Wednesday, August 22, 2012

Boy is a Boy is a Boy

On Friday morning, Raider and I will be meeting with the Tiny Tornado's teacher and principal to talk about his gender status. I have just spent a little time working on my notes for that meeting, and it feels tricky. I know exactly what I want to say, and nothing is negotiable. We're not going in there to have a discussion about "how should we handle this?" We are going in there to make sure they know how we expect it to be handled. But I don't want to sound like an obnoxious lecturer, and I know it's hard for people to listen receptively when it seems like someone is hitting them with something unexpected, and laying down the law. So I am thinking about how to be gentle and at the same time communiciate that these things are firm, and not "suggestions" or "ideas" that we have.

This morning, the Tiny Tornado expressed concern that his name might make people think he is a girl. It's such an unusual name that this doesn't seem to have happened yet, but I share his concern. One of his nicknames is a shortened version of his name that does not sound girly at all, and I suggested that we start calling him that full-time. He loved the idea. I think his timing is good; it will be easiest if he starts school with this name.

My notes for the talk so far:
The Tiny Tornado has exhibited a consistent interest in boy things, clothes, etc, since toddlerhood, and in May asked to be referred to by male pronouns. Since May, he has been living as a boy full-time. Therefore, he is starting Begindergarten as a boy. We are fully supportive of him in this choice, as is his doctor. It is in keeping with current best practices for gender-nonconforming children.
He is concerned that his full name will make people think he is a girl. He has asked to be called "Nickname," which does not have that problem. Nickname should be the name used full-time in class, on papers and anything written. He should be introduced to other children, parents, and staff as Nickname and with exclusively male pronouns. His full name and trans status must not be disclosed to any children or parents, or to staff who do not have access to his records. Staff who do have access to his records should be given this information so that they do not disclose inappropriately by accident.
He will use the boys' restroom.
It would be great if there wasn't a lot of "boy/girl" divisions in the classroom--nametags with flowers vs. firetrucks, lining up by boys and girls, boys vs. girls in a game, and so on. He needs to be supported in his chosen identity and activities like this draw attention to his gender status in a way that can make him uncomfortable.
So far, my plan for making this all sound less like a lecture is to smile a lot, and say, "Do you have any questions? Do you have any experience with this kind of thing? Is there anything you'd like to know? Would you like some links to resources?" That may be the best I can do.

My Three Sons



Monday, August 13, 2012

Someone is Wrong on the Internet

I was browsing my rss feeds this morning over breakfast, just passing the time, and happened upon Lisa Wade's post at Sociological Images, "Gender-Variant Children Continue to Confound", a discussion of the recent excellent New York Times piece, "What's so Bad About a Boy Who Wants to Wear a Dress?" I enjoy Sociological Images, though I sometimes find their analyses a bit reductive. But today I was amazed that Wade could pack so much wrongness into such a short piece, starting with the title. I'm not sure who is "confounded" by gender-variant children. The Times article she linked to, for instance, is full of stories of parents who have come to accept and support their children, despite challenges. Psychologists and doctors who work extensively with gender-variant children have a pretty good understanding of what the various paths that such kids take look like; Raider and I had the chance to hear some such people speak at TransHealth this spring, and they didn't seem confounded at all. Neither did the parents in the parent support group we attended. Neither did the tweens and teens who came and went from the Teen Center, where I volunteered every day.

Sure, they had their questions, their anxieties, their concerns. But nobody was "confounded."

I think Wade is confounded because she is making a common mistake: she thinks it matters why these kids are the way they are. And the only answers she can come up with stem from her view of the way sexism plays out in our culture. This leads her to dismiss children's gender expression as inauthentic. Tomboys don't wear boys' clothes because wearing those clothes is an authentic gender expression, but as a way of "rejecting one’s maturing body" in order to "put off the sexual attention that comes with growing up." She says that male-bodied gender-variant children adopt a "sexualized...adult hyperfeminity," basing this on a photo of three kids dressed up for a fashion show at a camp for trans kids.


To my eye, those kids don't look either especially adult or sexualized. The "heels" she decries on two of the kids' feet are modest; the nail polish on one kid is a playful blue on one hand, pink on the other, and the ring the same child is wearing is a plastic flower. One child has a temporary tattoo; another is wearing one of the rubber bracelets that are all the rage these days. Their skirts are flirty layered skirts like I've seen on a gazillion cisgendered girls. They look like children dressed up, to me.

One of my friends on Facebook pointed out, too, that they are dressed for a fashion show. If I were dressed for a fashion show, I would be more made-up and more "feminized" than I am in my daily life. It's a bad sample Wade is drawing on here, and a wide generalization she's drawing from it.

She assumes, for instance, that this picture represents "their (or their camp counselors') idea of what it means to be a girl." I see two things wrong with that sentence (at least!). First, it reflects her assumption that children don't know their own minds, by bringing in the possiblity of them being dressed not as they prefer, but as an influential adult prefers. And second, she assumes that this picture is both an accurate and complete representation of what they think it "means to be a girl." My partner took a picture of me at a party last Saturday; I was wearing a dress cut so low I had to use double-sided tape to keep the neckline in place. Today I'm wearing a modest cotton sundress. Yesterday I had on pants. In my closet there is a beautiful princess dress for wearing to Renaissance Faires. Which of those outfits defines my idea of what it means to be a woman?

None of them, you say? You win the prize.

Wade should know better--she says, "even most biological girls don't dress/act this way most of the time." But she assumes that these kids do. It's sloppy thinking, driven, I think, by her own ignorance and prejudices.

She should meet more gender-variant kids. TransHealth is a free conference; she should come some time and watch and listen. She would see, yes, tween girls dressed in ways that could arguably be seen as sexualized and too-adult; a friend of mine who is a mother of cisgenderd girls that age calls it "the slut phase," and gender variant girls are not the only ones who go through it. But she might also meet the male-to-female tomboy I had pizza with one night, or the 10-year-old whose gender identity was explicity and firmly "boy" but whose gender expression was profoundly feminine. What was he saying about what it "means" to be a boy or girl? Nothing, I think. His self-expression spoke profoundly about what it meant to be him.

Wade says:

In contrast, girls, when they enact a tomboy role — and now I’m off into speculation-land — don’t seem to go so far into the weeds. We don’t see girls dressing up like lumberjacks or business men in suits and ties. They don’t do tomman, they do tomboy.
I take issue with so much in these three sentences. "Enact a tomboy role"--Wade loves language like this, that says these kids are performing gender rather than experiencing it, or expressing it authentically. These girls "don't seem to go so far into the weeds." So, we assume that the kids in the picture, waiting their turn at the fashion show, are off-track? They've made some kind of mistake? And so do tomboys! Sorry, "girls who enact a tomboy role." They're "in the weeds," too, just not so deeply. How should kids dress and act that wouldn't put them "in the weeds"? If a female-bodied child dresses "like a girl," is she out of the weeds? Or in the weeds in a different way? What can a child do that Wade would see as powerful, authentic, and worth taking seriously? How can any human being have an authentic gender expression in her view, especially if it is explicity "feminine" or "masculine"? Or are we all in the weeds, all the time?

And when she says, "We don't see girls dressing up like lumberjacks or business men in suits and ties," she really means, "I haven't seen this." Little persons whom Wade would call "girls" certainly do. Ok, not lumberjacks--that's a ridiculous example. What child these days has lumberjacks as a possible role model? But male athletes? Sure. Male police officers? Sure. Male superheroes? Sure. I wrote a hasty comment on the SocImages this morning, linking to this old blog post of mine. Scroll to the bottom, I said, to see a picture I flash around way too often: the Tiny Tornado in the vest and tie he insisted we buy him a couple of years ago.

I don't even know where TT found out about suits and ties at age 2 or 3. His dad goes to work every day in a t-shirt and jeans. But, somewhere, he found out about them. And by god, he wanted one. "We" do indeed see "girls" [sic] dressing up like business men, Dr. Wade.

A hint for folks whose theory has outpaced their experience: just because you haven't seen it doesn't mean it doesn't exist. If the only thing you have to offer is a projection of your theory onto the lives of people you know little about, and self-admitted speculation, perhaps take a moment to consider broadening your experience. I am sure that, like most liberals, feminists, and intellectuals, you think of yourself as open-minded. Practice opening your mind to the lived experience of human beings living in their bodies--including children, who can be surprisingly self-aware, knowledgeable about their own experience, and forceful in their demands that they be respected for who they are.

 

Sunday, August 12, 2012

Partying with the Freakiest of the Geeks

Last night, Raider's company, FluidHost, threw its annual open-bar riverboat party for employees. We've been going to this party for enough years now--this, and the super-elegant holiday party they throw in December--that I have friends there that I am always happy to see.

There is a relatively small tech sector here in mid-Michigan, and as a result, Raider and some of his co-workers have been crossing paths for years.The new project manager, for instance, used to work with Raider back at Tiny Internet Provider a decade ago, before it went under. Raider's boss at FluidHost interviewed at TIP at the same time Raider did but didn't get a job; the new project manager was offered a job at FluidHost five years ago, when Raider got hired on, but opted to go to work for the other tech company in town, CodeCrafters, instead. And so on.

So, they were talking about the corporate culture at CodeCrafters versus FluidHost, and the new PM was saying that CodeCrafters was just that little bit more buttoned-down. FluidHost has lots of guys like Raider--fairly ordinary-looking guys who don't stand out as a "type" until you see a bunch of them together and can only tell them apart by subtle variations in facial hair ("Look!" one of the other wives and I said to each other. "They're stroking their beards in exactly the same way! Isn't it adorable?")

But there's also a sizeable contingent of people who would stand out anywhere they went: a nice lesbian with pink hair, some visibly trans people, men with long hair and dramatic beards, people with gauged piercings and dramatic tattoos, goths, sexy fat women in scarlet corsets.

Watching a crowd waiting to embark during one of the boat's stops at the dock, the new project manager said, "You just don't see this diversity at CodeCrafters."

Raider said, "Yes, FluidHost gets the freakiest of the geeks."

The simple explanation is that most of the people who work at FluidHost are not software engineers like Raider and his team. They are tech support, working around the clock on the phone. The kind of job that is perfect for freaky smart people. I love the freaky smart people. I feel at home among them.

Raider and his cohort are much of a type: super-smart but taciturn and introverted, with a dry wit. They read science fiction and relax by playing Red Dead Redemption and Halo 3: ODST. Their passion for their smartphones is almost adulterous. To a man, they are possessed of colorful vivacious wives who do the social heavy-lifting for them. Last night, the other DevTeam wives and I were joking that we are such a stereotyped bunch that it's like there are factories producing us somewhere: one assembly line putting together guys, the final step being to outfit them in relaxed-fit jeans, dirty sneakers, and a t-shirt that says, "There are only 10 types of people in the world: those who understand binary, and those who don't."

On the other assembly line, a line of women who start chattering as soon as their heads are attached. They're dressed in bright pink with sequins, or black skirts chosen for their "twirl factor." It is hard to keep them separated so they can be packaged with their mates; they keep clumping up together to admire each other's shoes, laugh about child-rearing, and make affectionate jokes about the men they love.

By 8:30, the wives are on the dance floor. The husbands do not dance. With one exception, the Young Genius, who takes to the floor for one song with his Beautiful Wife, flinging himself around the floor and twirling her with a dorky abandon that the wives find charming and that causes us to cast hopeful glances at our own gentlemen. The husbands chatter more during this song that they have all evening: "Look at the Young Genius!" they say to each other. "He looks ridiculous! I will never go out there to make a fool of myself like him."

The wives sigh. And when the next song starts, we flood the dance floor again, together. Sometimes we are joined by one or two of the nice lesbians, though the sweet young butch who danced with me last year has, alas, moved on to greener pastures. It is a dance party so completely female that we might be back in high school, having a sleepover. Perhaps later we will give each other facials and try out dramatic new makeup looks.

A song comes on that stops everyone dead. "I don't know this song," the Young Genius's Beautiful Wife says. The others shake their heads and frown; they don't know it either.

Only I am still dancing, bopping around the floor singing, "I always feel like...somebody's watching me. And I got no privacy. Wo-o-o."

They look at me.

I shrug. "It's from when I was in high school."

The Beautiful Wife asks, "When were you in high school?"

I say, "Um, 79 to 83."

She says, "Teach me how to dance to it."

So I try to, explaning that it's all vertical, no butt and hips, all bouncing and arms and little girly kicks. Basically I am trying to teach her Molly Ringwald's moves from The Breakfast Club.

She almost gets it. But the effort nearly kills me. All that bouncing is hard on the knees at 46, and of course, my orthopedic sneakers are like anvils with magna-grip soles. After only a few minutes, I can barely breathe.

I love that she is game to try it. I collapse back at our table to drink a big glass of water and catch my breath, but the Beautiful Wife just keeps dancing.

Some final moments from the evening:

The New Guy's wife tells a story. Apparently, he came home from his interview dejected. "They took me out to lunch," he said, "but I don't think they liked me. Nobody said anything."

She told him, "They liked you. They will hire you because you will fit right in."

She was, of course, right.

And:

We are watching people arrive, and Raider says, "There's so-and-so and his partner." We sat with them at dinner last year. "His partner?" I say. "Are you sure? He introduced him to me as his friend."

Raider looks at me with pity. "Because we look like a middle-aged straight couple."

Me: "Oh, my god! And I fell for it!"

And:

I spend some time with the Life of the Party wife of Raider's Silent But Sexy co-worker. Life of the Party got me to do my first shots ever two Christmas parties ago. It involved pouring the booze through an elaborate tunnel carved in an ice sculpture, and the drink was called a Buttery Nipple.

Anyway, I score some points with Life of the Party by recognizing her Bettie Page tattoo. I am only able to do this (although I of course know who Bettie Page is) because a few minutes earlier Raider had said, "Hey, is that a Bettie Page tattoo on Life of the Party's calf?" but I don't let on. Turns out Life of the Party collects Bettie Page memorabilia. Beautiful Wife and I comment that we would love to see the Bettie Page memorabilia sometime. "I don't know," Life of the Party says. "It's pretty racy."

Beautiful Wife and I are totally up for racy. This, we think, sounds much better than a FluidHost wives tupperware party.

Eventually, Raider and I sneak away. We find a quiet spot along the rail on the second deck; above us, the drunkest partiers are smoking and being raucus; below us, people are at tables, trying to talk above the music. We're snuggled up as close as we can get, Raider's arm around my waist. We watch the riverbank pass slowly by in the twilight. We see ducks, swallows skimming the water, a kingfisher. We share a hard cider, passing the cold bottle back and forth, and chat quietly. Every now and then, we kiss.



Wednesday, August 1, 2012

In the Old Days, We Dreamed About the Old Days



Some of my readers may be old enough to remember the butch/femme renaissance of the mid-90s. Joan Nestle, also one of the founders of the Lesbian Herstory Archives, published The Persistent Desire: A Femme-Butch Reader in 1992. In 1993, Leslie Feinberg published Stone Butch Blues, a memoir about living as a transgendered butch in the pre-Stonewall days (this also was the start of a new awareness of, and debate about, transgender issues in the lesbian community).

Feinberg's lover Minnie Bruce Pratt followed up with S/he, a collection of short pieces about (among other things) her relationship with Feinberg, their exploration of gender and butch/femme, and their shared nostalgia for the days when the police raided gay bars, women had to have on at least three pieces of women's clothing when they did, and there was a back entrance for people to slip out of when the cops pulled up in front. (Pratt mentions the secret exit; Feinberg says smokily, "Only a femme from the old days would know about the secret exit." Then they fall into bed. Again.) The ever-prolific Leslea Newman edited The Femme Mystique a couple of years later.



For awhile there, it seemed like everybody was all heated up about butch/femme. I myself actually began wearing makeup again during this era, and sometimes gave readings in a blue velvet strapless cocktail dress and high heels. This get-up was very effective at attracting exactly the kind of woman I was attracted to: butches in black t-shirts and motorcycle boots, the kind of woman who'd open your car door for you, steer you through the door of the restaurant with one hand in the small of your back, take you home and tell you to take off everything but the shoes. I had one girlfriend who liked to slow-dance with me at the Lesbian Center, whispering a little fantasy in my ear about being in one of those dim old bars. Pehaps, she thought optimistically, she might have gotten into a knife fight over me!


It was a form of cosplay, I think now. Of historical re-enactment. It was a playful erotic fantasy brought out into the light of day. It was also an honoring of our foremothers, women who bravely lived their lives in a time of repression we didn't experience. Each of us hoped we would have been among them, that we might have shown up in some blurry photo Joan Nestle and her colleagues pulled out of the archives, that we would not have spent those decades as obedient daughters, wives, and mothers.

Lesbians at the bar, circa 1950


I've been thinking about those days lately--those long-ago days when we dreamed about long-ago days--because of how I've changed. I was young enough then to think that I was growing into the authentic expression of my sexuality; it never occurred to me then that I could be in a phase. I was a lesbian; not just that, I was a femme lesbian. Not just that, I was a femme lesbian whose attraction to stone butches bordered on being a full-blown fetish. One woman I dated said to me, "I'm afraid I'm just not butch enough for you." I was afraid of that, too. We didn't last long. I had high standards in those days. High, and inflexible.

And then, you know, Raider happened. But I didn't generalize from him. I didn't think, "I like men now!" (This is an interesting contrast to my original coming-out, when I declared myself a Lesbian for Life as soon as I'd kissed my first girl. I was wedded to firmly-bounded identities back then). I figured I was still basically a femme not-lesbian-but-something-kind-of-like-a-lesbian who liked stone butches...and Raider. The very special exception I'd chosen to spend my life with.

I am interested to discover that this isn't as true as I thought it was. In my mid-life renaissance, I am discovering that I am attracted to a lot of people. I have a profound appreciation for women in all shapes and sizes and forms of self-expression; indeed, I've had to force myself to stop complimenting women in my homeschool group on how cute/hot/charming/lovely they look, for fear they'd think I was hitting on them.

I'm also attracted to people on the female-to-male genderqueer spectrum (note: not actually a spectrum per se). If you knew how many of my "stone butch" ex-lovers were now living as men, this would totally not surprise you. But I like the softer ones, too, these days. And strong femmes with a core of steel. And persons born in male bodies who wear beards and skirts and sparkly hairbands. And I spend the occasional week or so enjoying the torment of a hopeless crush on a man I know perfectly well is as gay as a daisy in May.

Back then, though, I was so into my femme self that I wrote an essay about lipstick. Leslea Newman published it The Femme Mystique. Lambda Literary Review gave the book a lukewarm review, but called me and my piece out by name as highlights. I created a file I optimistically called "reviews" (plural!) and put it away in my filing cabinet. At the moment, my heart is broken, because that file apparently doesn't exist anymore. In that drawer, you can find copies of every magazine I published in from 1994-2001 (More than I remembered! Almost none you've heard of!). You can find 20-year-old submission cover letters that really should be recycled, ten copies of a chapbook I published in 1995, and the synopsis for a Star Trek novel I knew I'd never write but couldn't resist outlining because it was as much fun as a day at Disneyland. But you cannot find a copy of what I believe may have been my only published review. You have only my word for it that it was a good one.

But you can judge for yourself. I have braved the deepest cellars of my computer hard drive and brushed the cobwebs off "Lipstick." I have resisted the temptation to re-write it, to tone down the overblown rhetoric a bit. This is the writer I was twenty years ago. This is the woman I was twenty years ago.

Lipstick

I pull my lipstick out of my bag. My lover is across the room. We're separated by music, smoke, crowds of other women. I roll the lipstick up from its tube, spread it, wide and generous, on my lower lip, press my lips together firmly, delicately fill in the arches of my cupid's-bow with the pointed tip. As I re-cap the lipstick and drop it in my bag, I glance at my lover. She gives no overt sign of having noticed my slow touch-up, but her hand rests unobtrusively on her belt buckle. I bend to smooth my stocking at the ankle; from the corner of my eye I see that her fingertips are lightly stroking the inside of her thigh, near where I know the head of her cock is hidden in a fold of her black jeans. This is a part of our lovemaking. It begins in our separate houses with my lace underwear and her crisp white shirt; I can't tell you where it ends.

* * *
 Watching my mother, I learned the right way to get dressed for a party without getting makeup on my nice clothes. After her shower, she left her dress for the evening hanging safely in the closet or on the back of the door until she had finished with hairspray, nail polish, and powder puffs. Of course, she put on her underthings, stockings and slip; it would be indecent to remain naked. She slipped her feet into her pumps, to protect her hose from runs and snags. Her white slip was a pale suggestion of the evening's dress, full or narrow where the dress would be full or narrow, slit up one side or dropping deep down her back. Her arms, shoulders, neck, and face were bare and clean. Her hair lay tight and wet against her head, the comb-lines visible. She stepped into the bright light of the bathroom. Her pumps clicked on the tile, her brushes and compacts of eye color and lip color clicked on the counter as she laid them out. I was breathless as I watched her lift the first jar: she would be beautiful when she left this room.

I learned this ritual from sitting in an easy chair in the corner of my mother’s bedroom and watching her, and I practiced it all through my teen years. In my bathroom, wearing my slip and heels, I curled my hair, running the hot comb or iron through it again and again, rolling the hot curls around my fingers. I loved the feel of the warm ringlets on my neck and shoulders, and then the shiver that ran through me when I pinned the curls up and the cool air hit the back of my neck again. I wore a pink demi-cup underwire bra that lifted my breasts from underneath, as I imagined I might hold them in my hands to offer them to a lover. I dusted their tops with soft beige powder the color of my skin, the inner curves with blush a shade or so darker, to deepen my cleavage. The bra's clasp was in front, between the cups, and when I unsnapped it with two fingers, my breasts fell out abundantly, apples from an overturned bushel basket, loose gems from a velvet bag, tumbling out for my lover to catch. I practiced that movement over and over.

I loved the greasy act of putting makeup on. I pulled all my colors out of the drawer and arranged them before me, opened all the compacts and considered their contents. I was willing to make up, take it all off, and make up again to get it right. I sometimes spent whole evenings trying out new ways to wear eyeshadow, new lipstick colors. From magazines for girls I learned to smooth foundation under my chin, down my neck, around to the back, into my hairline. Its ending had to be a secret; no one should see the line. Powder followed, then blush in two shades: lighter on my cheekbones, darker blush below to create shadows. I brushed on eyeshadow in four stages, and dipped my eyebrow brush in sugar water; once dry, it kept each shiny hair in place. I pulled my lower eyelids down and smeared eyeliner pencil inside, behind the roots of my eyelashes. I was extravagant; I wore lipliner pencil and two lipsticks at a time—the lower lip one shade darker to make it look swollen and pouty, like I’d already been kissing for hours.

Eventually, I discovered department store cosmetics, and stopped buying waxy two-dollar lipsticks at Perry Drug. I threw away my Revlon eyeshadows, and the cheap plastic applicators with sponge-rubber tips that had come with them. In Hudson's Aisles of Beauty, the applicators for the blushes and eyeshadows were bits of soft chamois cloth on smooth wood, or brushes sold separately; some were made from real hair, like artists' brushes, and they were round, flat, angled, beveled. There were tiny brushes for liquid eyeliner, and huge soft brushes for loose powder. Loose powder! That was a revelation. I gladly abandoned pressed powder compacts, with their abrasive puffs and powder that clumped and streaked on my face and neck. Loose powder came in a beautiful wide-mouthed jar. I loved to unscrew its lid, plunge the brush in, tap off the excess, and brush the powder on with a light motion of my wrist, rapid and even, from my forehead to the top of my bra.

The lipsticks at Hudson's were heavy, greasy, meant to stay on for hours without drying, meant to soften and ease the friction of two mouths connecting. I loved those lipsticks. I could spread samples from the testers up the back of my hand nearly to my elbow, studying my skin tone, comparing the colors. Even the powder eyeshadows were moist, clinging to my eyelids like humid air. Cheap cosmetics were stiff and powdery; they flaked if I smiled, if I frowned, if I talked too much. Good makeup was a soft veil; the weight of it pulled my eyelids to sleepy half-mast.

I learned to be sexy from my mother in her slip, leaning toward her mirror with a lipstick in her hand. My mother in her slip turned me on. I wanted to be sexy that way, boldly, my lipstick a challenge and a declaration: yes, I know I'm sexy. I dare you to look at me. I dare you to look away.

Monday, July 30, 2012

Odds & Ends

The mail truck just went by and picked up our outgoing mail. A few pieces of business were in there, and this year's letter to the Tiny Tornado's birthmother. It's a short letter this year; I just told K that TT is doing well and will be starting school this fall, but that there are things going on in our lives right now that make both TT and me uncomfortable sharing details or photos. We don't have a fully-open adoption; these annual letters are our only point of contact. Even so, and although I promised to write again when TT turns six, I feel like I have just closed our adoption.

I would expect to feel some regret at this. Again and again, I have fantasized that K would respond to one of my letters, use the enclosed SASE to write to the Tiny Tornado. That she would send a picture. That there would be more connection between us, not less.

This is primarily a self-serving fantasy, wanting K to signal, "I'm healed! Everything is OK and I'm fine with this now!" Just in case you thought I was thinking of some wish of Tiny Tornado's to know his birth mother, or of some desire K might have to be in touch with her third child. Nope. Mostly I just wanted to be relieved of any residual guilt about K's broken heart.

But, today, I don't feel regret. I only feel tremendous relief, that this year Tiny Tornado decided to live as a boy, giving me an excuse not to write a long, friendly letter to a woman I've never met, a woman who hurt my child and lied to us.

I'm glad not to have to do it.

I told K I'd write again in a year, and that maybe we'd be willing to tell her more about the Tiny Tornado's life. And a year from now, I will write. I will write in good faith. If I can, I will tell her details. If I can, I'll include pictures. But today? I feel like being honest about how much I hate this obligation, and how glad I am to have a year off from it.

The incoming mail included an unexpected compliment. I got a form letter thanking me for working at the summer gathering, but it included a personal post-script from the conference coordinator saying she appreciated my "patience, creativity, and initiative." I have a file of unexpected, sincere compliments I've gotten, to counter the occasional negative voices in my head. This one is going in there.

Leftover notes jotted down during the gathering:

A friend says to me, "That's a really cute water bottle. I don't think I've seen [a Kleen Kanteen] that small before."

Me: Well, it originally came with a sippy cup top, if that tells you anything.

I pick up Word Boy and a friend of his from their gathering in the morning. As we stroll along, they are discussing a dead bird they found and closely examined that morning. They used the word "dissect," but I doubt they really did. Anyway, a friend passing in the other direction overhears and says, "Doesn't the impromptu dissection worry you?"

I say, "Eh, I'm getting used to it."

One of a million things I've decided it's not worth fighting about. Word Boy knows: Do not touch any dead animal with your hands. Be respectful of the dead animal: you may examine it but do not whack it brutally with sticks. If possible move the carcass somewhere it won't be further harrassed. Wash your hands after.

I trust him to follow these guidelines. Beyond that, there's just really no stopping a kid who is so fascinated with bodies and how they fit together.

Speaking of trust, I was thinking of the Tiny Tornado this morning. First, as I was sweeping up dog hair clippings from the living room floor, I was thinking about how much easier life is when I just accept that he's going to do things like trim the mats from the dog's ear hair, draw himself a bubble bath, or (as he did the other day) glue his feet to the floor. I'll live longer if I don't go through the roof when these entirely predictable things happen.

On the other hand, I was musing as I listened to him show a friend how to feed pumpkin seeds to the hamsters, there are things he is entirely trustworthy about. For instance, he is allowed to open the hamster cages and play with the hamsters whenever he wants, because he is always gentle and appropriate with them, and reliable about closing the cage. He can be trusted with animals in general; he is interested in how to care for them, and takes the information he's given to heart. The worst sins he commits against the dogs, for instance, involve dressing them up, and sometimes needing to be reminded that even dogs get done playing with their friends and need to be allowed to have some quiet time.

I popped into an old blog of mine earlier, looking for something, and got sucked into reading about life with the Lego Savant when he was a baby. Here are a few things I found fun:

My first day alone with the baby

A Day in the Life: A log of our day at 8 weeks old

A bad day at the dentist. Lego Savant is 2; I am pregnant with Word Boy

On birthing plans

Word Boy's birth story

And this was just kind of funny. The references to Montana: dear friends' home had just been burned down by an arsonist, and I had flown out to help them during the days after the fire.

I think I'll go do something productive. This day is flying away from me. Fortunately, the Lego Savant and I put a pot roast in the slow cooker this morning, so dinner is taken care of.

Thursday, July 26, 2012

What's Hecuba to Him, or He to Hecuba?

Raider and I have an especially beloved friend; the kids call him Uncle Toots. We have a long history with Toots. Raider and Toots can remember the night they met as college students; they quickly became best friends and, sometimes, lovers. They have so much in common and have been through so much together that we joke that they are the same person; indeed, once when they were young, someone seeing them together at an event did a double-take: this person, knowing them separately, had thought they were one person. (First aside: sometime even I confuse them. One time I said to Raider, "I made a stir-fry for dinner, but I didn't put in any ginger because I know you don't like it." Raider said, "I like ginger. Toots doesn't like ginger.")

I moved to town a few years later and met Toots on our first day working at the same place. We fell in love. I didn't get to know Raider well over the next couple of years, because he was back and forth to North Dakota caring for his parents, but I remember the night I met Raider: he and Toots lived together, and I met Raider when I picked Toots up for our first date. Until Toots and I got an apartment together, there was a room across the hall from his that belonged to Raider; I saw his stuff, I even slept in his bed a time or two, before I got to know him.

Toots and I stopped being lover-lovers after awhile. Two years? I can't remember exactly. But we had this weird inertia--we knew that one of us should move out of the apartment, but somehow we never could bring ourselves to do it. And, after awhile, we found that we had transitioned to a new relationship, something more than friends and other than lovers, although we were still occaionally "lovers" in the technical sense, as were Toots and Raider, once in a blue moon. This was the beginning of our having a relationship there is no name for. (Second aside: I've been re-thinking the expression "break up," because I have had so many relationships with lovers that didn't end, but rather turned into something else. Sometimes that transition is painful; sometimes it's not. But in the long run, it often turns out that nothing was broken.)

Raider's parents died within a few months of each other when he was 25. (Third aside: now that many of my friends and I are beginning to deal with parents who are aging, I have a new sympathy for what it must have been like for him, as an only child, to go through that so young.)

A few months after his mother died, Raider came back to Michigan, to continue work on a library science degree at Michigan. He had a tiny single on North Campus, but during this time of intense grieving, what he needed was to be with his other half, and day after day he would finish classes and drive the hour to our house so he could be with Toots. This is when Raider and I began to know each other; and we got even closer when we decided that it made more sense for him to live with us and commute to school the next semester.

In the years since then, Toots and Raider and I have lived together and apart in a variety of configurations. We all lived together for awhile, then Raider got his own house and Toots lit out for San Francisco. Then Raider and I moved in together. Then some malignant idiot ran a red light and nearly killed Toots, and he came back to Michigan to recuperate while his multiple broken limbs healed. He ended up staying, and we lived together after that for, what, four or five years? Until the Lego Savant was about 18 months old anyway. If Toots comes back to Michigan someday--as he may, to be near his own aging parents, and us--we will most likely live together again.

When the Lego Savant was a toddler, Toots moved to Boston to be with his sweetie, the Crafty Elf. We can tolerate this separation only because we love the Crafty Elf so very much. And we spent some time seriously considering whether we should move to Boston, too.

My point is: What is Toots to us? What are we to Toots? The kids call him Uncle, but we could just as easily have decided to call him Papa Toots; he is the closest thing they have to a third parent. I sometimes tell people that they might think of Toots as the third adult in our nuclear family, even though he lives with the Crafty Elf these days. Toots sometimes tries to convey his relationship with the children by telling people he is their godfather; that works pretty well. Sometimes he takes flack from his family for spending more time with our kids than with his biological nephew; would it help people understand the relationship and accept it if we had decided to call him their stepfather?

I remember one night when I was pregnant with the Lego Savant. I was very sick, as usual. Raider had tucked me into bed early, and he and Toots were next door in Toots' bedroom watching ST:TNG. I lay there listening to them talk and laugh, and I could feel their intimacy and love for one another, and I felt so warmed by it. Their connection gave me tremendous pleasure. It still does.

Recently, Toots was visiting, and we were hanging out in the living room after the kids had gone to bed. I was crocheting in my big chair, and drifted out of the conversation a little bit, listening to them talk, and it occurred to me: in some ways, Raider is closer to Toots than he is to me. In important ways. I am non-optional for Raider. But so is Toots. I miss Toots when we don't see him often enough; Raider feels his absence profoundly much of the time.

This gets me thinking: are we polyamorous with Toots? Neither of us has had a sexual relationship with Toots in a very long time, but why do we so often use sex to define relationships? Heck, you don't need intimate details of my relationship with Raider to guess that, between two terrible pregnancies, a lifetime of chronic pain, extended illness, and the normal pressures of having young children, we have had some long stretches when sex was a happy memory and a longed-for future. If our relationship had to be redefined every time we went a certain number of weeks or months without sex, we'd have been married, unmarried, married, unmarried, married, and unmarried many times over the past 19 years. (Fourth aside: a new euphemism. "Hey, Raider: Will you marry met? Marry me hard!")

The only thing I know for sure is: this is one of the ways that family looks in our lives.






Wednesday, July 25, 2012

You Put Your Whole Self In

The other day, I talked some about polyamory. I honestly forget sometimes that things like that might surprise some people, or make them uncomfortable. I know that a couple of my readers were uncomfortable with that post, and based on my blog stats, I'm guessing I lost some readers (though that could be a coincidence). I was like, "Oh, yeah, right."

I am lucky to have a diverse group of friends, including, through homeschooling and elsewhere, committed Christians of various stripes. It should be no surprise that there are things we don't share easily with each other. I do forget sometimes that when I write on my blog, I am writing both to some faceless audience of people I haven't met, and also to specific friends and loved ones, and that some posts may be very welcome to some friends, and uncomfortable for others.

I've actually been thinking about this kind of a lot since I posted about polyamory. Right now, my own sexuality and sexual history are things I'm interested in, and if I'm interested in something, I usually write about it, to someone, in some venue. Right now, this blog is my venue most of the time.

I write about a lot of things on my blog. Even before my renewed interest in reflection on sexuality and polyamory, I wondered if my blog was too scattered. I write about adoption; parenting; anxiety; race and class; books; Quakerism and faith; my life; people I love. Perhaps I should have several blogs--one about adoption, one about books, one about Quakerism, one for profiles of my beloveds, one about parenting...

The problem is that I don't have enough to say about any one of those things to sustain a blog. Long-time readers may recall that this blog started as a place to think about transracial adoption. Eventually, though, I found that I had said most of what I have to say on that topic, and the blog was quiet for awhile until I started using it as The Blog of All Things. I seem to be a Blog of All Things kind of person, because I don't have one thing I'm interested in. I'm deeply interested in transracial adoption for awhile; then I'm reading up on economics and globalization; then I'm reading a whole bunch of classic sci-fi, or re-watching Firefly. Lately I've been studying up on homebirth and midwifery, because I realized I didn't have an informed opinion on those things, and I was curious. Sometimes I'm interested in several things at once: right now, I'm very interested in reading and talking about gifted kids; kittens; amigurumi; common birds of Michigan; young adult fiction; marriage; flirting; service; homeschooling; gender-nonconforming kids; and religion. Off the top of my head. And that might mean a blog post on one of those things one day, and on another the next day. Or one post that touches on a couple of those things.

They're not neatly compartmentalized for me. Parenting, gender-nonconformance, anxiety, religion, and kittens, for instance, have some obvious connections in my life right now. I can't see it working for me to have a blog that was supposed to be only about one of those things.

Something I thought about yesterday, during my middle-of-the-night drive home from Ann Arbor, was whether, if I want to write about polyamory and sexuality, I should have a special space for that. A separate blog, or a section of this blog that people could choose to go to, or not. But part of what I'm thinking about is my desire to be wholly known, by which I mean to be in places and with people where I can bring my whole self. One of the things I love about FLGBTQC is that it comes so close to that for me--I've said many times, and here I am saying it again, FLGBTQC is the place in my life where people can best honor and hold both my relationship with Raider and my queer identity. I like that. I want and need more places like that in my life.

As Ragen Chastain says, I am the boss of my underpants. I am also the boss of my blog. And I need and want this to be a place where I can write honestly about what matters to me.

It's not my wish to make anyone uncomfortable; it is, indeed, my regret if I do. But at the same time, it's OK with me if people are uncomfortable. It's OK if some people only read my posts on books, or my posts on parenting. It's OK if some people decide not to read my blog at all. Even people I love. Even people who are my friends and want to stay my friends. It's OK, if you're uncomfortable, to say so. I welcome both "I" statements and Good-Faith Questions on any topic. Tell me what you think and feel; that's fine with me. Ask me more; that's fine with me. Choose to spend your time elsewhere; I'm sorry to see you go, but that's fine with me, too, and when I see you at park day or in the grocery store or at a friend's house, I'll still be glad to see you and I hope you'll be glad to see me.

I am a moral person. I am a deeply ethical person. I am religious in a non-trivial way. I think and ponder and reflect and think some more about everything. The decisions I make about my life are shaped by these things. I don't think I've ever made a decision lightly. So, you know, at least, that if I make a decision that seems dangerous, reckless, immoral, wrong-headed, deeply mistaken, risky, or even just head-scratchingly incomprehensible to you, well, it's probably the best-thought-out, most-thoroughly-processed bone-headed move in history. Perhaps that is a consolation.

I might write some more about sexuality and polyamory sometime soon; I have a couple of things percolating in the Grab-Bag. But I won't write explicity about sex here. Just so you know.

In other news, my notebook went missing yesterday just after I wrote about it. It went missing in circumstances that make me hope it will yet turn up--I remember putting it, and my shopping list, into my bag, but when the Tiny Tornado and I got to the store, I opened my bag and they weren't there. Somewhere in the house, we think. Or maybe the car.

I hope it turns up. This is not just a notebook; it's the notebook my friend Janis gave me a pen quiver for. I love perfect, unexpected gifts (like the time my friend Weaver mailed me a fancy tape-flag dispenser! Clearly office supplies are a theme) and I treasure my pen quiver.

In the meantime, Raider gave me a little notebook he picked up at a conference in May, small enough to carry in my bag. And I have a beautiful journal my friend Uncle Toots bought for me at Walden Pond, really too nice for the kind of disposable note-taking I do. And I remind myself that my brain is always generating more thoughts and ideas than I know what to do with, so anything that stays lost is probably not that important; meanwhile, worthwhile things (and some that aren't) find their way to the surface again. I'm already on the second page of notes in the lovely journal.

And so on.