Wednesday, June 6, 2012

Another Satisfied Customer

When I was in my early 20s, and my mom was in her mid-50s, she went to school at our local community college. She hadn't been in school since graduating from high school at the age of 16, but she did well and enjoyed it. She told me one time, though, that when she sat down in class she would take out a clean piece of paper for taking notes, and she would write across the top of it "KYMSUCUJ."

This meant: Keep Your Mouth Shut Until Called Upon, Joanne. It was supposed to keep her from blurting out inappropriate jokes in class.

From this single anecdote, you will readily infer that I am much like my mother. I look like her, I have her sense of humor, I have her tendency to blurt things out, her inclination to the slightly off-color, and her habit of sharing too much information. She is a collector and teller of family stories, as well. Truly, I am an apple that did not fall far from the tree in this case.

My dad, though? At first glance, we are nothing alike. He doesn't think about the past much; or, if he does, he doesn't talk about it. He doesn't talk about much, in general. He's taciturn and cranky. His default facial expression is a forbidding scowl. Once, on a family vacation, my mom, my brother, and I were waiting outside some touristy welcome center while he went in to pick up a map or something. He came out the door, carrying the map and wearing his characteristic frown. My mom said, "Another satisfied customer!" and we all cracked up. This became a running joke which only he failed to see the humor in.

In the last couple of years, though, I've noticed some of the ways he influenced me. That he was not just something to react against in my childhood and young adult years.

My two oldest kids are left-handed, color-blind boys. In this, they are the image of their grandfather. Word Boy's big square head? Grandpa. The Lego Savant's ability to build anything, and his interest in mechanisms? Grandpa.

Their rigidness and inflexibility? Grandpa, too. Since he always had power over me, I saw him as ridiculously controlling. My dad believes there is one right way to do everything, and that way is his way. (I've probably told you the story from when I was a teenage girl with long, thick hair, and my dad got mad at me for using too much shampoo. He showed me how much shampoo he used--a tiny dot in the palm of his hand--and informed me that this was how much I should also use. This from a man who was already bald when he got married at the age of 24.)

I watch my kids, though, and wonder how much of my dad's tendency to be controlling was about his own emotional comfort. When I watch Word Boy struggle with perfectionism, or fall to pieces when presented with a question that has no single right answer, I see my dad. When the Lego Savant tries to micro-manage the whole family so that his environment can be comfortable for him, I see my dad. When I think about my own inflexibility--which I didn't fully recognize until I became a mom and had less control over my time and environment than I'd ever had before--I see myself in my dad, and my dad in me. I recently read a blog post (which I can't find now but will link to if it turns up) in which the writer said, "I have to write 'be spontaneous' in my calendar, or I'll forget to do it," and that is a pretty good description of me, as well. I used to think my dad was very controlling of his loved ones because we were his loved ones, and that he was trying to take care of us and keep us safe by guiding us very carefully, with attention to every minute detail.

I still think that.

But now I wonder if he wasn't also managing some form of the anxiety that seems to run in our family. Or suffering from a mild version of anxiety's stepsibling, obsessive-compulsive disorder (my first actual psychiatric diagnosis was "Generalized Anxiety Disorder with Obsessive-Compulsive Tendences." Now I wonder if they shouldn't just print that right on the birth certificates of new babies born into my family).

I'm like my dad in other ways, too, if you look behind the superficial. My dad keeps busy building things, fixing things, planning to build things. He spent most evenings and weekends throughout my childhood in his very well-equipped garage, doing god only knows what with power tools. My brother is like this, too--they live next door to each other and have quite the impressive pole barn workspace, with heat and a little fridge and microwave. My brother has build a dune buggy (from scratch!) and a race car (from a regular car) out there.

I used to think my dad and I were not alike: he works with his hands, whereas I am a word person. While he's rebuilding an engine, I'm reading something or writing something or taking a class on something. If my home needs a minor repair, I can live with that quite comfortably for a good long time--indeed, I recently noticed something small that needed fixing ( I can't remember what now) and realized that it had been broken for six months and it had never occurred to me to fix it.

My dad, on the other hand, read exactly one book the whole time I was growing up (though he and my mom have been hooked on audiobooks they listen to together for some years now).

So, just how are we alike in all this?

We both like to be busy. We both are always planning and doing projects. We are both quick to volunteer our expertise--you need a new driveway poured? He's there. You need a press release written for your non-profit organization? I'm happy to do that for you.

My dad, despite his habitual scowl, has a wonderful capacity for maintaining relationships, as well. All the years I was growing up, we only went on three vacations-for-vacation's-sake. But we traveled a lot. We spent many weekends at my grandma and grandpa's house in the woods up north; we drove as often as twice a year to Virginia, where we visited my dad's best friend Kevin and his family. We probably logged thousands of miles around Michigan visiting my dad's counsins and aunts and uncles and old friends from high school or college. We were always off to see somebody.

Even now, when my parents take their annual RV trek to the warmth of the southwest, they give much of their time to meeting up with relatives and friends in Arizona and southern California.

My dad and Kevin have been close friends since they were in the Army together in the 50s, and they have probably seen each other 2-3 times a year almost every year for all that time. My dad's other best friend, John, was his office mate when they were both hired as entry-level engineers at GM in the early 60s. Sometimes when Kevin makes one of his rare visits to Michigan, John and Kevin and my dad sit around the dining room table drinking beer, and John and Kevin have drunken pseudo-arguments about which one is really my dad's best friend. At least, they used to when I was young.

Like my dad, I love old friends--I keep saying that one of the benefits of middle age that nobody tells you about in advance is that you start to have friends you've known for 20, 30, 35 years. Like my dad, I rarely travel just to go see a place. Though I am not close to my extended family, I'm very close to an extended chosen family and I travel multiple times a year to be with these people. When I worry that I might lose a friend, because someone moves away, for instance, I think of my dad and the role model he is for not letting mere geography control his relationships.

(And I have many pleasant mental images of my dad laughing with his friends. He can relax the scowl when he's around them--or around his grandkids.)

I suppose I've been a cliche all my life--hard at work differentiating from my parents as a young adult, finding more common ground as a no-longer-young adult. But I would say that this is also one of the satisfactions of middle age for me.

My dad spent the day at my house today, working on fixing up my breezeway. He's putting in all-new screens, a new floor, and new doors. I worked on my front yard, weeding and moving some things around and getting ready for a big delivery of mulch. Partway through the day, I posted this as a status update on Facebook:

I have just peeked my head into the breezeway to admire my dad's work. We chat a bit.

Me: Well, I'm going to get back to work in the front yard.

Dad: Why don't you get those kids out here to help you?

I laugh.

Dad: Why are you all "ha ha"? They're old enough.

Me: I know. And they will help. They like helping in the yard. I'm laughing because I'm 46 years old and you're still bossing me around.

Dad: Well, that's the way I am.

Me: I know. That's why I laughed instead of getting mad.

We both laugh and then we go about our business.

Saturday, June 2, 2012

Speak at Your Own Peril: "It's Just a Phase"

Yesterday we had lunch at a Burmese restaurant. I will be ever-grateful to our friend ODG for taking us there. Our family is in Philadelphia for the TransHealth conference, and are just a few blocks from Chinatown. The Tiny Tornado loves Chinese food, so we've been strolling down there every day, and having the kind of wonderful meals where we are all passing plates around saying, "Try this! Have a bite of this!" The Burmese food was a great new experience. Similar to other Asian foods, but with a different kind of flavor and spiciness. I had a chicken dish that made me understand why people go on and on about the flavors in food--I'd put a bite in my mouth, and it tasted lemony but not sweet, with an undertone of smokiness. Then, as the lemon flavor faded, a spicy heat would rise up to take its place. I couldn't eat it quickly, because this layering and progression of flavors was so worth experiencing that I had to wait it out each time. Wowza.

Anyway, I was complaining at lunch about people saying that the Tiny Tornado's interest in boy things and boy clothes is "just a phase." Sometimes they use those exact words, and sometimes they simply imply them. Someone told me yesterday that she knew authoritatively that children do not have a fixed gender identity until age 6 (tell that to the 11-year-old girl I met yesterday who transitioned male-to-female before starting kindergarten). Another said that she thought all kids would be wildly gender creative and exploratory if they were free to do so, which begs the question of why my two older kids, certainly as free to do so as my youngest, were only mildly gender-transgressive as young kids. And someone also told me yesterday (I get this one a lot, but only from people who haven't actually met the Tiny Tornado and encountered the force of his will) that the TT is "trying to be like her older brothers," or "emulating her dad." Which, again, begs the question of all the girls with older brothers they love and admire who nonetheless do not dress like them and demand that everyone call them "he."

But, yes, someone also said to me yesterday, in so many words, "it's probably just a phase."

I was complaining about this at lunch, and the Lego Savant said, "Really? Someone said that to you here? You'd think all the people at a place like this would know better." Sometimes the Lego Savant surprises us. He seems to sail through life blissfully unaware that a surprising proportion of his adult friends and loved ones are gay, lesbian, transgendered, transsexual, or queer in various other ways, or that these things are seen as deviant in some places and by some people. Every now and then, though, he comes out with something that makes us realize that he has been paying attention all along, understands a great deal, and has some insight to share.

Anyway: those of you who are my Facebook friends may already know that on Thursday morning when we arrived at the conference, the Tiny Tornado was asked which pronouns he preferred so that it could be indicated on his nametag. You can probably guess from that sentence that he chose the boy pronouns.

I could do a whole digression here about how he has never seemed to care too much about pronouns before, but now I wonder if it just hadn't really occurred to him because nobody had offered him the option before. Because suddenly he cares very much about the pronouns, even getting angry at the Lego Savant yesterday when LS slipped and called him "she." (An apology, a hug, and an explanation that we're all doing our best but will slip sometimes seemed to resolve that.)

But: today I am talking about the expression "it's just a phase." Because, as I said at lunch, the next person who says this to me is going to get a fork in the Adam's Apple. (Metaphorical fork. Metaphorical Adam's Apple. I am a Quaker, after all.)

Because, listen: this phrase is not only dismissive of my child's self-understanding and how important it is to him right now, but it implies that anything we do in our lives for only a while, any exploration we undertake is somehow unimportant if it doesn't lead to permanent change.

Raider ViaDude (my new anagrammatic pseudonym for my sweetie) went to a presentation yesterday afternoon where the speaker said that the few studies that have been done show that about 25-40% of kids who are transgendered before puberty actually fully transition. Some reach puberty and discover they're actually gay, for instance, or otherwise have some different understanding of themselves than "I must be a girl" or "I must be a boy." [Insert digression here on the very interesting distinction made in the parent support group the other day between "expression" and "identity." I'll save it for another post.]

So there's really a pretty good chance that the Tiny Tornado will not permanently identify as male, or choose to transition. But that doesn't mean that what's going on now is "just" anything. Clearly it is a very important exploration for him, something he feels strongly about and is enjoying (you should have seen him glow when I helped him find some shorts he could wear as swim trunks, instead of his tankini, to the trans families pool party last night).

When I think about my own life, there are some things that were "phases" but were nonetheless very formative for me. One that comes immediately to mind whenever I think about something like this is my flirtation with punk rock when I was 18 and 19. I was never really a punk rocker, more of a hanger-on wannabe, but being exposed to that subculture and that music did good things for me.

Recently, I spent a year or so seriously considering attending seminary, culminating in a visit during a prospective student weekend. But within a few weeks of that visit, which I enjoyed, it had become clear to me that I was not going to attend seminary, and I have not had a tinge of regret or any residual urges about it.

Was that "just" a phase? Or was that me spending some time asking an important question about my life, which was eventually clearly answered in the negative?

So, you know, when people say that the Tiny Torndao is "just" going through a phase with his gender explorations, it irks me. It irks me because even if tomorrow, or next month, or in a year he says, "You know what, mom, I'm really a girl and I feel very sure about that," that doesn't mean that this time of wanting to be seen as a boy, treated as a boy, talked to and talked about as a boy, is "just" anything. It's the life he's living now. It's him asking a really important question.

We don't need to wait ten years to find out whether he's "really" trans to know that his life right now, at 4 years old, matters. There is no "just" at all about a little person living a great big life.

Tuesday, May 29, 2012

Last Human Standing

I woke up this morning thinking about my friend Farina Endfen, certainly because of our plans to have lunch today. But I think about her a lot, with great admiration for the work she does. Farina is a Physician Assistant in a prison in Ohio.

Before she made a mid-life career change to be a PA, she was a medical social worker. She worked in a hospital in Detroit, on a unit for closed-head injuries. Many of the patients had been gunshot. At least once, they had two patients at the same time who were members of rival gangs, and when their friends came to visit them things could be...tense. One of her jobs was finding people long-term placements when their time in the brain injury rehab unit ended. All the social workers knew that people's options were limited, and that they sometimes--often?--placed people into substandard facilities because there were no other options. But they would keep looking, hoping to find something better.

Except, it seemed to Farina, that in staff meetings to discuss case dispositions, her boss was more inclined to encourage the social workers to keep looking if the patient was white, and more likely to encourage them to make a quick and easy placement into a bad facility if the patient was black. So she said so. And then she started refusing to disclose her patients' race during these meetings.

Because that is the kind of thing she does.

She worked as a social worker in a community health center, and, after earning her second master's and becoming a PA, in the worst hospital in Detroit. Resources were scarce, there were more patients than beds, and many of her patients were gun shot victims or addicts, some of them with septic wounds from injecting with dirty needles, some of them with assorted diseases and injuries, and some of them just drug-seeking.

One of the things I've always respected about her is that she has always worked with poor people, with addicts, with criminals, and it's not that she doesn't judge so much as she is able to maintain her sense of these folks as human beings. Even when a drug-seeking addict is trying to manipulate her into giving him drugs, she still feels compassion. And on the occasions when they succeed--like when a patient at the prison clinic got her to write a Vicodin prescription for him and then was seen playing basketball in the yard an hour or so later--she doesn't take it too hard. She figures they don't get past her too often.

She likes some things about her work at the prison. One benefit of working with underserved populations is that she has more independence as a PA than she would have elsewhere. She gets to diagnose, for instance, which she likes. And she gets to do lots of minor surgical procedures, which she loves and is good at, in part because the guys at the prison get lots of boils and infected toenails (which she is terrific at removing, but whatever you do don't let her describe the process, and for God's sake don't let her show you the pictures). They also get lots of wounds that need to be stitched up, and while she doesn't like it that they go around poking each other with sharpened things, she does a great job fixing them up.

She likes being able to say to me, "Hey, wanna see what I took out of a guy today?" and pull a bullet out of her pocket. She has a whole collections of bullets she's taken out of people. Over months or years they work their way near to the surface, or into an uncomfortable place, and if one is bugging a guy, she'll remove it for him.

Other things, she doesn't like so much. She hates the bureaucratic stupidity that bans anything that could be a potential weapon, but then issues heavy padlocks to the prisoners. A padlock in a sock, it turns out, makes a great bludgeon and leaves a very distinctive crescent-shaped would. Farina has treated many of these wounds.

She doesn't mind the murderers, she says. And, while she can spot a domestic abuser right away because of their transparent attempts to dominate her space, she can hold her own with them. What she has more and more trouble dealing with are the child molesters and rapists. I remember she had one guy, a rapist if I remember correctly, brought to her with a broken leg. All she had to do was relieve his pain and stabilize him for transport to the ER. She didn't want to. She didn't want to relieve his pain. She didn't want to handle his leg in the least painful way possible.

She did it. She made herself do it. But she didn't want to.

A few months ago she had a patient who had drowned his two toddlers in the bathtub, not all that long ago. Uncharacteristically, she asked the corrections officer who accompanied him to come into the exam room--usually they wait outside. "Scared of this guy, huh?" the officer said to her. "No," Farina said. "I'm afraid if someone else isn't in there I won't behave appropriately."

Usually the patients are well-behaved with her. She has something they want, she says, and she treats them well. Indeed, she has a reputation among the prisoners for being competent and respectful. She's been at the prison a few years now, and the rotating staff of doctors have one important thing in common: they are all incompetent. More than once she has resolved a patient's long-term problem by making a diagnosis that, she says, is "first-year med school stuff," but which had been missed for months or even years. But the doctors just don't look at the patients enough. They just don't care enough. And they just don't know enough.

One day, on her way out of work, a prisoner called from the yard to thank her for arranging for his transport to the nearby city hospital for a test he needed. But when would he get his results? he asked. "Oh, you're scheduled with Dr. So-and-so on Monday, he'll take care of you," she answered. The man said, "He'll see me, but we all know it's you who takes care of us."

One patient did grab her breast one time. She stepped back, yelled, and pushed her panic button. Nearby staff, hearing her yell, also pushed their panic buttons. This shuts the whole prison down: the officers get the prisoners back to their cells, a little squadron comes on the trot to where the button was pushed. The prisoner ends up in solitary.

It's not funny, of course. But she was getting ready to remove a growth on his neck at the time. I can't help wondering how stupid or desperate you need to be to grope a woman who is literally bending over you with a scalpel to your throat.

All of this is old news. Farina's been telling me these stories all along, usually with a good dose of gallows humor. But a month or two ago, we were out to dinner with an old friend who was passing through town, and in response to some of his questions, she got talking about dealing with rapes.

The corrections officers, she says, collude so as not to witness rape. The staff on the night shift see nothing and hear nothing. All rape victims are found in their cells by the morning staff. The assumption is that there was a fight, and both parties are treated as potential perpetrators until there can be a hearing, usually after a week or more. In the meantime, they're brought to the clinic in shackles and then kept in isolation until the hearing.

If Farina is on staff that morning, she will treat the victim on-site. This means examining him in shackles, with an officer present, and doing any treatment she needs to--stitches, for instance, are common--under those conditions as well. But the benefit of treating them there instead of transporting them to the hospital is that she knows she will do a good job of stitching, and she will be as compassionate as she can be, and she won't add to their trauma by being abusive.

The corrections officers, she says, are exactly as the stereotypes would lead you to expect. They are ignorant, brutal, racist, and homophobic. But it behooves her to cultivate good relationships with them. She does this by treating minor wounds, and by writing them antibiotic prescriptions for the STDs they routinely acquire.

She keeps a careful mental tally of just how high her standing is with the officers. "If it's high enough," she says, "once in awhile I can ask for something that will make things easier for a rape victim. I can get his shackles removed for his exam, or I can get the officer to step outside so he can tell me honestly what happened, or I can just show him more sympathy when he cries than the officers would normally let me get away with."

"How often do you deal with this?" I asked.

She said, "Two or three times a week." Two or three days a week she comes into work and examines a shackled and brutalized rape victim who will then be put into isolation for a week or more. Once in awhile, if she writes enough antibiotic prescriptions for a bunch of guys who don't know enough to wear a condom, if she ignores enough racial slurs and homophobic cracks over enough days and weeks, she can take this little pellet of goodwill she has earned and spend it to make that exam just a tiny bit less terrible.

She can do nothing, she says, for the gay prisoners, for the trans prisoners. The culture is too toxic; there is not enough goodwill in the world. There is a crack she can pry open just a hair so she can get this prisoner a CT scan, or that prisoner a better diagnosis and appropriate treatment for a leg injury, or the shackles taken off one rape victim in, what, 20? 30? But the homophobia is an impenetrable wall.

She's going to leave the prison before too long. I hope so, anyway. I'd like to see her working in a nice clean well-stocked suburban clinic, treating, oh, poison ivy and splinters, doing punch biopsies on suspicious moles and stitching up the cuts people get trying to open cans of cat food. Where nobody gets shivved, and she doesn't have to carry a panic button in her pocket or be searched on the way into work, and rape is not part of her daily life. She has done her share, and more. She deserves the easy job now.

But I'll be sorry, too, just like I was when she left the addicts and drug-seekers and gunshot victims in Detroit. Because it so often looks to me like she is the last line of defense between these people and the complete inhumanity of the institutions they are trapped in. She is the last human in their lives, because she is the only one who sees their humanity.

Saturday, May 26, 2012

Infant Piety, A Cheetah-Colored Bird, and the Pirate Wench

1.

Raider ViaDude and I took five kids to a Renaissance Festival today: our three, and two brothers who are friends of the Lego Savant and Word Boy. When we arrived in Marshall, where the festival was being held, the weather was cold and rainy. Needing lunch in any case, we decided to forego fast food in favor of a leisurely meal at what was called Win Schuler's back in the day, a nice steak place in a historic hotel.

The five kids were very well-behaved in the restaurant, placing their orders clearly and politely, thanking the server, getting loud only at infrequent intervals. They discussed books (the older four, anyway) and drew pictures while we waited for our food. Our 9-year-old friend, who I'll call The Explainer, was so pleased with his meal that he left his own tip, out of his spending money, in addition to mine.

At the end of the meal, the kids were getting restless, so Raider took them outside while I waited for our check. When the server brought it, she said to me, "Wow, five boys! And all so well-behaved."

I was tempted, for just a moment, to bask in her praise, but I fessed up to some of the kids just being with us for the day.

When I caught up with the rest of the group, I told them what the server had said. Our 12-year-old friend, who I'll call The Armorer because he makes the most wonderfully accurate shields, helmets, breastplates, and so on out of cardboard and whatever bits and pieces are lying around, said, "When we get comments like that, our mom rewards us."

The Lego Savant said, "You know what my reward is when I hear about a comment like that? Just getting the comment. Just knowing someone said it."

Which was very sweet, but brought instantly to mind this favorite passage from Jane Eyre:
“Do you say your prayers night and morning?” continued my interrogator.

“Yes, sir.”

“Do you read your Bible?”

“Sometimes.”

“With pleasure? Are you fond of it?”

“I like Revelations, and the book of Daniel, and Genesis, and Samuel, and a little bit of Exodus, and some parts of Kings, and Chronicles, and Job and Jonah.”

“And the Psalms? I hope you like them?”

“No, sir.”

“No? oh, shocking! I have a little boy, younger than you, who knows six Psalms by heart: and when you ask him which he would rather have, a gingerbread-nut to eat, or a verse of a Psalm to learn, he says: ‘Oh! the verse of a Psalm! angels sing Psalms,’ says he; ‘I wish to be a little angel here below;’ he then gets two nuts in recompense for his infant piety.”

“Psalms are not interesting,” I remarked.
The Lego Savant earned his second gingerbread-nut today. And I'm just glad he was with homeschoolers and not on a public school playground, or he'd surely have been walloped.

(Our long lunch served us well, by the way. We came out to a pleasantly cool overcast, and the sun didn't come out and start baking things until we were just about ready to leave the festival anyway.)

2.

I have heard of musical prodigies, and math prodigies, and chess prodigies. But it had never occurred to me there could be bird-watching prodigies until one showed up in my own family. The Tiny Tornado keeps a close eye on the birds at our birdfeeders, and is often the first one to spot a new bird. When she does, she loves to tell us about it, and she is very good at describing them. Often we can then find them in our bird book.

The other night, Raider was out doing errands, and the Tiny Tornado told me excitedly, "I saw a new bird! It had a reddish head and (patting her belly) was colored like a cheetah."

I had no idea what she was talking about, and although we checked our book and both the Sibley and Peterson iPad apps, she and I couldn't find her bird.

Raider got home and saw the bird book sitting on the table. "Did somebody look up a bird?" he asked.

"We tried to," I said. "The Tornado saw a new bird but we couldn't find it. She said it had a reddish head and was colored like a cheetah."

Raider said excitedly, "A Northern Flicker! What a wonderful description!"

I give you The Red-Headed Cheetah-Colored Bird:


3.

This year, I promised myself, I would get "garb" for the Ren Fests. There is a seamstress on etsy who I was going to have make me a beautiful medieval surcoat. But today I impulsively bought a red leather tricorn hat, which will not go with the surcoat at all no matter how much I pretend not to care about historical authenticity. In fact, it pretty much locks me into Pirate/Wench looks. Not that I'm opposed to that. It just means I'm back to square one in my shopping.

I told Raider, "We did great today. Except for our extravagant lunch and my $50 hat, we stuck right to our budget for the day!"

Word Boy bought a skunk skull from the guy at the fur booth. I knew as soon as I saw the skulls that he would want one, and be transported with joy from it. And so it was.

The Lego Savant wants garb, too. Mostly he wants a cloak, though if he could have a whole shirts/pants/bow with quiver/cloak thing he'd have the whole Ranger's Apprentice look going, which is what he wants:


This month, as I've been posting almost daily, my pageviews have more than doubled--easy to do when the numbers start out so small. Several people have let me know how much they like my blog, or a particular post.

I love getting these comments. But I also like having readers, so next time you like something, tell me if you must, but I'd be grateful if you'd also tell a friend.

Thursday, May 24, 2012

The Post-Preschool Experiment, Day 1: Report of Subject #1


My captors have isolated me with a tiny humanoid. It looks innocent--indeed, its appearance evokes in me a kind of atavistic instinct to nurture and protect it. It seems in all ways like living flesh but I think it must be a construct of some kind as no living thing could be so indefatigable and relentless. It has recently gone into some kind of resting mode; perhaps I will have an opportunity to examine it more closely, though its resting platform is guarded by two beasts, small furry creatures it calls "dogs," which, though small, make ferocious noises and are possessed of fangs.

I do not know how long the resting mode will last. I must write quickly.

I have learned that when the tiny humanoid utters the nonsense syllable "mom," it is seeking my attention. Using this attention-seeking strategy, which becomes louder and evolves into the two-syllable "mommy" if I do not respond quickly enough, it issues contradictory requests and disconnected pronouncements at intervals of approximately 6-10 seconds at all times when not in resting mode. I am obligated to respond to these requests although it is not possible to fulfill them all. I do my best to comply although I am exhausted by the effort.

I do not know what the tiny humanoid is capable of; I fear its punishment. Sometimes it arms itself.


And it is a master of disguise.


It seems to have an "argumentation" subroutine installed which leads it to reject every proposal I make or proposition I utter. Its programming is clearly sophisticated, yet a bug in its code causes it to misunderstand the word "no" or any other negative response as permission to proceed. My only respite comes when it turns its attention to the other beings that share our enclosure, these "dogs." They do not speak but also demand my attention and care, as do some minute caged creatures the tiny humanoid refers to as "hamsters." In addition to the other challenges I face, I must protect these creatures from the tiny humanoid's depredations.

I do not know what purpose my torment serves: amusement for some hidden observer? some scientific purpose? punishment? I only know I must endure. Perhaps someday I may return to the life I knew before. Dreamlike and half-remembered, it nonetheless gives me hope. In the meantime, I ingest vast quantities of a stimulating sugary beverage with which the food cooling unit is stocked, and visit the personal hygeine cubicle as often as possible. There I may gain a few precious seconds of peace before my tiny tormentor tracks me down. The sound of its voice calling "mom" from the other side of the door fills me with dread. What will it ask of me next?


Wednesday, May 23, 2012

Reality Television, Baader-Meinhof, & More About Memoir

Until recently, I had never watched a reality TV show. It's not that I'm above bad TV; there is some bad TV I love. But I never have much time for watching TV, and I didn't think reality TV was likely to be my thing. I find it excruciating to watch people be awkward or embarrassed (this is part of why I also rarely watch sitcoms). I assumed that reality television would have a lot of that kind of thing, and that it would be tacky and stupid and full of people being mean to each other.

Recently, though, it occurred to me that I had let this whole cultural phenomenon pass me by, and so, sometimes, late at night, when there's nothing else on, I have been dipping into reality TV. I've watched 10 minutes of Hoarders, 7 minutes of Dance Moms, and as much as 5 minutes of several other shows. Usually that's all I can handle, because it's pretty much exactly like I imagined.

Last night, though, I watched an entire episode of Toddlers & Tiaras. And I might watch another one sometime. It was exactly like I imagined it, and yet...I kind of liked it.

My thoughts on Toddlers & Tiaras:

1. One of the moms named her daughter after the calamari she craved during her pregnancy.

2. Was that one mom really that nasty, or was she playing it up to get screen time?

3. I thought the mom who worked as a wrestling "ring girl" and raised extra money by putting out a sexy calendar of herself was actually quite awesome.

4. I was amused by the winking-at-the-audience way the show undercut the moms' claims about their daughters. "The thing is, Destiny is just a star! She absolutely sparkles!" Cut to Destiny, slumped against a wall, finger shoved up her nose to the second knuckle. Or: "Camari loves doing pageants. She has a total understanding of what it is, more like a 6 or 7 or 8 year old would, she's so mature, and this is just absolutely where she wants to be." Cut to montage of Camari's assorted tantrums as her mom tries to get her to practice her moves, tries to get her into the makeup chair, tries to get her dress on her.

5. The biggest prize you can win in any given pageant is a thousand-dollar savings bond, yet one mom said she had spent over $30,000 on pageants in the last two years, and another one admitted that she had maxed out the family's "emergency" credit card on pageant stuff.

6. The biggest surprise for me was that I thought these kids would actually be talented. I mean, I thought they'd be precocious little hoofers, a whole generation of Shirley Temples. But they were pretty much like any 2- or 3-year-old you've ever met. Their moms usually went on stage with them and pushed them around like little rhinestone-bespackled sacks of meat during the "beauty" portion, and during the "disco" portion, when they were supposed to dance, they usually stood around blankly until their moms, signaling from behind the judges or standing on-stage prompting with whispers, reminded them to do their "moves." Their "moves" were a handful of gestures their mothers had taught them--blowing a kiss, doing a John Travolta disco point, shaking their chubby little hips, putting their hands under their chins and batting their eyelashes--which they did at more-or-less random intervals and which were universally unnatural-looking and somewhat disturbing.

7. The show followed three girls, but there were quick-cut montages of the other contestants. I really wanted to know more about the boy doing the disco bit.

8. One of the girls had a white ring around her mouth because she wouldn't take her pacifier out when she was getting her spray tan.

9. I really missed an opportunity not getting the Tiny Tornado in on this.

Speaking of the Tiny Tornado, a friend posted this to my Facebook wall:


On the one hand, it's perfect. On the other hand, it makes me feel that I could have been more creative in coming up with a pseudonym for her. Who knew "tiny tornado" was a cliche?

Or it's the Baader-Meinhof phenomenon.

So, two days ago I wrote a little stub about memoir and the tension between Art and Relationships. Hit a dead end in the writing, and I still don't have a place for it to go. But I do want to say a bit about the possibilities.

What got me thinking about this issue is that I attended a panel of memoirists at the Festival of Faith & Writing last month, and this question came up. The panelists were asked about how they handled writing about real people, how they dealt with the possibility that what they wrote would hurt someone's feelings, violate their privacy, make them angry. What made me sit up and take notice was that all of the writers on the panel gave priority to their relationships over their writing. They came at this question with an underlying premise--"relationships should be respected" that was the opposite of the one I was acculturated to, "your art is the most important thing."

So each of them had developed strategies for preserving their relationships. One gave her manuscript to people and asked for feedback about how she had written about them, though she reserved to herself the right to make final decisions. Another actually gave some people veto power, though she was an extreme outlier. Many made specific changes to protect people's identities, creating composite characters or putting one person's words into another's mouth. One woman gave a single character all the thoughtless and hurtful things her friends said to her after her daughter was born with Down Syndrome, for instance.

One writer made such dramatic changes to people and situations that I thought she had crossed a line and was no longer writing memoir. For instance, she took a conversation she'd heard two adults have and, in order to disguise their identities, put it into the mouths of two imaginary children on a playground. To me, inventing characters and settings wholesale is fiction.

I was interested, though, to hear them say that much of this was pointless anyway. One writer, after carefully disguising someone, was surprised that everyone figured out who she was anyway (though she refused to confirm their guesses). Another got her brother-in-law's approval for her book, but after it was published he told her that it was different actually having it out there rather than just reading the manuscript, and there were things he regretted allowing her to include.

The other piece of all this is that I feel quite differently about this issue than I did when I was young. I have, in recent years, even found myself relieved that certain pieces were never published, or at least never published in any place my family might happen upon, because they would have hurt my mother, and right now in my my life, I don't want to hurt my mother.

I know people who remain estranged from their families of origin, and for good reason. But I also know many people whose relationships with their families have evolved. I'm one. My parents, for instance, are never going to match up with the picture of ideal parents I have in my mind. But over the years, I've learned to do a better job of taking them as they are; they may not express love in the ways that I craved as a child, but as an adult I can see the ways that they do express it. Despite their failings, I've become very fond of them--not just loving them in the automatic way that children love their parents, but fond of them. I like seeing them. I enjoy spending time with them. I respect them--my mother in particular was an extraordinary young woman who made her own way in the world at age 16 with purpose and intent and discipline.

I have a friend whose childhood was undeniably bad. But she has a pretty good relationship with her father these days. She says, "The thing is, he's a much better parent of grown children than he was of young children." These things are complicated and they change as we change.

As a middle-aged person, I am glad that I didn't recklessly burn any bridges during that young adult time of feeling that my parents had failed me in every possible way. Because my parents, love them as I do, are not the kind of people to get over that kind of thing.

I still have to wrestle with these issues. I am a writer, and the thing I write about most often is my life. This means that if you are in my life, even briefly, I will almost certainly write about you. Sometimes people like this--if I spend time with your kids, I will probably write something about your kids, probably privately, and sometimes I send a collection of what I've written to the parents and they think it's great. On the other hand, sometimes I mention something that seems innocuous to me and it hurts someone's feelings. Or I think I'm being funny and the humor doesn't come through, and they're offended. No one has stopped being my friend because of this, but I know that some of my friends--I'm thinking of one in particular--have a love/hate relationship with my tendency to write about them.

And there are a few things I absolutely long to write about and can't because David doesn't want me to. He is a very private person and is remarkably patient with my tendency to hang our laundry out to dry--indeed, he loves my writing and is my biggest fan--so I try to respect those few things around which he has drawn a line. I try. And I almost always succeed.

Monday, May 21, 2012

What It Was Like When We Were Young & Took Ourselves Way Too Seriously

As a quick aside, I'll mention that I am at the discouraged stage of learning to crochet amigurumi. A month ago, when I started, I was just thrilled to be able to do it at all, and if things came out a little lopsided, well, I didn't mind. Now I am ambitious. I really wanted the Tiny Tornado's hamster to come out well, and it...didn't. (Not that she minds.) I'm disappointed. This is the part where it's hard to stick with it until my skills catch up with my higher ambition.

And now, our feature attraction:

Years ago, when I was a Serious Writer hanging out with many other Serious Writers, I participated in many conversations about what responsibility, if any, a writer had to the people she wrote about in memoir or poetry. In my MFA program, at OutWrite (the Gay & Lesbian Writers' Conference I attended for many years), in casual coffee-shop conversations, we talked about it. And talked about it.

Being queer and feminist, we saw the writing we did about our own lives as important. We were always "breaking silence." People were writing about child abuse, sexual abuse, rape, harassment. About childhood crushes, same-sex experimentation, the hidden homosexuals in our family tree. One year during my MFA program, I swear half the class showed up with stories about their grandmothers' abortions.

All of this felt very meaningful. We saw ourselves as the inheritors of the second-wave feminists of the 60s and 70s, of the wild energy that drove the crowd at Stonewall. We thought it was an act of courage to write honestly about women's lives, about lesbians' lives, about children's lives. We thought it mattered to tell these stories. We thought it mattered to us, as we made sense of our lives and grew into our work. We thought it mattered to the broader culture, which had simply chosen to ignore a great deal for a long time and needed a reckoning. We thought it mattered to other women, to other lesbians, to girls and boys who didn't have words for their experiences, and who didn't know they weren't alone. In many ways, we were late to the party: second-wave feminism's mad ferment was already starting to die down, and Stonewall's 20th anniversary had come and gone. But we felt like we were part of it.

On the other hand, we didn't see much reason to be loyal to the people we might write about: mom, dad, the great-uncle with the roving hands, the drunken grandpa, the big brother or cousin who had much to say on the subject of dykes and faggots. My first lover's father sent out word on the family grapevine that he knew we were lesbians and he wasn't upset about it and nothing bad would happen, he just wanted her to be honest with him. So she was, and he suddenly realized he could no longer afford to pay her college tuition or help with living expenses. My own parents responded to my coming-out letter by not saying a word about it (the letter, or the topic) for a good fifteen years. I had one friend who'd been institutionalized as a teen for being bisexual. My David, an only child, lost both his parents in the same year, and was attacked by his uncle for bringing his same-sex partner--who had lived with his parents and cared for them in their illnesses--to his own mother's funeral.

In the realm of bad things that happen to people who are queer, most of our complaints were small. But we were connected, through our broader community, to people much worse things had happened to, were still happening to. We were just old enough to have been a part of the AIDS crisis; we'd seen The Normal Heart in Greenwich Village, we'd volunteered with Gay Men's Health Crisis, we'd viewed The Quilt at the March on Washington in 1987, and stood silent and tearful in front of the panels of friends and acquaintances and loved ones. Sometimes they were panels we'd sewn. We felt--even us lesbians--like we were part of a community that was under attack in a time of grief.

My point is, that when anyone asked whether what we were writing and publishing and reading out loud might hurt someone, we tended to say, "Who cares?" If we were accused of abandoning all family loyalty, well, for the most part they abandoned us first.


When I started writing this, I knew where I wanted to go. But I can't get there from here. I can't seem to get anyplace else, either. I've been banging my head against it for the better part of the afternoon, while the laundry molders and the children run amok. I give up. I didn't want to write a whiny rant; I wanted to start with this thing I'd been thinking about Art v. Relationships and take it someplace more nuanced and thoughtful. But the Muse laughs!

So, I'll just leave this here. Maybe something more will come of it sometime. Or maybe not. Sometimes all you get is a fragment.