau tells me is only 7% black; in a meeting with about 50 members, we would need only 3.5 black people to match our immediate community demographically. Success!

Of course, that's a very partial picture. Our Quaker meeting draws Friends from all over the area, including a city that is 22% black, and the suburb I live in, which is only 4% black. But I wonder if this is part of why it's hard for a Quaker meeting to reflect its area more accurately: most Quaker meetings are the only game in town for Friends. Some people drive half an hour or more to come to worship, and they might not do that if there were another meeting close by. By way of contrast, the ELCA church locator tells me that there are 10 Lutheran churches within 15 miles of my house, and 11 in Lansing proper. How far do people normally go when they're looking for a new church, I wonder? Are there people in Lansing who never find us because when they go church shopping, of the 10 churches in easy travel distance from their home, not one is a Quaker meeting? (And will our racial makeup change now that we've moved from the suburbs to a meetinghouse in Lansing? Will we end up on more people's shopping lists?)

So, on the one hand, I think Julye may be wrong in attributing the overwhelming whiteness of liberal Quakerism primarily to racism within the Religious Society of Friends. It seems to me that societal and structural legacies of racism could be doing the job just fine without much help from us at all.

On the other hand, I wonder how much it takes for a black person who comes to worship to decide it's just not the place for her. I've been thinking a lot about the ideas of comfort and discomfort because sometimes it seems to me that my reasons for taking a break from my meeting are petty and reveal me as a small person: sometimes people say things I disagree with. Or they hurt my feelings.

I have often thought that we place too much emphasis on being comfortable, often couching it in language about "safety." This came up a lot in the years I worked security at the Michigan Womyn's Music Festival, where many women wanted us to regulate other women's behavior because, they told us, they felt "unsafe" around (pick one): women with certain body modifications; women in leather; women who drink beer and get loud around the campfire at night. For a long time, I was very sympathetic to these complaints, until it dawned on me that "safe" and "comfortable" are not synonyms, and that if someone else's behavior or words make you uncomfortable, that isn't the same as them hurting you or threatening to. And sometimes being made uncomfortable is the first step in growth.

So I have been concerned that, in taking a break from my meeting, I am protecting myself from imaginary threats.

On the other hand...

Some of the things I find hardest about being at my meeting are things I deal with all the time elsewhere. I would like my monthly meeting to be a haven from what is ugly in the world, but it seems like most Quakers don't see some of the ugliness I do, and thoughtlessly recreate it. This means that at my meeting, as much as anyplace else, I get to enjoy hearing women who weigh a hundred pounds less than me complain about how fat they are and how much weight they need to lose. I get to hear moms speak about their children in dismissive, labeling, judgmental ways, or confidently predict the trouble I'm going to have with mine someday. I get to listen to the insights of people who think they understand poverty because they lived on a really tiny stipend while they were in graduate school. I get to hear people who've recently been tourists in third-world countries rave about the spiritual wisdom of the natives there, their deep connection to the earth, their openness and generosity despite their poverty.

And you know what? I get enough of that shit elsewhere. I don't need to come to Quaker meeting for it.

So now I imagine a black person coming to our meeting for the first time. She is likely to be welcomed effusively, as all newcomers are, because we are really nice people at Red Cedar. She may feel there is a slight tinge of "oh, yay, a black person!" in the welcome; she may suspect that, as happy as people are to see her in particular, they are also at least a little happy to think that if she keeps coming, she might improve our demographic profile. She is probably not wrong about that. She has probably experienced this before, and may feel prepared to deal with it. She may like us, and what we do, well enough to come back anyway.

But what happens on the day that tourist talks during Joys and Sorrows about the happy, enlightened, spiritually advanced poor natives he saw on his trip? What happens if she overhears a white woman making fun of the decor in the home of an African-American family she visited recently*? What happens when somebody refers to a stereotype about black people that they think is harmless because it's a positive stereotype?

How much does it take for a black person to decide we're not worth the trouble?

I want to be clear: I do not subscribe to the idea that all white people are automatically racists. I don't feel guilty about either the color of my skin or my middle-class upbringing. I don't think guilt and self-flagellation are productive.

On the other hand: I want to hold myself and my beloved community of Friends to a high standard of awareness, a high standard of behavior, a high standard of speech. We can be 99% racism-free, but our careless assumptions about who is in the room with us, how much they have in common with us, how universal our experience is, how correct our understanding is--these can be enough to tell a newcomer that he does not belong.

We should be challenging everyone who walks through our doors: challenging them spiritually, challenging them to grow into a deeper understanding of God's Truth, challenging them to join with us in the hard work of becoming the people God calls us to be. To do that, we have to be a place where people can become humble, open, and vulnerable, because it is only in that state that new truths can be heard. If people have to guard themselves against us, they will have to be exceptionally strong to simultaneously open themselves to God.

I imagine Julye must be one such exceptionally strong person, to respond to the racism she experiences in the Religious Society of Friends not by leaving but by giving seven years of her life to research and writing a book of truth about our history. She (and her white co-author) see our impoverishment of spirit and understanding, and respond by giving more of themselves to us. This is not something we can expect of every black person, or every working-class or poor person, or every fat person. We are filled with love for each other--I know that I am beloved in my meeting, sometimes very deeply loved by the same people whose behavior I find most hurtful. What we need to understand is: Love isn't enough.

*I don't make up examples or rely on hearsay. If I describe something in my meeting, it is something I have directly witnessed.

Friday, March 26, 2010

The Answer isn't Always What You Expect; Neither Are the Questions

Many of you know that I have been on hiatus from my Quaker meeting since late last May, when someone gave vocal ministry that described a Quakerism I didn't recognize at all, and in response, God whispered in my ear, "You don't need to be here for awhile." I'd have gotten up and left at that moment, except that the kids were getting their annual gift of books from the meeting, and I stayed to collect my kids' books.

I've still been acting as treasurer, but many months I have gone to business meeting just long enough to give my report. This was partly because of health problems that required me to carefully decide how to use my energy--I had, for about a year and half, not even enough spoons to stay awake and out of bed for a whole day, and sitting through business meeting was just too costly. But it was also because I found it hard to be with that group of people.

The reasons I took my hiatus feel complicated and, in some cases, petty. It has been hard to talk about (though I do talk about it an awful lot!) and it has often left me confused. Certain irritations had been growing on me for a long time, and a big handful of painfully offensive conversations I'd had with specific members have stayed with me, unresolved. For a long time, I was cheerfully able to accept that people come to Quaker meeting for different reasons, and that if some people were there to get something different from what I was looking for, that didn't mean I couldn't also find what I needed. But I began to feel that the Quakerism I was looking for was being crowded out by, for instance, liberal politics and a small but vocal number of Friends who were openly hostile to the idea of talking about God.

I've had a very hard time sorting out what things have to do with individuals, and what have to do with the meeting. For instance, one reason I've been uncomfortable with the meeting is the sense that, overall, we are affluent and highly educated, and not especially willing to be aware of our privilege, or think about what it means. And I still think that's true. But when I think back over things people have said that seemed absolutely clueless or hostile or offensive on class issues, it is primarily one person. So, is this a problem with the meeting, or a problem I have with this one person?

Similarly, we have an awful lot of college professors, lawyers, and doctors in our meeting. On the one hand, this creates a certain meeting culture that I wish we were more aware of: for instance, when a grad student comments in Joys and Sorrows that she's taking comps this week, the collective groan of sympathy that passes through the room really says something about who we are. We also tend to use language that goes beyond merely middle-class to--having trouble with words here, a little short on spoons today--erudite, academic, almost jargony. If we want to be a diverse and welcoming meeting, it would be good to be aware that when someone makes a joke about capital gains tax in business meeting and most of us laugh, or someone says about a recent trip to Europe, "I just can't relax unless I'm on another continent, that's just how far away I have to get," and a non-zero number of listeners chuckle in recognition of the sentiment, we are sending powerful signals about who we are. And believe me visitors for whom capital gains tax and trips to Europe are not on their list of active concerns will pick up on those signals. (Full disclosure: I was the one who made the joke about capital gains tax. And then immediately wished it back. But this is why I say "us, us, us," and not, "them, them, them," when talking about social class and my monthly meeting.)

None of that makes us bad people. It makes us who we are, and I only wish that, as a group, we were willing to think more about that. But it's mixed up in my mind with hurtful interactions I've had with specific people: for instance, only two people in my whole life have ever patronized or condescended to me because I am a housewife. Both of those people are college professors who are members of my meeting. I cannot always tell where the line is between "some people in my meeting are like this," and "my meeting is like this."

I don't want to slip into my Litany of Complaint here. The short version is that I often find myself not sharing specific values that seem to be taken for granted by many in the meeting; that I am interested in pursuing a possible call to a ministry that is not supported in liberal Quakerism; that I want a more religious religion than many Red Cedar Friends seem comfortable with; that I am troubled and discouraged by vocal ministry that draws on NPR and The New York Times for inspiration, or is what the British call "daffodil ministry" ("I saw daffodils blooming on the way to the meetinghouse this morning..."). The specific vocal ministry that inspired God to let me take a break from my struggles was so different from my own understanding of Quakerism's historical roots and influences that either the person offering it was sadly misinformed, or I need a refresher course.

The problem is that not attending meeting didn't end my struggle. It just gave me a short break from it. After some months, all the questions started rising up for me again, but my thinking is no clearer--I rehearse the same old complaints, questions, and doubts, but don't find movement. I took God's message very seriously--that "for awhile" implied to me that I would be back at Red Cedar someday. But the months passed and I was not led to return. Last month, inspired by the Lenten reflections of my friend Pastor Julie, I decided to try going back as a Lenten discipline. I went twice. It was horrible both times. The second time I found myself so wounded and angered by something that happened during the social hour that I cried in the car on the way home.

Now, I find myself considering the possibility that I may never go back. My term as treasurer ends in May, and I am supposed to serve on the Adult Religious Education committee. This seems like a good fit for me, something I should be excited about. The meeting is going to experiment with regular ARE activities twice a month, now that we're in our own meetinghouse. I love leading study and discussion groups, and book groups. I spent the first few months of my hiatus reading deeply and widely on religious subjects, and have many ideas for materials that might be of interest to the meeting. I have been bitching for years about the Gospel of The New York Times; this is a chance for me to put my money where my mouth is and join with other members of my meeting in religious reading and discussion.

But, right this minute, my heart is just not in it. I was actually considering last week whether I ought to let the meeting know they should find someone else to fill my spot. And then, yesterday I got a nice e-mail from the Worship and Pastoral Care committee telling me that they would be providing Connecting Kids to Quakers money for my children to attend FGC Gathering: a total of $720 for my three kids. I found that I wasn't sure I felt comfortable accepting the money; David says I should, he says it's premature to think of myself as no longer part of the meeting or undeserving of the services it provides. But I feel a pang, and think it's possible I accepted David's argument so readily not because I feel he's right, but because without that money, the kids and I can't go to Gathering, and I want to go. The fact that my reaction to the message was to feel uncomfortable about the money tells me something important, I think, about my relationship to my meeting and where it might be going.

God said eight words to me, and I thought I understood them perfectly well: You get to take a break, and then you come back. But what if I'm wrong? I've been waiting for way to open, and for that way to be a door back into Red Cedar. I thought it would look like one of those internal shifts where you find yourself able to transcend the pettiness, accept things as they are, open your heart so wide that people who used to hurt and disappoint you are objects of sympathy and affection. Or maybe, I thought, God would give me a word to speak, a clear leading about how to be different in my meeting, a ministry that could be heard there; God might transform me from a whining, self-pitying, over-sensitive complainer into someone with something meaningful to offer, an agent of grace.

But what if God is cutting me loose? Can it really be true that God no longer wants or needs me to be a Quaker in a monthly meeting? Is there someplace else I'm needed? How would I know? I thought I'd have answers by now, but all I have is a new set of questions I never thought I'd be asking.

Well (she said briskly, dusting her hands) they don't have to be answered this minute. This minute, there's a Yehva-related mess in the kitchen that needs to be cleaned up, a shower to be taken, a worryingly sick cat to be taken to the vet, a grocery list to be written, bills to be paid.