Friday, July 13, 2012

The Things You Find Out About Yourself

I had a couple of surprises at last week's FGC Gathering of Friends. One was that one of the highlights of my week was being invited to meet with a group of polyamorous and kinky Friends. A small group of us met early in the week, and enjoyed it so much that we met again a few days later. That second meeting was one of the deepest, most worshipful parts of my week.

I was surprised by how much meeting with these folks meant to me, because I hadn't thought of polyamory as a central part of who I am. If anything, I see myself as something of a poser--Raider and I claim to be in an open relationship, but it's only been actively opened up a couple of times, and that before we had kids.

Indeed, we've spent most of our 19 years together too busy with other things to have relationships on the side. For the first few years, we were so busy enjoying each other we actually thought we were monogamous. Then, one day in the car, we engaged in one of those "what if" conversations--what if you were at a conference and it was someone you'd never see again? what if it was an ongoing relationship with someone out of town? what if it was someone in town and you wanted to date them in a clearly secondary-to-our-relationship way? what if it was someone in town and you got very serious with them?

And we discovered that none of these scenarios was a deal-breaker for either of us. "Huh," we said. "I guess we're not monogamous. Who knew?"

It was another four or five years before either of us acted on it, though. We got busy with figuring out how to stay in a relationship past the first couple of years, and then in dealing with an undiagnosed anxiety disorder I'd had since childhood, and with one thing and another, there was never a good time. For one thing, we were too darn busy to have time to date. For another, it's never a good idea to start a second relationship when your first one is vulnerable. It's too easy to use the new lover as an excuse to opt out of the work you need to do with the old one.

I'm sure some people do it and make it work. It's not a risk I'm willing to take.

And then, after awhile, all the drama and hard work was behind us. We were stable, settled, happy. And over several months in the summer of 2000, we both had some outside adventures, and it was fine. It was fun, and it was fine.

And then, a few weeks later, I got pregnant with the Lego Savant, and there followed another decade of being just too darn busy. Most parents can attest that nurturing your own relationship during the years you're raising young children is hard enough; I couldn't imagine having the energy or patience for a girlfriend.

In general, for the last decade, I've seen myself settling into life as a very conventional middle-class stay-at-home mom. I felt like I clung to my theoretical polyamory the way I clung to my nose piercing--something that signalled that I wasn't boring and middle American. Or, at least, not just boring and middle American.

I need to digress to say that I don't mean to suggest that heterosexual, monogamously married moms are dull or unworthy. I know many women who are, so far as I know, HMMMs, and they are all awesome. They make mothering into a loving art, they like their husbands, they all have something that isn't their children that they are passionate about, whether that's gardening, art, religion, political and social activism, bread-baking. There's no shame in being one of them, and to the extent that I am one of them, I'm proud to be. This is just a holdover from some anxiety from my youth; it's about me, not about them.

It never occurred to me that I clung to my "theoretical" polyamory because polyarmory is actually part of who I am. That I might not be a poseur trying to be more interesting than I am, but a polyamorous person who just hasn't had the inclination or opportunity to practice much these last two decades.

But I had a lot of time to reflect on the long car ride home, and realized that nearly all of my relationships have been non-monogamous. I've done it well, and I've done it badly. I've done it with women whose care and respect for their lovers were a model to emulate, and I've done it with women whose behavior was a red flag I should have let myself see sooner. I've gotten it so badly wrong that I've hurt someone I care about very much (long since forgiven!), and I've gotten it so right that my girlfriend and I could double-date with her lover and her lover's other lover.

But I've always done it. My first woman lover and I broke up in 1988, and I don't think I have committed to be exclusive with anyone since then (that first few years with Raider, when we mistakenly believed ourselves to be monogamous, are a special case).

Anyway, I wanted to say that until I walked into that room for that meeting last week, I hadn't realized how isolated I have felt among Quakers as a polyamorous person. (And as a person with some unconventional sexual preferences, but I'm not going to talk about that in any detail.) It felt good to be in a circle of folks where I knew I wouldn't be judged, though it actually took us some work to get to that point, because you never know. Unconventional people can be just as prone as anybody else to think that everything on their side of some self-defined line is OK, and anything on the other side is just plain wrong. Nobody wants to face that moment when you make yourself vulnerable only to find out that you were not safe from judgment in that space. But we got there. And it was a good, deep, and worshipful place to be.

I might have another post on this topic in me--thinking about this brought up so many memories: good, bad, funny, sexy. I might write about what, in my experience, works and what doesn't. What are some of the common blunders? What are the red flags you should look for in a new relationship? How do people of good will take care of each other in multiple relationships? I'm no expert, but I spent a few intense years in my 20s learning by trial and error, and I might have a few words to say.

I usually do.

Thursday, July 12, 2012

The Story I Didn't Tell Shani On the Golf Cart

Yesterday, I said that I had three additional blog posts queued up in my brain. I was wrong. All day yesterday, things would come back to me and I would jot them in the "blog ideas" section of my notebook. There aren't three of them. There are ten.

I'd better get to it, then.

We'll start with a relatively light-hearted one, because I have much to do today and don't want to have to think too hard.

The University of Rhode Island campus doesn't have many hills. It pretty much has one. One big hill that the whole place is built on. I found the campus disorienting in general, but as the week wore on, "uphill" and "downhill" became my most useful means of visualizing where things were.

The campus wasn't large, but because of the hill, I ended up using the golf carts quite a bit. Early in the week, I walked everywhere, but after a couple of days I found that my plantar fasciitis was acting up in a very painful way, so I started rationing my walking.

Man, that was two dull paragraphs. I'll try to spice things up.

Anyway, one afternoon my sweet friend Shani and I were taking a golf cart somewhere together--business meeting, maybe? I can't remember. And we were chatting. Being on the golf cart reminded me of a story about a previous golf cart ride I'd taken, and I was about to start telling it when it suddenly occurred to me that our driver might have been the driver of that golf cart, too. Looking at him, it began to seem quite likely, in fact.

Had I told the story then, it would have been a delicious but excruciating irony. As you will understand when you have heard it.

Four years ago, I had injured my knee quite badly and couldn't walk any distance. Somehow, as the gathering grew near, I was able to connect with someone who lent me a scooter for the week. I loved my scooter so much. I could zip around anywhere, I didn't have to wait for golf carts, and with some judicious squeezing (and Baby Tornado in a sling), all three of the kids could ride it with me, which they thought was fun.

I did a lot of FLGBTQC childcare that week. The campus had this wonderful quad with criss-crossing paths that the kids loved to ride their bikes and scooters (the push-with-your-foot kind) around. They were all so enamored of my power scooter that, when I was doing childcare, I also let them drive it around the quad. This was a very popular pastime.

Now, I know that there is a school of thought that mobility tools and accessibility aids are not toys. I get those arguments--they're tools, not playthings. But I also think that they belong to the person who owns them. I've helped my kids understand that it's not OK to touch someone's chair or crutches without permission, for instance. People with disabilities often talk about having their bodily autonomy violated by people who touch them without permission. This is also a thing that happens to children all the time. And so we've worked on making sure that our family knows that curiosity is a fine thing, questions are usually a fine thing, but respect for other people's bodies--and the accessibility aids that they use--is foundational.

I've also noticed that people often give permission when asked--the Tiny Tornado's preschool teacher, for instance, showed the class the lift in her van, and let them try out her daughter's wheelchair, because they were very curious about it. This kind of response to curiosity is healthy, I think. It helps create connections instead of leaving people with disabilities "over there" on the other side of an invisible line.

So, anyway.

Four years ago, I crossed over from temporarily able-bodied to temporarily disabled, and I had a power scooter. It was a wonderful tool for me during that gathering, when I was, as usual, there alone with my three kids and also couldn't walk much. But we also played with it.

Now, this playing was accompanied by conversations with every single kid about respecting individuals' choices about their gear. Yes, I'll let you drive my scooter, but that doesn't mean anybody else with a scooter will let you. They may feel that it's inappropriate, and they get to choose. And, by the way, let me remind you that you should never touch anyone's mobility aids without permission--even if they're not using it right then. (All the kids: "Yeah, we get it already." *eyeroll*)

That was a lot of caveats. Perhaps too much Big Dull Buildup. I just wanted folks to know where I was coming from when I let the kids drive around the quad.

One day, though, I took a golf cart. I don't remember why. Maybe the kids had run down the battery and my scooter was charging. Who knows? But I had this conversation with the driver, which started out awkward and only got worse:

As we drove along, we kept passing people I knew, and I would exchange greetings with them. So I said to the driver, "Do you ever feel like you know everybody here?"

Driver: No.

Me: Oh. Well, I've been coming for a long time, 12 or 13 years.

Driver: I've been at every gathering since 1984.

Me: Oh. Well, I meet a lot of people through my kids.

Driver: My four adult children have been at the gathering every year of their lives.

Me: Oh.

*awkward pause*

At this point, we pass a woman using a power scooter.

Driver: That woman drives me crazy. She has no respect at all. She drives around on her scooter like it's a motorcycle, all these kids hanging off her, and she lets kids drive it around. She has no idea that it's completely inappropriate to do that. It disgusts me.

Me: Actually, that's me you're talking about.

*even more awkward silence until we get to my destination*

I was very amused by this interaction. I know the point of view he ascribes to; I just don't agree with it entirely. "People like that take all the fun out of being disabled," I fumed to David. (Yes, I was joking. Just in case you can't tell. Sometimes people can't.)

I'd never before had someone complain about me, to my face, without realzing it was me they were complaining about. It was a fascinating thing to have happen.

I was also amused by the irony of being lectured on appropriate behavior with regard to the disabled by a person who couldn't tell me and a Black woman with dreadlocks apart. I mean, really: Scooter Woman #2 and I resembled each other not at all. Anyone could tell us apart with the most superficial of glances. There is no excuse for mistaking us for each other except a failure to look past the machine.

So, I was on the golf cart with Shani, and this story came to mind, and then I looked at the driver and realized that he might very well be the same man. In fact, I'm reasonbly sure he was. So I did not tell the story, though it would have been a satisfying conclusion to tell a story about a person not realizing he was talking about me while not realizing I was talking about him.

This man was also, later in the week, the first golf cart driver to question my need for a cart. I have other friends who've had this happen to them, some of them routinely, because they have an invisible disability. But it had never happened to me until this week.

This gentleman was parked outside the dining hall, and the kids and I walked up and asked if he was free to take us somewhere. The kids were excited about riding the golf cart, and he said to me, "The golf carts are not for riding just for fun. I'm not going to take you just because you want to ride and then not be here when someone really needs it."

I said, "It is fun to ride the golf carts. I also need it. But we will wait for another driver."

I was sorry right then that I hadn't taken the time to get a priority rider card--I hadn't done it early in the week because I didn't expect to use the carts, and then I was just too lazy even though I walked past Golf Cart Central every morning on my way to my job at the Info Desk. But I'd have been glad to be able to flash it at him just then.

I hope this man isn't as joyless in general as he has seemed in our interactions. He reminds me of a roommate of mine in grad school who was very involved in several political causes, and she would come home from meetings frothing with anger because people had been having fun. "As if they're at a social event!" She wanted her political activism to be serious, and couldn't see that, for many people, such work is both serious and a social outlet. She disapporoved of chatting and laughter while planning direct action.

If I had a power scooter again--even permanently--I would still let children drive it around. Because I am pro-fun, I am indulgent with children, and I do not believe that my decision to let kids drive my scooter disrespects anyone else, or the decisions they make about their own bodies and their own tools. And I trust children to understand that just because I let them do this doesn't mean they should assume that anyone else will.

That's my choice. I respect that other people make different choices. And I hope that this man has, somewhere in his life, an outlet for frivolity and fun.

Wednesday, July 11, 2012

Some Moments from our Trip to Rhode Island & Boston

We got home about 36 hours ago. I've been doing lots and lots of laundry, spent much of yesterday doing a first clearing-out of my overloaded inbox, and have not yet had the down time I was so sure awaited me here in Michigan.

I have a lot to write about. My brain containts full blog posts on polyamory, the fragrance-free policy at the gathering (and the handing out of soap at registration), and something else I can't remember right now; these were all worked out during the long hours of driving and thinking on the way home. But right now I'm just going to toss out some brief bits to clear the surface detritus.

I have a years-long tradition of flirting with a certain friend of mine when we see each other at gatherings. This year's best moment:

Her: I brought nothing but black shirts.

Me: That's great, because as far as I'm concerned, it's black shirts or nothing.

We also had a fun, if rather obvious, "sleeping together" joke after we both napped through meeting for worship late in the week.

My friend Janis is getting ready to homeschool her daughter this coming school year, and we spent a lot of time this week talking about it, as her deadline for getting some forms into the state was coming up soon. She'll be a natural at it, as this story she told me clearly proves. All my homeschooling friends will recognize themselves in this:

After missing a couple of days of school, her 12-year-old daughter told her that she had missed the unit on reproduction. Janis went into overdrive, pulling out books and queueing up websites and generally making sure her daughter had the most complete, accurate, and healthy information about human sexuality available. She even pulled down a volume of Leonardo da Vinci's anatomoical drawings, including a cut-away view from the side of a man and a woman having intercourse, as well as drawings like this of babies in utero:


After returning to school, her daughter came home and told her that none of the other kids knew any of that stuff. She'd mis-heard a word. Whatever they studied on the days she missed, it wasn't "reproduction."

Visiting the New England Aquarium made Word Boy really hungry for seafood.

The Lego Savant--now 11--was so free-range at the gathering that most days I only saw him at meals and bedtime. Not at meals to eat with, you understand. Merely to see him from across the room, talking and laughing with his friends, and know that he was showing up where he was supposed to when he was supposed to.

Officially, I was required to show up at the beginning and end of every morning and evening session of Junior Gathering to sign him in and out. Unofficially, his friends' parents--and in one case, a grandmother I still haven't met, though the Lego Savant says she's really nice--did it for me most of the time. We parents have done a lot of signing each other's kids in and out over the years, but this year we didn't even coordinate it. Whoever showed up just did it, and then we'd bump into each other walking around and say, "Oh, by the way, I signed the kids in."

I'd sign him out in the evening, tell him, "you're signed out, don't stay out too late," and head back to the dorm. He would show up about half an hour later, though the last night he and a friend stayed to help pack up and he was gone more than an hour.

One morning, without thinking, I tried to kiss him when I saw him in the cafeteria at breakfast, and was rebuffed. But later that very same day, I ran into him and his friends, and he was feeling so happy that he spontaneously gave me a great big hug. He's in a transitional stage of life right now, I'd say. He's been moving back and forth over a line between childhood and adolescence for some time.

Word Boy has become fashion-conscious since his last haircut, which he loves. He actually checks his hair in the mirror in the morning, and he wants his clothes to match. He suffered from a perplexing shortage of clean shorts and t-shirts at the gathering (packing up, we found a bag with more clean ones that had gotten buried, which at least solved the mystery although it came too late to do much good). One day, the only clean t-shirt and shorts he had didn't, in his view, match. Also, the t-shirt was too long. I showed him how to tuck it in, which helped, but he was pretty grumpy about the whole thing until we got to breakfast and someone said, "Hey, looking good, Word Boy." I could have kissed that person.

He has also become fashion-conscious on my behalf. He has favorite outfits, and can be consulted as to color choices. One morning at breakfast, I stood up from the table, and he exclaimed, "Mom! That is my new favorite outfit! That dress, with the black headband...and your new purse. You look perfect!"

Love that kid.

The dress in question has a plunging neckline. For the first time in my life, I had to use double-sided fabric tape to hold it in place. The Tiny Tornado thought double-sided fabric tape was a great idea, and also used it, in his case to keep the collar of his polo shirt just so.

One afternoon, I was watching Word Boy and the Tiny Tornado, as well as a friend's kid--we'll call him The Explainer, because it's perfect for him, even though Word Boy already has a friend I've nicknamed that. Word Boy is attracted to a certain kind of very smart and verbal kid. Practically all of his friends could be called "The Explainer." Word Boy and The Explainers--some day they'll form a band.

One day I came back to the table at lunch to find Word Boy, a boy we'll call That Smart-Talkin' Kid because Explainer 3 starts to get hard to keep track of, and a third kid who might have been Explainer 2 but might have been Word Boy's new friend The Dissector, I can't quite remember--anyway, I came back to the table and the three of them were discussing Leornardo da Vinci's anatomical drawings. It was kind of a theme of the week, apparently. That Smart-Talkin' Kid's mom and I were a bit proud of this moment, though I felt less proud because, until this week, Word Boy hadn't actually heard of da Vinci's anatomy drawings. Which, given his interests, is a huge oversight on my part which I must rectify immediately.

Word Boy had a wonderful time in his Junior Gathering group. He spent lots of time with his oldest Gathering friend, Still Waters, as well as getting closer to Explainer 2 and making new friends in That Smart-Talkin' Kid and The Dissector. He got to spend the afternoon at Still Waters' campground with him and his family, and Explainer 2's mom took him on a late-night trip to see the beach under a nearly-full moon.

As we were packing up to leave on Saturday, my friend Neil asked me how we were doing.

Me: We're doing fine. Word Boy has been having such a wonderful time and has made such good friends that he is absolutely heartbroken about leaving.

Neil: That's great!

A pause. And then we both burst out laughing.

Anyway, I had WB, TT, and Explainer 2, and we were hanging out at this wonderful spot near the cafeteria, a boulder-strewn stream bed that was a favorite of the kids all week (multiple stream-based drenchings account for why I had to do laundry not once, but twice, on this trip). And some dear friends from our yearly meeting were also hanging out there, including a boy about Word Boy's age who we'll call The Force of Nature.




The kids were having such a good time together that I suggested to The Force of Nature's mom that he spend the afternoon with us, too. She thanked me, and then checked in to be sure I was really up for it--The Force of Nature is, shall we way, not an especially compliant child or talented at listening to grown-ups' instructions, though he is very sweet and his intentions are generally good.

I said, "I have had a little practice at dealing with that kind of thing. The Tiny Tornado has been training me. Five years ago, I'd have been completely unprepared. Today? I think I can probably manage."

My three favorite 12-year-old girls in the world:


They roomed right across from us and teased me that they had learned the 6-digit access code for our door because they'd been hearing me coach the Tiny Tornado through it all week. By Friday, he was inputting it and opening the door all by himself.

Here they are doing dorm hall tricks:


Which was very inspiring to the Tiny Tornado:


And this is what we found coming out of FLGBTQC worship one day. That's Word Boy, the Explainer, Katherine, the Tiny Tornado, and Aliyah:


I am already planning for next year in Greeley, Colorado. I know how long a drive it is (about 19 hours actual driving time, 5 hours more than this year's trip to Rhode Island). I'm starting to have some ideas about where we might stop on the way to see interesting things; we might even head north, take I-90 for awhile, and stop at Effigy Mounds National Monument, which I think the kids would love.

I'm planning my budget already, thinking about how I can save up the money we'll need. This isn't a gathering I can start thinking about in March the way I usually do. And I really want to be there next year. I want to see all these kids; I want to see my grown-up friends; I want to flirt with the people I flirt with; I want the kids to see the Rocky Mountains (and to see them myself for the first time in over 30 years).

The narrow, twisty roads and excessive tree cover in New England made me twitchy and claustrophobic. I was so happy to get to Ohio and see cornfields and sky. I love the midwest and I love the plains, so you will believe me when I say that I am even looking forward to driving across Iowa and Nebraska.

A whole year to live through before we go back again. This time of year, it seems like an endless wait. But somehow it always comes around again.

Monday, July 2, 2012

Phone Blogging from Rhode Island

The kids and I have arrived safely in Rhode Island after an 800-mile drive in which not much happened. We stopped after 500 miles to sleep. The Tiny Tornado has had some kind of developmental upgrade and is perfectly fine to drive with for long periods, except during the same stretch of the afternoon where he gets fussy at home--the time that was, until recently, nap time. One of those transitions.

It's possible, though, that my iPad did not make it safely to RI. Actually, tha'ts not true--we know it made it to RI because someone was watching a movie on it when we arrived at the University of Rhode Island. It just seems to have not made it safely to our dorm room. I checked the car last night without luck but am hoping that when we check again in the light of day it will turn out to have slipped down beside someone's seat. Because I love my iPad. I'm not worried about losing data--I'm backed up in the cloud for the most part, or on the computer at home. But it would not make me happy to have to replace the darn thing just now. And I will have to--I do most of my computing on the iPad.

At least I have my bluetooth keyboard with me, and so I can write on my phone. The Gathering is the kind of place where I will bust if I can't write., because so much is happening all the time.

Expect a dramatic uptick in uncorrected typos, though.

Our dorm room is wonderful. It's roomy and has a pleasant view of the campus. It also has a spiral staircase in it, which leads to another roomy pleasant room upstairs. This is just so nifty that we are all very excited about it.

Word Boy and the Lego Savant are living upstairs. Everyone has their own dresser and desk. The Tiny Tornado built himself a cozy nest for sleeping in the nook under the staircase, but was finally only able to go to sleep last night by crawling into my bed.

A few highlights of our trip before I go take my morning shower:

Word Boy observed that ever since we stayed at a Hampton Inn in Philadelphia, he's been seeing them everywhere. I told him that he is experiencing a common phenomenon, that is called the Baader-Meinhoff Phenomenon, or sometimes the Yellow Volkswagen effect, which is that once you become aware of something you hadn't noticed before--a new word, the Hampton Inn, a yellow volkswagen, you start seeing it everywhere.

Word Boy said that he had experienced this phenomenon other times as well.

Meanwhile, the Tiny Tornado heard us say "phenomenon" a few times, and started going, "ma-na-ma-na," to which we off course ended up replying "doot-do do-do-do."

After a long stretch during which no one had said anything, Word Boy piped up with, "I suddenly have a taste for broccoli. Do you think we could stop for lunch at a place that has broccoli?"

Later, after arriving on campus: "Today was a pretty good day. I never did get any broccoli, though."

And, in case you thought this trip wouldn't be educational: we came out of our motel room yesterday morning to head down to the free continental breakfast, and found a boy about Word Boy's age, who said, "come here and see this."

"This" turned out to be a butterfly with a wingspan of 4 or 5 inches, which was resting quietly on the back of his hand. He told us, "This is an owl butterfly," and explained how the eye spots on its wings can fool predators into thinking it's too big and scary to eat.

I commented that it was the largest butterfly I'd ever seen in the wild. He explained that, although it was indeed large, that it was not an especially large specimen of its kind.

We hung out with him, chatting about butterflies and marveling at this one's beautiful wings and fringed antennae, and tremendously large body, and then he put it back where he had found it, resting in a shady spot, and we all went downstairs to eat.

There really are wonderful things everywhere. Who knew we'd step out the door of a Super 8 in Danville, Pennsylvania, to find a Butterfly Docent waiting for us? I wonder what's going to surprise us today.

Monday, June 25, 2012

This Post Could Cost Me Hundreds of Thousands of Dollars and the Love of My Mother. So Be It.

My mom visited me twice last week, driving over with my dad, who is fixing up my breezeway. She and I sat at my dining room table and yakked up a storm. At some point during her second visit, she said to me, "If any of this turns up on Facebook, you're out of the will."

I choose to interpret that injunction as applying to only the subject we'd been discussing for some time at that point: the disposition of estates, family finances, and my father's life expectancy, which I promise you we had a good reason for discussing beyond "when can we get our hands on his hard-earned loot?"

But the conversation we had two days earlier? I figure that's fair game.

Also, my mother didn't say anything about my blog.

My dad is a man for whom actions speak much louder than words. Indeed, his actions often contradict his words. He complains about my mother's disability, but when it comes to caring for her he is, if not quite tender, then certainly kind and indefatiguable. Over the last decade he has taken over all the cooking and housework, after 50 years in a marriage with such traditional division of labor that my mother even fixed him lunch on Saturdays, something it would never occur to me to do for Raider. When my nephew, Word Boy 2, was born three years ago, my 75-year-old dad even took up diaper-changing so my folks could baby-sit him.

He built my mom a little half-step that he carries in the car to help her get up short unavoidable flights of stairs, like my front stoop. For some reason, this little wooden home-made step warmed my heart. Quintessence of Dad, right there, to jump in and build something to solve a problem.

Anyway, on Wednesday my mom and I sat around for three hours and told family stories. I like re-hearing the stories I heard as a kid, if only because it reassures me that I haven't made stuff up. Or because it lets me correct the misunderstandings and mistakes in my versions.

But sometimes, my mom surprises me by telling a story I haven't heard before, and that happened on Wednesday.

I used to joke, darkly, that I came from a long line of women who didn't want children. The only thing in that line that's not true is the "long" part. I don't know how my maternal great-grandmother, parent of 13, felt about having children. I do know that the family story goes that my grandma, number 13, didn't have a middle name because her parents had flat-out run out of ideas.

My grandma, though, didn't choose to have children. The defining story of her life is that at 17, a senior in high school and on-track to be valedictorian, she fell pregnant and was forced to drop out of school to marry my grandfather. She always regretted school; she was proud of her accomplishments there, and hoped at least to go on to nursing school as so many of her sisters had. She sometimes regretted my grandfather; their marriage was not an easy one, marked by conflict, some of it physical, and it wasn't until their children were grown and gone that they enjoyed some measure of financial stability.

She blamed my aunt for ruining her life, as if my aunt somehow got herself conceived and born, and she had a remarkable capacity for not forgiving. She carried childhood slights to her grave, and apparently never repented of her tendency to blame her children for the disappointments of her life.

She was 17 in 1927; she had three children while she and grandpa were still living with her parents. And here's the new story my mom told me:

Apparently, the road they lived on was a long, straight country road with no stop signs. Cars got moving pretty fast, and when the road ended in a T, it took many drivers by surprise. You could tell how surprised they were by the wreckage of their cars up against a big tree that stood straight ahead and brought them up short if they didn't make the turn onto the cross street.

My grandmother, not very happily married and with three young children, found herself pregnant again, and despaired. She told my mother that she drove down that street, thinking about that tree, and it was a powerful temptation.

"Well," my mother said, "I was her fourth child. Talk about your unwanted children!"

My grandma didn't want that fourth child so strongly that she thought about suicide. My mother, pregnant in 1965, didn't want that baby, either. She wanted an abortion, but she couldn't get one.

My mom told me about grandma and the tree without apprently referencing or remembering my own status as the baby who wouldn't be here if she'd had her druthers. And one direction this writing could go in might be about my mother's and my shared wound, of knowing that we were unwanted children. Or it could turn into a story about how my mother, recognizing her own wound, nonetheless turned around and inflicted the same one on me. I've always thought that the "I wanted an abortion" story was one I could have lived my whole life without hearing, and knowing that she was told her own version of it does make me wonder, just a little, what she was thinking, not keeping that to herself?

(It also lends a delicious irony to her distaste for people on Facebook who don't know when to shut up.)

But I don't see the story that way right now. What it has had me thinking about for days is my grandma, my mom, and me, and how our lives were shaped by the times we lived in.

My grandma became sexually active at 17 in a time when birth control was not only not readily available, but frowned upon for "decent" women. There's a story (there's always a story!) about her turning my grandpa out of her bed unless he bought protection. He drove to a neighboring town to buy condoms, because no decent man would use condoms with his wife.

Well, somebody saw him there. And word got back to my grandma that LJ was cheating on her. Because why else would he be buying condoms? The story goes, my grandma just laughed when she heard that.

I don't know if the condoms failed them, or they didn't use them for long, but my grandma got pregnant three more times after my mom, the unwanted fourth child, was born. One of the babies was a full-term stillbirth, which she birthed at home, all alone. Grandpa had to go to work, and although he had stopped by on his way to tell his sisters my grandma needed them, by the time they got to the house it was all over. My grandma had given birth, stripped the bed, bathed and dressed herself, washed and wrapped her stillborn baby and laid it neatly in a clean shoe box.

Because back then, women like my grandma were tough, strong, matter-of-fact people who did what needed to be done. I wonder how she felt about that baby, buried under a walnut tree somewhere on that farm. Grief, I imagine, and also relief. In what measures? We'll never know.

That's my grandma's story, in her time and place: seven pregnancies she had almost no control over; six children to raise in poverty. Wanted or not, the babies came.

My mom got married 40 years later, in 1957. She was 24 years old and had been living on her own and supporting herself for eight years. She and my dad had their first child, my brother, four years later. Sooner than they'd planned to; they were putting my dad through college and wanted him to graduate first. And they had me not quite four years after that, also at a time not of their choosing.

My mom and dad at least had some option for family planning. In the pre-Roe, pre-Pill days of their early marriage, though, their children also came as they would. Two birth control failures. That my folks wanted at least one child is implicit in the plan to "wait" until after graduation. They didn't get to choose their times, but they were at least able to space their children, to have only one kid under three at a time instead of 2 or 3. And they were able to stop at two.

My mom quit work when my brother was born. She'd been at the phone company since she was sixteen, and was by then a supervisor. She liked her work and was good at it. She has some great stories (of course) about being a telephone operator in a college town in the days when operators had to place long-distance calls for you, and fake collect calls ("Collect call from Miss Blue Shoes") could be placed in the hope that Dad would be clever enough to realize you needed something mailed to you in time for Saturday's dance.

In 1961, women quit work when they "started a family." So that's what my mom did. But she always regretted it, at least a little. She liked her work, and felt competent and appreciated there. She liked her independence. And she did not find being home full-time with her children especially fulfilling.

She was just a bit too early; she just missed a coming revolution. By the time I was in middle school in the mid-70s, the mothers of my friends--most of them a decade or so younger than my mom, who'd had me when she was 32--worked. Our neighbors worked. My mom thought it mattered that there was someone home for us when we got back from school, but the other kids in our neighhorhood got by with a mix of babysitters, unsupervised time, and the careless oversight of slightly older children. And they seemed to be doing fine.

To add insult to injury, it seemed to my mother that my brother and I envied them, that we also wanted the freedom of an empty house and no adult supervision. We didn't, it seemed to her, treasure the mother who waited for us at home. We resented her.

(I say "it seemed to her" because I don't remember feeling that way. But I am perfectly preparted to believe that my behavior was consistent with her interpretation.)

By the time I became sexually active, around 1985, I had easy access to a whole array of birth control options (and my mother, bless her, made damn sure I knew what they were and how important it was to use them). Abortion was an option. And by 1986, I'd stopped having procreative sex--I haven't had to deal with the spectre of unwanted pregnancy for 25 years.

I know that, as a lesbian and then as part of a couple who can't reproduce without medical intervention, I'm an outlyer. I could only have babies I planned for. I know that people still have surprise babies. Word Boy 2 was a late-life bonus for my brother and sister-in-law. My sister-in-law's sister has a daughter who is significantly younger than her other children. "We joked," she told me one time, "that we should name her Daisy. As in, Whoops-a-daisy!"

But even these surprise babies are, at least in some measure, chosen babies. At least for the families I know, who have the knowledge and the resources to exercise their options even in today's climate of attacks on abortion rights.

I had the luxury of actively choosing each of my children, something my mother aspired to and couldn't quite manage, something my grandmother couldn't even imagine.

My point is that I don't think my grandma's story, my mom's story, and my story are just sad personal tales of children who weren't wanted and knew it, of women trapped or constrained by childrearing. My grandma was eight years old when women got the right to vote in federal elections. The first time I voted, I voted for a woman for vice president. We're not just our own stories. We're the story of a whole century of women in America.

Friday, June 15, 2012

Some Reflections on Creating Fragrance-Free Space

In recent years, both the Friends General Conference summer gathering, and the FLGBTQC Midwinter Gathering have been working toward becoming fragrance-free spaces. This is a tricky process; creating fragrance- and chemical-free spaces depend on the individual daily decisions of hundreds or thousands of people. Every time someone washes their hands, gels their hair, applies deodorant, washes their clothes, cleans a mirror, shampoos the lobby rug, paints a wall, applies sunscreen, wears their favorite lipstick, lights a candle, launders the sheets in a conference center, pops the cap off a marker to make notes on newsprint or a white board, or does the lunch-time washing-up, they are faced with a choice about using a product that contains fragrance.

(In this post, I'm going to say "fragrance." But I hope we call all remember that this is a short-hand for actual fragrance and other problematic chemicals that can also trigger headaches, asthma, skin rashes and hives, neurological problems, and other symptoms in the approximately 20% of the population--according to one study I read whose citation I will try to find and insert later--who are sensitive to them. I'm also going to say "fragrance" because that is what these two Quaker conferences have been emphasizing in their ongoing work on these issues.)

This got really long, so I have included headings. It has four parts: The Challenges, which provides some background information; The Strategy, which talks about some of what these organizations have done to create fragrance-free gatherings; The Point: Some New Questions, which you may want to scroll down to if you are familiar with FGC and FLGBTQC conferences; and The Epilogue.

THE CHALLENGES

You can imagine the many challenges involved in trying to create what the FGC Gathering is trying to become: a traveling conference of 1500 or so people, all of whom will make the fragrance-free choice each time.

The first challenge is that many people don't know that they are making a choice about fragrance. It is so ubiquitous in the products we use that it comes to seem a natural part of our environment; the proverbial water the fish are swimming in. Why would people who don't have sensitivities think about this on their own? You'd be astonished if they did. So it's necessary to, first, let people know that there's a problem.

This leads directly to the second challenge: a lot of people--perhaps most people hearing about this for the first time, if my experience is any indication--don't believe there's a problem even once they're told about it. I don't, in general, blame people for this. If they've never known anyone who was affected, they probably have no idea how bad it can be. I have sometimes been tempted to tap someone on the shoulder and say, "Excuse me, I need to leave now, but I wanted to let you know before I go that your decision to wear perfume to this event not only excludes me from it but means that I will probably be sick until next Thursday." But hardly anyone has ever received that shoulder tap, from me or anyone else. So they've never enountered a sufferer in the wild.

Even if they believe there's a problem, and that for some people it can be quite bad, they're inclined to assume that these folks are very rare. The first time I brought up the issue of fragrance at the summer gathering, many years ago, the person I spoke to assumed that I was the only one affected, and that the problem of one person was not sufficient to merit asking 1500 people to change their behavior. In other words, the problem might be real, but it's the job of the sufferers to manage it.

One friend told me that she met a woman at the gathering two years ago who was ranting about the FF policy. She thought it was just another pointless PC thing. My friend told her about me, about how hard gatherings had always been for me, and how much my experience had improved since the FF policy had started to get some traction. The woman was surprised and moved. She'd had no idea this actually mattered to anybody.

I also suspect that many of us progressive types suffer from issue fatigue. We've gotten on board with "Column A: The Essential Social Issues." However imperfectly, we've embraced racial justice; gender equality; the gay and lesbian rights movement; physical accessibility for people who use wheelchairs, scooters, canes, and walkers. In addition, each of us has probably also chosen to prioritize some or all of the "optional" social issues in Column B as well: factory farming, a struggling educational system, the dismantling of voter rights, conditions for workers in overseas factories, animal rights, over-reliance on petroleum fuels, global warming, the environment, the existence of bisexuals, the bottled water industry, invasive species, and whatever else I can't think of off the top of my head.

It can be very frustrating when you try to introduce the fragrance issue to the very people you think will be most open to it, and instead they resist. But I do think that resistance often comes from folks feeling like they have enough on their plate and they don't have the energy to take on one more thing.

I also wonder if some of the resistance might come from a desire not to seem even more like whacked-out troublemakers than we already do. I can imagine--and this is entirely my imagination, not anything I have any knowledge of--but I can imagine the person whose job it is to talk to universities or retreat centers about our needs ranting, "I already have to tell their cafeteria staff that they have to learn to cook vegan food, turn off the ice cream machines at Wednesday's lunch, and get us re-usable cups instead of the paper ones they usually have at the beverage station. And I need to tell the facilities people that we need some of the bathrooms re-designated from Male and Female to Gender-Neutral. Now I'm supposed to tell them, what? That we want them to switch out all the bathroom soap for fragrance-free, and that they can't use their usual cleaning products in the bedrooms? Well, I sure look forward to that conversation!"

Even once people decide they'd like to make some personal changes to help with this problem, there are challenges. They might not know where to find FF products for instance--though this has gotten much easier in recent years. I used to be able to use only Clinique makeup, for instance--$15 for a lipstick!--but a few years ago, when I needed to buy makeup for the first time in years for a choir concert, I was able to get cheap FF lipstick, blush, foundation, eyeshadow, and mascara at my corner Rite Aid.

But people who haven't looked before may not know that somewhere in that wall of shaving cream is one brand whose "extra sensitive" product is fragrance-free, or that Common Brand Of Lotion makes a FF moisturizer you just have to read the fine print to find. It can be disorienting and overwhelming.

People might also be concerned that FF products won't work as well as what they're used to. And that might indeed happen. Sometimes that's a trade-off people should just resign themselves to making (are your perfect hair and blinding-white gym socks really that important?), and sometimes it's a trade-off they can't make. I had some things to say about this previously in a post called The Hierarchy of Harm.

THE STRATEGY

The approach that the FGC Gathering took, beginning a few years ago, and which FLGBTQC has also adopted, is to make the transition easier for people. As well as providing information and a list of fragrance-free products on their website, the FGC Gathering has provided bars of FF soap participants can pick up at registration, and a table of product samples. Somebody on the staff walks around campus, goes into the public bathrooms in every building we're going to use, puts a "please don't use this" sign on the soap dispenser, and leaves a supply of FF liquid soap on the counter.

At the most recent FLGBQTC Midwinter, we arrived to find that the Gathering Committee had not only provided FF products in the public bathrooms, but had stocked each private bathroom with a dispenser of FF soap.

I don't know the rationale that was used when the decision to do this things was made. I've always assumed it was to provide education and support. Perhaps also to make switching to fragrance-free easy enough that people would have no excuse not to do it.

So, that's where we're at. The fragrance-free policies have been, in my experience, very successful at both these conferences. It took a few years, especially at FGC Gathering, for the reality to catch up with our intentions, but the last couple of years have been a transformed experience for me. I think it was only four years ago that I sprinted out of the shower half-rinsed, and down the hall to my room half-naked, because, even though I was on a "fragrance free" floor in the dorm, someone had come in and cracked open the World's Most Toxic Body Wash in the stall next to me. But year before last, I only had a single exposure all week, and that one in a public place where I was able to move away. And last year, much the same. Instead of resigning myself to partial participation, to enjoying myself despite the headache and dizziness, to several days of recovery once I get home, I've simply enjoyed myself.

For this, I thank everyone who worked on this policy, who put out the new soap in the public bathrooms, who was willing to try a new deodorant, who bought FF dryer sheets, who was willing to be educated to be compassionate, to be moved instead of entrenched in their ideas, to put themselves to some small trouble and inconvenience for me and my ilk.

THE POINT: SOME NEW QUESTIONS

Which brings us to the point of this blog post: For how long is it productive to provide this level of support to attenders? When, and how, can responsibility be shifted from the organizers to the community--to the individuals who make up the community?

This came up during a conversation I had with some friends at the FLGBTQC Midwinter Gathering in February. Apparently the organizing committee had discussed this, with regard to providing every attender FF soap in their bathrooms.

It was clear to everyone that providing FF soap in the public bathrooms was the responsibllity of the organizing committee. But it wasn't so clear that providing soap for the private bathrooms was. And it's not clear to me that it is either, or that FGC should continue providing bars of soap at check-in.

Providing toiletries for people's personal use strikes me as problematic for several reasons.

First, it is an extra expense, and extra work, for organizers who have a very long to-do list and a very limited budget. Maybe this is a relatively small concern; after all, these committees take on all kinds of additional tasks when the community decides it matteres enough. If being fragrance-free is important to the community, perhaps the organizers are simply acting to reflect that value.

But--second--I think this extra work reflects the organizers' commitment, but may paper over a lack of clarity in the community. We might end up with a majority of attenders using FF soap in the shower, while only a minority are actually committed to creating a FF conference. Is this a problem, if the goal is, by and large, met? I think it is, for a few reasons.

One is that it can create a false sense that a problem has been solved, and close down conversation and educationi prematurely. Maybe. This is me being hypothetical. Do Quakers ever stop talking about anything? OK, this argument strikes me as a bit weak.

But what message does it send on an individual level? For some people, the FF soap at registration may serve as a reminder that their other products should be FF as well. For others, it may suggest that there's nothing more they need to do. If soap is important enough that the conference provides it for everyone, then is shampoo less important? Deodorant? Lotion? Hair gel?

Is providing soap an effective way to reduce environmenal fragrance at conferences? Honestly, I doubt it. If you asked me, I'd say that soap, which people use in the shower and which doesn't necessarily have a strong residual odor once they're dried and dressed, wouldn't be my first priority. Lotion, which is often strongly perfumed and which people feel comfortable putting on in public, repeatedly, throughout the day, is a much bigger problem for me. Likewise sunscreen and lip balm. If I were asked "What grooming products would make the most difference to you if everyone were to switch to the fragrance-free version?" I'm not sure the soap people use in the shower, or to wash their hands in their own bathroom, would make the top 10.

At the Conference Run By Me In The World Which I Am Also Completely In Charge Of, I probably wouldn't provide folks with soap. But I would search their belongings--especially purses and day packs--for little bottles of stinky lotion, and do a tube-for-tube swap. People whose lotion was already fragrance-free would be eligible for door prizes.

(Public restroom liquid handsoap is also a major offender. Once Raider forgot and washed his hands with the soap in a rest area bathroom when we were on a trip, and I almost left him by the road somewhere in Iowa. When I talk about "soap," I'm not talking about the public restroom soap, which I hope and expect organizers will continue to provide an alternative for. This is a big deal.)

Finally, by providing soap for a number of years in a row, we create an expectation in people that soap will be provided. They start to feel entitled to their free soap. This is a problem, in my view, because it means they aren't pushed to take responsibilty for their own choices. They aren't being asked to actively commit to the fragrance-free policy. They aren't being expected to remember from year to year not only that they'll want to bring a fan for their dorm room, but that they'll need to come ready to bathe and groom themselves with products that aren't harmful to their beloved Friends.

By "they" I mean "we"--in a Quaker context, there is such a fine line between organizer and attender that they are often the same person in different years, or even the same person in the same year. There's no great divide, and I don't mean to imply or create an us-vs-them dichotomy here. I can attest to this sense of entitlement because even I, a person who uses only fragrance-free products for personal grooming and has for years, feel entitled to my bar of FGC soap. I use liquid soap at home, and some years I forget to buy bar soap for the trip. That's OK, I think; I'll take Raider's bar soap. But his bar soap is round and doesn't fit in the rectangular travel soap box. Faced with the impossibility of fitting a round soap into a square box, I shrug and say, "Oh, well. I'll just pick up a bar of soap at registration."

At what point do we expect people to have internalized this community expectation around accessibility, to take full responsibility for doing their part? I want each person to understand that this is their job. And they may not understand that as long as someone else keeps doing it.

THE EPILOGUE

I wrote this for my friend Racy (not her real name. Part of an anagram of her real name. A good part). When we had a short conversation about this issue and she asked if I would write about it, I wasn't sure I had strong feelings either way. Yet I seem to have written myself into some strong feelings. I'm not entirely sure I agree with myself. It's possible that if someone else had promised to wear a black t-shirt if I would write a piece about how important it is for FGC and FLGBTQC to keep providing soap to people, I'd be working myself into a froth about that.

(Ha! Soap...froth. I didn't even do that on purpose. But it makes me sad I never worked "soapbox" in somewhere.)

I don't have time to proof. The children are hungry, I have no idea what I'm going to feed them, the kitchen is a mess, and the laundry needs folding so that we can pack for a short trip we're leaving on in the morning. Very early in the morning. You do me a kindness if you drop me a note about any typos you spot.

Wednesday, June 13, 2012

Some Conversations with My Kids

Warning: Self-Satisfied Mommy Blogging.

1.

The kids and I are walking from the ballfield to our car along a narrow edge of grass beside the parking lot. The Lego Savant's hand bumps mine every time it swings back as I walk.

Me: Are you doing that on purpose?

Lego Savant: Doing what? [He grins mischievously.]

Me: We should have named you Alec. For Smart Alec.

Word Boy: What should you have named me?

Me: Um...

Lego Savant: Brain Boy. Um... The Knower, because you know so much.

Me: The Thinker.

The Tiny Tornado: I am The Thinker, too. Because I am always thinking of things. I always have ideas.

Word Boy: I don't really know so much, it's more like I am always asking questions.

Lego Savant: The Questioner. Curiosity Man!

2.

Word Boy reads in his bunk bed until I get the Tiny Tornado settled, and then I go in to tuck him in. He says, "I like my bunk bed. I like my room." He looks around the room, and then says, "Hey, are the blades on the ceiling fan tilted on purpose, or did something happen to them?"

Me: It's on purpose so they push the air better.

Him: Are all fans like that?

Me: Yeah, pretty much. And propellers.

Him: Huh, I didn't know that. I guess I thought they would just be straight. How did they make them that way? Do they twist?

I inspect the fan: No, the blades themselves are straight, but the things that hold them on are made so that they hold them at an angle.

Him: Ah.

He collects his five special stuffed friends and gathers them into his arms while I climb onto a stool and turn the tangled ball of covers back into a sheet and a blanket. He lies down, all five friends in his arms. I cover him up. He rolls on his side, tugs the blanket up under his chin, and closes his eyes. He gets the same supremely contented look that he has gotten every day of his life when he feels cozy and safe. And then he is asleep.

3.

We are at the park, me and my three kids and a 4-year-old friend ("The Boy With the Beautiful Smile," maybe. Accurate, but too long. I'll have to keep thinking). The Lego Savant is pushing the other three on the tire swing. He gets them really going, then sits beside me on the bench to watch them spin. They are hanging their heads backwards and laughing and laughing.

The Lego Savant: I love making little kids happy.

4. One night, at a Chinese restaurant in Philadelphia, the Lego Savant keeps finding water chestnuts on his plate even though they aren't part of his dish. The Tiny Tornado is sneaking them on there, it turns out, because he knows how much the Lego Savant likes them.

5. That's it. Mostly I just wanted to try out this new blogging software for the iPad.

6. Smug, self-satisfied mommy blogging? Don't say you weren't warned.